JOSEPH COOK wisely refused to hold a public debate with a noted free-thinker in Australia, for the following tersely expressed reasons: “First, Free-thought, spiritualism, and infidelity in general in America, England, and India, and as far as I know, in Australia, are notoriously connected with schemes for the propagation of immorality. Several of the prominent agitators in support of infidelity and free-thought have been sent to jail for distributing infamous publications through the mails. No decent man can consent to appear on the same platform with the representatives of enterprises that have a debasing effect on the public mind. Secondly, I am not open to challenges of which the evident object is to advertise infidelity. Thirdly, Not an unoccupied nor an unengaged hour is left open to me in Australia. Fourthly, When infidels of any kind issue a book that goes through ten editions in ten years, at a dollar a copy, I will reply to it. I have a right to offer this challenge, for several of the volumes of ‘the Boston Monday Lectures’ have gone through ten editions in five years. Fifthly, Infidels can put their written inquiries, if they choose, into the box at my free question-box lectures.”—Sel.