AdventAI

IS IT DANGEROUS?

By N. J. Bowers

From Review and Herald, Vol. 61, No. 19., May 6, 1884

BY N. J. BOWERS.

It is sometimes objected that the doctrine of the destruction of the wicked makes infidels, and that it is calculated to quiet the fears of the sinner, making him indifferent to the claims of the gospel, and that the immoral condition of society at the present day is due in a measure to the growing prominence of the doctrine in question.

These objections have been presented to me in a private conversation, and I have thought it proper to reply to them briefly in this article. These are serious charges, and if they can be sustained, the doctrine has an evil tendency in society, and should be discarded. But let us not be too hasty. Let us examine a little into the matter. The prejudices of even well-meaning people will sometimes prompt them to make statements that cannot be sustained by reason and the logic of facts.

1. If the doctrine of the destruction of the wicked is a bad one, making infidels, then the Bible is a bad book; for it teaches just this doctrine. Read Ps. 5:6; Rev. 20:9; Ps. 21:8, 9; Mal. 4:1, 3; Matt. 3:12; Ps. 37:38; Rom. 6:21, 23; 2 Thess. 1:9; 2 Pet. 2:12; Heb. 6:8; 10:27; John 15:6; Rev. 21:8; and other scriptures. Therefore the Bible is chargeable with making infidels if the doctrine in question does so! Is the Bible a good book if it runs men and women into infidelity? Those who have faith in the Scriptures should be careful, lest they discard the Bible entirely; for surely (as we may see by looking up the above references) if one is rejected the other must be.

But, really, does the doctrine make men infidels? This can be settled by a short and easy test. Ask the first infidel you meet why he does not believe the Bible, and note his answer. If he tells you it is because he does not believe that the sinner will suffer to endless ages in hell, but that instead of this he believes it teaches the complete destruction of the wicked, you may conclude that the doctrine has to some extent at least made him an infidel. But ten chances against one, he will tell you the Bible teaches the eternal misery of the greater part of the human race, and for this reason he cannot accept it as a divine revelation. This is one of the strong reasons Col. Ingersoll urges against the Bible, and many other infidels present the same. So this is the infidel-making doctrine rather than the other, that ought to be given up.

It is safe to suppose that not one individual on reading the Bible has thrown it aside as no revelation of God because he believes it does not teach an eternal hell of woe to the sinner, but instead an everlasting destruction. It is safe to suppose that not one of the thousands who have departed from the faith of the Bible has done so because he believed it did not teach everlasting torment to the wicked, but destruction instead. But it is a fact that many who once believed the Bible taught the first of the two doctrines just mentioned, and who for this reason rejected it as of divine authority, have accepted it as such when brought to believe it taught the second! Men who scoffed at religion and mocked at her messengers, and who had no faith in the atoning blood of Jesus, have become men of Christian gravity, of pious sobriety, of prayer and praise to God and of faith in his promises, when they saw the Bible doctrine of the destruction of the wicked. Do not say the doctrine makes infidels. It unmakes them.

The most influential body of infidel Bible disbelievers in the world to-day, the spiritualists, do not believe in the destruction of the wicked. So this doctrine did not make them infidels. A tree is known by its fruits. So is an item of faith, or a doctrine. I think it can be safely said of those who hold to the doctrine of the ultimate destruction of the wicked, that they read the Bible as much and prize it as highly, if not more so, than do those who hold to the so-called orthodox view of future punishment. Also their daily life and Christian character will compare equally with the latter class. A Bible doctrine will carry with it no bad results; therefore the doctrine here defended can have no such character of evil.

2. If the doctrine hardens, or at least leaves the sinner at ease, then blame the Bible, not the doctrine. The former, as has been said, plainly sets forth the latter. If the Bible admonitions and warnings will not move the wicked, then we need use no others. We cannot justify ourselves in so doing, nor will God. The word has given us the means of awakening the ungodly. We cannot improve upon them. We must not use false alarms and false threatenings. We should not use here what God has not. We must plainly, patiently, kindly, and fully present the truth. Then our work ends. People should have the truth presented to them. If this will not win, nothing will.

The truth is, and there is no use of denying it, people are fast losing faith in the hell of our fathers, and are looking upon it as a monstrous absurdity or with an indignant scorn. This is shown in part by the softening and toning down of the doctrine on the part of some of the orthodox ministry, and by others who deny it in toto. This doctrine to-day has no great influence upon the ungodly, because they do not believe it. If the doctrine of the destruction of the wicked will not arouse the sinner, neither will the other, because people treat it with neglect and contempt. But the doctrine of destruction will arouse the sinner as I have indicated.

3. The idea that this doctrine has anything to do with the prevailing immorality of to-day is simply foolishness. It is about as absurd as is the Catholic bigotry that lays to Protestantism the national and individual calamities of the world for the last four hundred years. If the doctrine is blamable, I say again, Charge it all to the Bible! The doctrine has about as much connection with the present moral status of society as the Declaration of Independence, State Rights, or the Five Points of Calvinism. Look to atheism, intemperance, greed for gain, personal and political supremacy. These are the springs that feed the swelling tide of immorality at the present hour.