AdventAI

“CHRISTIAN PAGAN” OR “CHRISTIAN EVOLUTIONIST”?

By Wm. Penniman

From Review and Herald, Vol. 61, No. 21., May 20, 1884

BY WM. PENNIMAN.

The New York World says: “The announcement made by Mr. Beecher that he does not believe in the fall of Adam and in the inheritance of guilt, is less interesting in itself than as the prelude or introduction to the subsequent confession of disbelief which we may expect in logical sequence. The rejection of the doctrine of the fall and of inherited guilt naturally dispenses with any necessity for an atonement or for a divine Redeemer. If we reject the idea of vicarious sin, we must also reject the idea of vicarious atonement, and the whole divine element in the mission of Christ disappears at once. Such a form of unbelief is easy to understand; but it is not easy to understand why one who thus unceremoniously rejects the divine mission of Christ should take the trouble of calling himself a ‘Christian evolutionist.’ There would be as much meaning in the words if, under the same circumstances, he should call himself a Christian pagan. It would be more seemly if those who wholly repudiate the authority of Christ would also repudiate the name of Christian altogether.”

Certainly the world moves, and the New York World knows it in saying that Mr. Beecher might as well call himself a “Christian pagan” as a “Christian evolutionist.” If there is any meaning in the words “Christian pagan,” it must be “evolution backwards,” as Dr. Talmage expresses it, or a perverted or paganized Christian. The institutions of the Old Testament and the ordinances of the New have been so mixed up with paganism that perhaps there is some force in the words after all. For instance, Sunday is a word of pagan origin, and it is called a Christian institution, and is considered a Christian Sunday (yet many persist in calling it a Christian Sabbath). There is just as much force in the words “Christian Sunday” as in “Christian pagan”; and there is just as much proof that Sunday originated in Christianity as that evolution did. There is just as much proof in the Bible or in Christianity that man originated from a monkey, as there is that Christ taught Sunday-keeping. As the doctrine of Mr. Beecher tends to the rejection of the mission of Christ, it is so far in harmony with paganism. Mr. B. once took the position that the earth was inhabited by myriads of beings before man was upon it, but he said they were not taken to heaven, as God would not suffer so much mud to be taken there; but now it seems that he would transport all (even worse mud than the pre-Adamite) by a process of evolution to that happy place.

Certainly there is force in the words of the World: “It would be more seemly if those who wholly repudiate the authority of Christ would also repudiate the name of Christian altogether.”