BY N. J. BOWERS.
PRIMARY THOUGHTS.
1. If there be a divine Ruler, there must be a divine rule, or law; if a divine law, a divine administration of law, or a divine government; if there be a divine government, there must be rewards and penalties annexed to the law upon which such government rests and is administered. This government must be supreme. “It ruleth over all,” and all are its subjects.
2. The Design of Government.—The honor of the Author of the government, and the well-being of the governed. We speak here only of the latter. This design must contemplate laws regulating human conduct, rewards, and protection to the obedient, punishments to the disobedient.
3. The government’s laws must have annexed to them penalties for their infraction.
4. The design of penalties or punishments,—
a. For the common good of the governed.
b. To maintain the respect and authority of the government.
Special Objects,—
a. Disciplinary, for the good of the subject.
b. Cautionary, preventive, to warn.
c. Protective, guarding life and rights.
d. Authoritative, maintaining and enforcing authority.
5. Justice.—An indispensable element in all governmental administration. No good government can exist without it. Justice is defined as “the giving to every one his due.”
Just.—“Appropriate or suitable.”—Webster.
6. Justice may be wrongly dispensed or thwarted by,—
1st. Showing favor to the bad, and oppressing and punishing the good.
2d. Proceeding equally against all classes, not discriminating.
3d. Transcending its proper bounds, going beyond its jurisdiction.
The administration may go too far as well as come short. It may do too much as well as too little. The government may become tyrannical and unjustly severe, and thus inflict upon its disobedient subject more than his due of punishment, or that which is not “appropriate or suitable.”
As we have said, the laws must prescribe the penalty. If the administration does not reflect the law, it is unjust and should not stand; and so the law itself must be just. Justice should be tempered with mercy, and should not be driven over its farther extreme by imperious will and hate. Justice should always take mercy along with it. Mercy should not rule at the expense of justice, nor justice to the exclusion of mercy. They should be an indissoluble firm in the administration of government.
7. Justice is rightly dispensed or administered when it is done according to law as intimated, which should be according to merit, to deserving, according to the manner in which the subject treated the laws under which he lived and the authority that protected him, according to the attitude he sustained to the government.
He who finds fault with the government, who says hard things about it, who talks rebellion and seeks to stir up rebellious feelings, who talks and acts treason, should be dealt with accordingly, and not as a peaceable and loyal subject.
8. The principles of justice underlie and permeate the administration of the divine government.
9. Doctrines of Divine Punishment.—Four general views are held concerning punishment inflicted for violation of the divine law,—
1st. All received in this life, during probationary time.
2d. Partly future, but will end. Restoration.
3d. Eternal sufferings. Endless life in misery.
4th. Death. Destruction of life and being.
How shall we determine which is the correct view? How shall we know which of these theories accords with truth and divine justice? By what means, or by what standard, shall we try them? Ans.—By the divine law and inspired testimony.
1. That punishment due to sin is not received in this life is evident from Eccl. 8:14; Ps. 73:3–7; 2 Cor. 5:10; Rev. 20:12–15. Neither is this punishment according to law. Eze. 18:4, 20, 24; Rom. 6:23.
2. Restoration.—No change of character or condition. Rev. 22:11; Luke 16:26; 2 Thess. 1:9. Probation closed. All cases decided. No repentance. Also illegal. Not according to the terms of the law. See Rom. 6:21–23.
3. Eternal pain, miserable existence, illegal, and so unjust.
4. The law says death and not life.
a. That view which maintains death to be the penalty of the divine law is alone reasonable and scriptural. See 1 John 3:4; Rom. 6:23; Eze. 18:24, 27, 32; John 8:51; 11:26; Rom. 8:13; Rev. 21:8. Sin of itself brings death, Jas. 1:15. Then there is no eternal sin. It will come to an end. There are no post mortem sins. 2 Cor. 5:10. The sinner is not punished forever for the sins he commits in hell. The affirmation of this is an invention to meet a long-felt want. It assumes that the sinner must forever sin that God may be just in forever tormenting him. So the assumption of eternal torment is built upon the other assumption of eternal sin. Assumption upon assumption, and presumption, we fear, under all.
b. God abhors sin, and will not suffer its eternal continuance in his sight.
c. All intelligences will eventually join in ascriptions of praise to God and the Son. Rev. 5:13. Consequently there is no place for an eternal hell in all the dominions of the Father.
d. The dwelling-place of the wicked will come to naught. Job 8:22; Ps. 37:10. The mercy of God follows the sinner through life, holds out to him with gentle hand and winning voice the gracious conditions of the gospel, and is at last seen in his destruction,—in a release from a miserable existence beyond the tomb.
e. The justice of God cannot allow the persistently rebellious, the scornful despiser of his government, to share equally with the loving, the loyal, and the obedient in the blessings in store for those in harmony with the administration, and so the executive power cuts them off, and maintains the survival of the fittest. This is right. This is just; and all must see it. The government has kept its word, and preserved its dignity, honor, and authority. A government cannot say one thing and do another. It must be true.
10. Universal salvation would be unjust, because the law makes provision for the obedient only. Those not in harmony with divine authority must either become obedient or suffer the penalty of sin—death.
11. Eternal suffering is equally unjust, because contrary to the law. It commands death, not life. A human law would not be fulfilled if a criminal condemned by it to be hanged till dead, were incarcerated in the penitentiary for life.
Lastly, there can be no mercy displayed in everlasting pains, as in this kind of punishment, and it must not be inflicted.
Concordia, Kan.