INQUIRER.—I have been reading the arguments of some who oppose the keeping of the seventh day as the Sabbath; and it has awakened in me a strong desire to learn what can be said in its favor; and knowing that you observe the seventh day, and presuming that you would not follow a practice so at variance with general custom without what seemed to you the very clearest reasons, I thought I would like to know those reasons if you are willing to give them.
SABBATH-KEEPER.—With pleasure. Nothing suits us better than to meet the honest inquirer. We only wish that people would more generally seek for truth not only in regard to our practice, but also to their own. Too many drift along with custom, doing as others do, without stopping to learn for themselves whether or not God has ever required it at their hands. What you wish, I suppose, is a “Thus saith the Lord,” if we have one to give, in behalf of the observance of the seventh day?
I.—Yes. I have noticed that those who oppose the seventh day and argue for the first-day Sabbath, or for no Sabbath, do not have any uniform line of argument to present. One tries to establish his point in one way, another in another. They do not seem to have any direct testimony of the Scriptures to which to appeal, but reach their conclusions by a long process of reasoning; and I have wondered if you would be obliged to do the same in behalf of the seventh day.
S.—Emphatically, no! and this is one of the most decisive tests by which to judge between truth and error. Every true theory can be read in direct terms from the Scriptures. Especially is this true of moral duties. How preposterous the idea that God should so fail to express his will that men must build up a series of premises by inferring this and assuming that, and by a long process of reasoning draw out a conclusion, before they would know their duty! Whoever proceeds in this way gives prima facie evidence that he is trying to bolster up simply a man-made institution. Now in regard to the Sabbath our position is a very simple one, and expressed in a few words. We keep the Sabbath because God has explicitly commanded us to do so, telling us what day the Sabbath is, and how to keep it. Here are his words with which every Bible reader is familiar: “Remember the Sabbath day to keep it holy. Six days shalt thou labor and do all thy work, but the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God, in it thou shalt not do any work,” etc. Ex. 20: 8–11. You know it is a principle of logic that a law once enacted is presumed to be still binding unless it was subject to limitations or has been expressly repealed. Here is a law which once a voice from heaven proclaimed to men in tones that shook the whole earth. We find in it no limitation as to people, or place, or time; and we do not find that it has ever been repealed. Therefore we regard it as still binding.
I.—But what difference does it make which day we keep?
S.—What difference does it make whether we keep any day or not? Is it not because God has told us to keep a day, and to refuse is to disobey his command. So far as it pertains to what we shall answer at his bar in the Judgment, we might just as well keep no day as not to keep the day which he has specified. Aside from the promptings of the carnal mind, it is just as easy to keep the day which God has named as any other; and despite the carnal mind, men would do better to keep it. They will find it so in the Judgment.
I.—But I have heard ministers assert that it is not the seventh day of the week, we are commanded to keep, because the word “week” is not in the commandment.
S.—Pray, then, what is it the seventh day of? Is it of the month? the season? the year? a lunation? or a solar cycle? It is a serious thing to quibble over a command of the great Jehovah. If it is not the seventh day of the week, how do these men know that the day of rest comes every week? No one could tell. Here is a command enjoining rest on the seventh day. This rest, divines tell us, must come every week; yet in the same breath they affirm that it is not the seventh day of the weekly cycle! It may be any day of this cycle. Any day, then, is the seventh day. If this is so, it follows that every day is the seventh day; for seven different persons might each keep a different day of the week, and each would, according to this theory, be keeping the seventh day according to the commandment. Hence we are asked to believe that here is a weekly cycle composed of seven seventh days, and nothing else! Do you believe the commandment contemplates any such thing? If any one should treat the enactments of an earthly tribunal in this manner, he would be fined for contempt of court, or sent to a home for imbeciles. But further, when the law-making power construes the law, that is held to settle forever its meaning. Now in case of the Sabbath, the Law-giver construed the law, and showed just what he meant by the seventh day. To the Hebrews, who were for the time being the depositaries of his law, he pointed out for forty years by withholding the manna on each seventh day, the very day he intended in the commandment; and lo! it was the seventh day of the Jewish week. That week suffered no change down to the time of Christ; and from the latter point to the present, the Jewish week has synchronized exactly with the Christian.
I.—Well, the commandment certainly is plain as to the day; and I am surprised that ministers should take a position so contrary to both Scripture and reason. But they have another position on which they lay great stress, which I should like to see examined. They claim that the Sabbath was a type, and hence has passed away.
S.—If the Sabbath was a type, of what was it a type?
I.—Of the millennium,—the future thousand years of blessedness and glory.
S.—Then do you not see that on their own showing the Sabbath should still be kept? for the antitype is not yet reached; and the type must continue till it meets its antitype.
I.—That is so; but now I remember, a more recent writer makes it a “type of the believer’s rest in Christ.”
S.—Indeed! Let us see how this can be. God worked six days, and rested the seventh day, then blessed and sanctified that day; and this rest we are told was a type of the believer’s rest in Christ. But if the seventh day’s rest was a type, the six days of labor were also types; and the whole transaction would signify, on this ground, that the sinner would—do what? sin six days and on the seventh be converted and rest in Christ? or, sin six years, then be converted and spend a year resting in Christ? or, spend six-sevenths of his life in sin, and the last seventh resting in Christ? It must be something of this kind, according to this theory; for there is a fixed proportion between the labor and the rest. We really wish our friends would give us a theory which we could follow at least a step or two without finding ourselves floundering in the grossest absurdities. The truth is, the Sabbath has not the remotest connection, typologically with the believer’s rest. In fact, the Sabbath is not a type at all, in any sense whatever, and from the very nature of the case cannot possibly be. This can be shown to the satisfaction of any candid mind by the very plainest considerations. But the time is lacking for further investigations now. Please call again next week, and we will resume this conversation.
I.—Thank you. Your positions are certainly so far invulnerable; and I shall wait with interest for another week to come that I may learn your views more fully.