ANNIHILATION OF THE WICKED

20%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jul 3, 1883

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 27.

Read the full edition

ANNIHILATION OF THE WICKED.

The Baltimore American in reviewing the theological opinion which Rev. Dr. McKim is said to entertain, says:—
“There was a time when the holders of opinions like these would be speedily called to answer a charge of heresy before an ecclesiastical court; but of late years there is a remarkable indisposition to go into the questions that must necessarily be discussed in a trial for heresy. Freedom of opinion is the temper of the times, and the enforcement of dogma through the discipline of excommunication is outside the range of popular sympathies. But it is to be noted that what are called heresies are usually efforts to bring about more rational conceptions of religion.
“The Christian idea during the first and second centuries was that man in his natural state dies, but that Christ offers to believers second life. When Paul first spoke to the Greeks of an after life, they ‘mocked.’ The Sadducees denied the resurrection; there was no direct promise of immortality in the law or the prophets. Death meant death, and it was not until long after the crucifixion that death came to mean ‘endless torment.’ When it was written, ‘The wages of sin is death, but the gift of God is eternal life,’ those words were accepted in their natural sense. The people of that time did not believe that they meant, ‘the wages of sin is eternal punishment.’ They regarded eternal life not a possession of the good and bad alike, but only as the gift of God to the righteous. All through the New Testament this may be read more or less distinctly. It may be true that there are other passages which convey a contrary meaning, and upon which the awful dogma of eternal punishment is founded; but there are theologians who hold that under a better translation these passages would be modified, and that it is quite possible to believe that the ‘fire’ may be eternal, and not the people who are cast into it. The ‘worm’ may never die, but the lost ones may. Eternal punishment does not necessarily mean eternal torment. If immortal joy awaits the righteous, then annihilation would be eternal punishment, but not eternal torture.
“If this be the doctrine which Dr. McKim holds, he does not hold it alone. He has had a long line of predecessors and many thousands of contemporaries in this belief. It dispenses with the hell that Dante depicted,—the hell that is sinking out of belief, along with diabolical possession, witchcraft, and all the rest of the demon lore. . . . ‘I am the resurrection and the life, and he that believeth on me, though he were dead, yet shall he live.’ ‘He that hath the Son hath life.’ ‘He that hath not the Son hath not life.’ ‘God so loved the world that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him, should not perish, but have everlasting life.’ To those Greeks who had no hope of an after life except the dreary shades of hades,—to those Greek Hebrews who had no hope of an immortality,—these assurances of Christianity came as the sweetest of messages. They expected death as the end-all, and when came to them the beautiful hope of an endless life and a fadeless youth in the ‘kingdom of Heaven,’ they clung passionately to the hope. They rejoiced in the hope of immortal bliss for themselves without the dark misgivings of an immortality of torture. The gospel then was, indeed, glad tidings. But was it good tidings when the idea of eternal hell gradually took form and hardened into dogma? Is it glad tidings to be told that many are called and few are chosen, and that all who are not chosen, though our dearest ones on earth, are to suffer to all eternity tortures that no mind can conceive? Compare first and second century Christianity, when love and hope were the bonds of union, when martyrdom and torture were joyously encountered, with that of the sixth and seventh and eighth centuries, when fear of hell was the great fact. Nothing can exceed the gloom and horror of the religion of these centuries—the Dark Ages. Dante and Milton and Bunyan show how long this shudder lasted. But it is passing away now. If the dogma of hell and endless torture be rejected on Biblical grounds, so much the better, but it is sinking out of belief, come what may.”