THOUGHTS FOR FREE-THINKERS

9%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Sep 18, 1883

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 38.

Read the full edition

THOUGHTS FOR FREE-THINKERS.

When the so-called free-thinkers reach a sufficient degree of freedom in the exercise of their thinking faculties, we hope they will bestow some thought upon a few facts stated by the Detroit Evening News, of Sept. 3, 1883. In that issue we find a notice of the “National Conference for the furtherance of Free Thought,” held a few days previous in Rochester, N. Y. Of this Conference, Dr. T. L. Brown, of Birmingham, N. Y., was president; and in his opening address he said:—
“A brave thinker or an advanced talker, subjects himself to the creed-bound criticism of such guides to holiness as Joseph Cook and T. De Witt Talmage.”
On this the News remarked: “This is indeed distressing. Revs. Joe and De Witt should be gagged. True, they are in turn subjected to the creed-bursting criticism of Col. Ingersoll, but it makes an obvious difference whether free thinking and free criticising is done inside the church or outside of it.”
Again, the News says: “But this congress has yet a weightier grievance. In the language of the president, ‘Preachers are now about the only persons who wholly disobey the command, ‘Six days only shalt thou labor’; they work the most on the seventh day.’ This is the last theological hair that breaks the atheistic camel’s back. A society of infidels to compel a better observance of the Sabbath on the part of Christians, is now in order, but for some reason the Rochester congress took no steps toward organizing it.”
“President Brown’s theme is, ‘Who are free-thinkers?’ but he fails to answer the question, except inferentially. Although he cannot, or does not, define what a free-thinker is, we are given to understand that it is a very important personage. ‘The free-thinker,’ he says, ‘is worth more to humanity than all the preachers and priests combined.’ As there are over seventy thousand clergymen in the United States, many of them fine fellows, presidents of universities, heads of charitable institutions and the like, the single free-thinker who outweighs them all and twice as many more like them in Europe, must be a man of considerable heft.”
“‘Free-thinkers,’ explains the president, ‘who have analyzed the forms and combinations of the nearest objects and plainly pointed out their relations and rational uses, not only save Christians from real evil, but make it necessary for them to more fully and correctly understand the material and immediate causes of disease and death.’ From this and much more to the same effect; we are left to infer that all important discoveries have been made and all sciences built up exclusively by infidels, while Christians did all they could to prevent it. Possibly if President Brown had been free to think, he would have thought differently, but being restrained of that inestimable privilege, he thinks and talks queerly.”
The News now gets down to solid talk; and it is this portion of its remarks which we especially commend to the reader in general, and the Free-thinker in particular. It continues:—
“As a matter of fact all the great discoveries which have shaped human history or laid the foundations of science have been made by Christians. Columbus, who discovered the new world; Galileo, who discovered the revolution of the earth; Sir Isaac Newton, who discovered gravitation and laid the foundation for the science of physics; Dr. Harvey, discoverer of the circulation of the blood and father of modern surgery; Dr. Priestly, discoverer of oxygen and first great promoter of chemistry; Linnaeus, the founder of the science of botany; Hugh Miller, the expounder of geology, and Louis Agassiz, the great authority in zoology, were all Christians. That oldest and grandest of sciences, astronomy, is illustrated by Copernicus, a pious and humble priest, who determined the revolution of the planets, by Father Secchi, the master of solar physics, and by so long a line of Christian investigators that it has passed into an aphorism, ‘The undevout astronomer is mad.’”
“There have been many free-thinkers, ancient and modern, but we do not now recall one who either found a new country, or founded a new science, or whose name is linked with any great discovery. All this, President Brown, being an educated physician, must know; but, of course, being restrained of his freedom to think, he can hardly be held responsible for his strange perversion of facts.”
“The spirit of President Brown and his fellow-scoffers is expressed in his closing sentence. ‘I think,’ he says, ‘if there is a God, he can save us, if necessary, without careworn and expensive help. I have found it wise and good for me to let them wholly care for themselves.’ How different from this was the spirit of Howard, the prison reformer; of Florence Nightingale, the philanthropist; of Father Gallaudet, founder of the system for instructing the deaf and dumb; and of all the noble men and women whose pious and self-sacrificing devotion to the welfare of others has rendered their names immortal. How different the spirit and creed of Paul, of Loyola, of Xavier, of Vincent de Paul, of John Eliot, of Judson, and of the innumerable Christians who, taking their lives in their hands, carried light and letters into the darkest corners of the earth. Had the narrow and selfish sentiment expressed by President Brown prevailed among the early Christians, whom he affects to despise, the whole face of history would have been changed, and the Rochester congress would have been as impossible as it has been unprofitable. The fact that such a convention should be held and allowed to publicly denounce, with offensive blasphemy, what the great majority of their countrymen reverence, is itself a proof that in this country people are free to think and to say what they please. The pretense of ‘furthering’ that freedom is ridiculous.”