AdventAI

THE MILLENNIUM.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 61, No. 13., March 25, 1884

The word “millennium,” from the Latin, mille, a thousand, and annus, year, signifies “a thousand years.” The scripture which sets apart a thousand years for a special purpose, from which the name and the doctrine which the name represents, have come, is Rev. 20:4: “And I saw thrones, and they sat upon them, and judgment was given unto them; . . . and they lived and reigned with Christ a thousand years.” Verse 5: “But the rest of the dead lived not again until the thousand years were finished.” Verse 7: “And when the thousand years are expired, Satan shall be loosed out of his prison.”

It denotes a blessed season sometime to transpire, when Satan shall be bound, and the people of God enjoy a thousand years of happy triumph. It would seem at first glance from the reading of the Scriptures that no such period could occur before the second coming of Christ, but must consequently be located after that event. For sixteen hundred years this was the view which prevailed in the church. It remained for Daniel Whitby, of England, about two hundred years ago, to introduce another view by which the first has been largely supplanted. From him has come the modern doctrine known as the “temporal millennium,” which locates the thousand years before the coming of Christ, and claims that the millennial prophecy is to be fulfilled by the conversion of all the world, and the universal prevalence of righteousness and peace before the end. And so general has this view become that Webster in defining the word “millennium,” says that it is “a word used to denote the thousand years mentioned in the twentieth chapter of Revelation, during which Satan will be bound, and holiness become triumphant throughout the world.”

To express the different views of Christendom on this great question, two words have come into use—“premillennialist” to designate those who believe that Christ’s coming takes place before the millennium; and “postmillennialist” as expressive of the faith of those who, with Whitby and his school, place that coming after the millennium.

The general fallacy on which the postmillennial view rests, consists in taking those scriptures which apply to the introduction of the future eternal state, or to the time when that condition is fully established, and applying them within the present dispensation. The principal texts thus perverted are the following:—

1. Ps. 2:8, which is claimed to mean the conversion of the world; whereas the very next verse shows that the destruction, not the conversion, of the heathen and wicked, is intended.

2. Dan. 2:34, 35, which is strangely supposed to mean the absorption of all the kingdoms of the world, by conversion, into the kingdom of God, represented by the stone which became a mountain and filled the whole earth; whereas the prophecy declares that these kingdoms are first dashed in pieces, ground to powder, and blown away like the chaff, before the stone kingdom fills the earth. In the parallel prophecy, Dan. 7:11, 27, the fourth and last beast is destroyed and given to the burning flame, not converted, before the saints take the kingdom. Thus, according to the parable of Matt. 13:41, all things that offend and do iniquity, are gathered out before the righteous shine forth therein as the sun. And these offenders which are thus gathered out and burned, not converted, are the tares which represent persons.

3. Isa. 66:8. But this text refers to the resurrection, not to the work of the gospel in conversion.

4. Rev. 11:15, 18. These texts refer to Christ’s future kingdom of glory, not to a kingdom of grace, augmented by conversions in this world.

5. Jer. 31:34. This scripture does not describe any condition of things to be reached in this world, but sets forth the result of the workings of the new covenant, which will at last bring all those who avail themselves of its provisions, to a knowledge of the Lord, and the enjoyment of his presence. It applies to a time when there is no more a remembrance of sin, which is after the Judgment has taken place, and sins have been put away, and the people of God are saved in his kingdom.

6. Num. 14:21; Hab. 2:14. These scriptures will be fulfilled when the earth is made new and filled with righteous beings only. 2 Pet. 3:13. They cannot be fulfilled before. It is altogether a perversion to apply them to the world in its state of probation, during all which time the greater proportion of men will continue in sin.

7. Isa. 11:9. This will also be fulfilled in the new earth. It cannot be realized before; for till that time the presence of sin and sinners and the effects of the curse, do “hurt” and “destroy.”

8. Isa. 65:17–25. This is a prophecy of the new heavens and new earth which God will create. It is by giving such prophecies as this a mystical interpretation, and ignoring the future literal new earth, that men are led to the perversions of the scriptures already noticed. For let such a future glorious condition of this earth be once granted, and these texts as naturally apply themselves to that condition, as the glove slips upon the hand. But Peter settles forever the question of the application of Isa. 65:17. He says (2 Pet. 3:5–7) that the present heavens and earth are to be destroyed by fire as the antediluvian world was destroyed by water. But beyond the fiery ordeal which shall melt the elements of this world, he says (verse 13) that we are to look for a new heaven and new earth, according to his promise. This is of course to be as literal as the present earth; and the only promise of it expressed in these terms is the prophecy of Isa. 65:17. It consequently applies to the re-genesis of this world after the coming of Christ, not to its conversion before.

9. Isa. 2:1–4, and Micah. 4:1–5, are considered strong testimony in favor of the temporal-millennium view; and indeed they would be if they were the words of the Lord; but a careful observer will see that they are a record not of what God says, but simply of what “many people” shall say in the last days. And in the preaching of a temporal millennium we see a striking fulfillment; for many people have adopted this deceptive view, and are saying that a time of righteousness and peace is coming in which swords and spears shall be beaten into plowshares and pruning hooks, and nations shall learn war no more. But the Lord speaks in a very different strain when he describes what shall be in the last days. By the prophet Joel (3:9, 10) he says, “Prepare war, wake up the mighty men, let all the men of war draw near. Let them come up; beat your plowshares into swords, and your pruning-hooks into spears.” Then follows a call to the heathen to assemble at the valley of Jehoshaphat, the valley of concision (cutting off), when the day of the Lord is near. This is just the opposite of what man says will be the characteristic of the last days. But God is right and man is wrong.

We now call the attention of the reader to a class of texts which show that such a condition of things as the temporal-millennium view contemplates is impossible before this dispensation shall close.

1. Dan. 7:21, 22. The little horn of Daniel’s fourth beast, symbolizing the papacy, is to prevail till the Judgment sits.

2. 2 Thess. 2:1–7, declares the same thing. The “man of sin,” “that wicked,” the “son of perdition” is consumed and destroyed only by the spirit of Christ’s mouth and the brightness of his coming. No millennium, certainly, while that vicegerent of hell strides in triumph through Christendom.

3. Matt. 13:24–30. This parable of the wheat and the tares, declares that the tares, the wicked, shall grow together with the wheat, the righteous, till the harvest, which is the end of the world.

4. 2 Tim. 3:12, 13, declares that evil men and seducers shall wax worse and worse, deceiving and being deceived, and that those who will live godly in Christ Jesus shall suffer persecution. There is no room for a period of a thousand years during which this rule shall be suspended, and the tendency be in the opposite direction.

4. 2 Pet. 3:3. This text declares that just before the coming of Christ scoffers arise, walking after their own lusts, and saying, Where is the promise of his coming? This would be a strange condition of things to close a thousand years of truth and holiness, as would be the case, if such a period just precedes the coming of Christ.

6. Luke 17:26–30. This, with parallel texts in the other gospels, compares the last days to the days of Noah, when the wickedness of man was great, and every imagination of the thoughts of his heart was only evil continually, and violence filled the earth, and but few were saved.

7. Matt. 7:13, 14. In this text our Lord himself declares that the way to life is narrow and but few find it, while the way that leadeth to destruction is broad, and many go in thereat.

All this, to adapt it to the temporal-millennium view, would have to be reversed, so that for a thousand years it should read, “the way to life is so broad that no one can help going in thereat, while the way to destruction is so narrow that nobody can find it.”

8. 2 Tim. 3:1–5. Here we have a catalogue of eighteen heinous sins which are to prevail in the last days. And the surprising part of it is that these are found in their greatest virulence among those who have “a form of godliness,” or profess the religion of Jesus Christ. Does the universal reign of righteousness for a thousand years have such an effect as to lead even the church itself at last into apostasy? It is impossible either to locate or explain these scriptures on the supposition of a temporal millennium.

There is another text, aside from Isaiah and Micah, which is emphatically fulfilled by this modern doctrine. In 1 Thess. 5:3, Paul says that “when they shall say Peace and safety, then sudden destruction cometh upon them, and they shall not escape.” If the doctrine of a temporal millennium is not this delusive peace and safety cry, what could fulfill it? It lulls men into a feeling of carnal security; it banishes from the mind all thoughts of an impending Judgment; and when one would be aroused by the solemn announcement of the Lord at hand, it lays the conscience to rest by the soothing opiate that a thousand years of universal righteousness must intervene before the Lord appears. Upon such the coming of the Lord, can but be, as Paul says, as a thief. But he adds, “Ye, brethren, are not in darkness that that day should overtake you as a thief.”

According to Rev. 20:1–6, the thousand years begin with the coming of Christ, the resurrection of the righteous dead, and the thrusting of Satan, bound, into the bottomless pit. They close with the resurrection of the wicked dead, the loosing of Satan, and the utter extinction of the whole godless host as they come up around the camp of the saints, the New Jerusalem, which has then comep. 201 down from God out of heaven. Verses 7–15. They begin with the convulsions of the last day, when the earth shall reel to and fro like a drunkard, and be utterly broken down (Isa. 24:19, 20), and the mightiest earthquake nature has ever known shall rend it from circumference to center (Rev. 16:18), and every island shall flee away and the mountains not be found. Verse 20. The earth is thus reduced to its original chaotic condition (Jer. 4:23), and by this change becomes “the bottomless pit,” the abyss, ἄβυσσος, the same word that is rendered “deep” in Gen. 1:2. And inasmuch as Satan is not loosed till the end of the thousand years, it follows that the earth remains in this condition during all that time.

Meanwhile, the saints, caught up to meet the Lord in the air when he comes (1 Thess. 4:17), are taken to the Father’s house (John 14:2, 3), the New Jerusalem (Gal. 4:26), where they reign with Christ a thousand years (Rev. 20:4), and at the end of that time descend with the city to this earth. Rev. 21:2. That the saints do go to heaven and spend a season there before their final location upon the new earth, see Rev. 15:2; 4:1, 6; 19:1.

In the scriptural doctrine of the millennium we rejoice; and upon its glories we hope soon to enter. Then our eyes shall feast upon the splendors of the city of God, our ears listen entranced to the songs of the redeemed, and our hearts thrill with joy unutterable as we look upon the face of our Redeemer, in whose presence there is “fullness of joy,” and at whose “right hand there are pleasures forevermore.”