AdventAI

SARATOGA'S REMARKABLE TRIBUTE TO EXTEMPORE PREACHING.

By S. Olin Garrison

From Review and Herald, Vol. 61, No. 16., April 15, 1884

THERE were some things said by prominent and elderly Presbyterian ministers in the Union Preachers’ Meeting at Saratoga lately, which ought not to be lost. They mark an era in the modern pulpit, and furnish an important contribution to practical theology. The subject under discussion was, “The best method of preaching to the people.”

Dr. Herrick Johnson, of Chicago, opened the discussion with a keen, analytical, and comprehensive half-hour address. There was not time for much expansion, but the Doctor took occasion at the close of his address to dwell at some length and with characteristic intensity on the three general methods of delivering a sermon, namely, “The memoriter, the manuscript, and the extempore.” He said: “Without any qualification the extemporaneous is the ideal method.” He described the memoriter preacher as revealing to the penetrating gaze of a keen listener that “blankness of facial expression which showed the speaker engaged in the most intense introspection lest he should miss his way in his recollected speech.” This internal effort broke the preacher’s highest power over his audience. For this and other reasons “the memoriter method was the weakest, and should never be used, except occasionally, perhaps, by the few speakers of marvelous memory.”

He continued: “To use the manuscript is always a confession of weakness.” This he said, at the same time recognizing before his brethren that although he often spoke extempore, his life-time practice had been with the manuscript. (The implication was, of course, that he regretted having failed in early years to master the extempore method.) The most forceful objection urged was that the manuscript crippled the preacher in pressing the truth home upon the hearers most directly and effectively.

Dr. Spear, of the New York Independent, then called out Dr. Hall, of Brooklyn, N. Y., who expressed himself as delighted with the address of Dr. Johnson, and especially with his remarks on the best method of delivering the sermon. He then proceeded to narrate the following personal experience: “About two and a half years ago, while spending a few weeks among the mountains, I was invited to preach in a Methodist pulpit for a few Sabbaths. Although I had used the manuscript throughout my entire ministry, I decided [the reader can see why] to preach to those Methodists extemporaneous sermons. Being somewhat pleased at the results, I decided to take these sermons home, and re-preach them to my own people. After a few Sabbaths my elders were so well pleased with the new method that they came to me with the request that I should not go back to the manuscript. But do you know, doctor [turning to Dr. Johnson], I was too cowardly to go on. However [facetiously], old as I am, I am encouraged by your remarks, and believe I shall try it again.”

The Rev. Dr. Hoge, of Richmond, Va., who the day before had captivated a Saratoga audience by an extemporaneous sermon preached without a scrap of paper, was soon after called out. He also at once expressed his delight at what he had heard, and especially with the place given the extemporaneous method. He said: “The manuscript is the curse of the American pulpit.” (I would not be too positive that he used the wordp. 252 curse, but it was a strong word, and in that identical sentence. His semi-asperated utterance, dulled the word, which I interpreted as curse.) In his early ministry he was so hampered by the manuscript he finally gave it up entirely. Often he had wanted to break away from his manuscript during the progress of the sermon, feeling that in the heat of public address he could express his thought better, and also interject new and stronger thoughts than he had wrought out in the study; but he was anchored to his written sermon. He said he believed the minister who was tied up to a written discourse thereby prevented the fullest and freest operation of the Holy Ghost in the proclamation of the gospel. Somehow or other—he could hardly tell why—the manuscript clipped the spiritual wings and prevented the highest spiritual flights. If his reputation as a preacher were to be staked on a given sermon, he would choose to think it out carefully while pacing the floor, trust to the hour for the language, and let a stenographer take it down while he delivered it.

The tide set so strongly in the direction Dr. Johnson gave it that it seemed for a time none would array themselves in opposition. Dr. Spear, however, ventured to demur, announcing the ideal method to be an interchange between the manuscript and the extempore method.

The statements given above were not put in quotation marks unless the writer was quite sure of the exact language. The thought is as it was expressed—no more, no less. No one, however, will be warranted in understanding these men to have opposed careful writing, directly or indirectly, in preparation for the extempore sermon. They all set a high value on the pen as a factor in the best preaching. Their own practices varied. Some wrote out the full sermon; some wrote a part; some did not write at all in direct preparation, but trusted wholly to their gathered resources and the inspiration of the hour for the language.

I will add to this paper one quotation from Dr. Spear, made at the Preacher’s Meeting, Aug. 20, on the subject of short sermons. He said: ‘After preaching thirty-seven years, and then listening fourteen years, if I had my ministry to live over I would preach shorter sermons.’—Rev. S. Olin Garrison, in Christian Advocate.