BY ELD. D. H. LAMSON.
The last paper, and, perhaps, the most significant that was presented at the National Reform Convention, Cleveland, Ohio, was by the Rev. Dr. Scoville, D. D., LL. D., president of Wooster College, Wooster, Ohio, formerly of Pittsburg, Penn. His subject was “The Liberty of Conscience.” The man is a gentleman and a scholar, and far above the average in culture and erudition. The subject was most ably handled, and were it not for the same spurious reasoning indulged in by other speakers, it might have passed unnoticed.
It is but just to say, that these men, some of them, perhaps all of them, from Pres. Brunot down, think they will, and that they do, honor God by the action they propose to take. Pres. Brunot publicly said in reference to the Sabbath Sentinel, of which 3000 copies were circulated at the Convention and in the city, that, though the heading was in harmony with the objects of the National Reform movement, it nevertheless contained many positive and intended misstatements.p. 67
It may be that the generation to which Mr. Brunot belongs (he is apparently an octogenarian) and, possibly, the people with whom he now associates in convention, have no ulterior designs on the lives and liberty of dissenters from their views. None, it seems to me, however, can fail to see that their disclaimer against the idea of the uniting of church and State, is entirely overthrown by the utterances of this, and other conventions. The statement quoted in a former paper, that “we do not desire the union of church and State, but a union of the State and religion,” may not be the beast itself, but it will not come far short of an image to the beast.
It is said of the monkey that was made aware of the sharpness of the claws of the cat, that he carefully pulled out by the roots every one. The framers of the Declaration of Independence and of the preamble and body of our National Constitution had known in their own persons, or in their immediate ancestry, the horror of the bondage of a State religion. They had fled to the wilderness of earth; that they “might found a church without a pope and a State without a king;” so they carefully kept out all that might be construed as favoring any form of religion or class legislation. It is not, as was iterated and reiterated in the Cleveland Convention, a declaration of rights, and a constitution that favors no religion; but one that favors and tolerates all that has for its basis a true morality. And what our fathers have reared as barriers and guardians to the liberty of conscience, this party, whether they know it or not, seek to overthrow. The ministers and people of our denomination have noticed the intolerant spirit in the clergy that are esteemed evangelical, and in the sectarian bigotry of individuals and churches, too long to be deceived. “The words of his mouth were smoother than butter, but war was in his heart; his words were softer than oil, yet were they drawn swords.” Ps. 55: 21.
The Rev. Dr. Scoville says, “Restraining the liberty of some is only benefiting the many.” “Liberty of action is only limited by morality.” “We impose no arbitrary rules on any, only the greatest good to the greatest number.” “Men are not to do as I like, or as they will, but as God will.” The doctrine of “the greatest good to the greatest number” is often against God and human rights; it is only another form of words to say that “might makes right.” King George and the holy inquisition tried that.
To the denial of Mr. Abbott of the Index, that one day in seven was any day that the government might determine, it was said, The minority is not too large to be coerced when outvoted. “If it be a moral question, then look out.”
We can get a pretty good idea of Mr. Scoville’s view of hell; for he says, “In hell the government is liberal and free,” and that “we are not going to have the infernal set up here for a long time yet.” To save themselves from such a condition they will “limit the liberty of the individual by authoritative morality,” and by “moral education enforced by moral legislation.” “There can, in the nineteenth century, be but one standard and that the Christian.” The Christian standard says that the first day of the week is the Sabbath. Then what shall we do who observe another day? As the Independent has said, “It is unfortunate to be in the minority.” We shall “either have to move or be moved.”
In speaking directly on the Sunday law of Pennsylvania, Mr. Scoville said, “It is in harmony with true personal liberty.” It is easy enough to get the view of this Convention on the Sabbath question; and such interpretation so directly offered to the plain letter of the fourth commandment cannot be overlooked on our part. In quoting from Robespierre’s Modifications of Rights, he says, “This is the true consensus,” and yet Robespierre’s hands were dyed in human gore. It may be that as Robespierre kindled a fire which took his own blood to quench, so this Reform Party may mingle their own in that sea that reaches to the horse’s bridles, when God himself is judge. The writer of these articles feels as Paul did when he arrived at Appii Forum; he thanked God and took courage. And although the remarks of the learned Doctor were greeted at the close with long applause, our own joy was more quiet, but no less rapturous, as we saw our hopes in prospect of speedy fulfillment. Though we be “but as grasshoppers in their sight, and they be as grasshoppers for multitude,” yet we are abundantly able to go up and possess the land. But let us awake, for our enemies are already in the field; their hosts are already marshalling for the fray. The din of conflict will soon be heard; and the shout of victory will at last be borne from Mount Zion, the city of the living God, by those who have “gotten the victory over the beast and over his mark and over the number of his name.”
“Hoist every sail to catch the gale; Each brother ply his oar: The night begins to wear away; We soon shall reach the shore.”