AdventAI

Sabbath-keeper.—I understand you to say that if it can be shown that Rom. 14:5 and Col. 2:16 do not release us from observing the Sabbath, you will yield the point and commence the observance of the seventh day according to the commandment?

Inquirer.—I shall feel under obligation to do so; for I find no intimation in the New Testament that the ancient Sabbath law is not still binding in this dispensation, unless these texts, and possibly one or two in Galatians, prove that we are released from it.

S.—You are right in supposing that these are the only texts from which any such idea can be drawn; but what if it can be shown that these texts can have no possible reference to the weekly Sabbath?

I.—That will clear the subject of all difficulty, and leave the Sabbath with all the binding force upon us that it ever had upon any people.

S.—We think this can easily be done. But let us first come to an understanding in regard to the issue before us. You will see that it is not between the seventh day and the first day, but between the seventh day and no day; for if these texts refer to a weekly Sabbath at all, they prove that there is no such Sabbath. This follows, certainly, if we may esteem every day alike, as Rom. 14:5 is understood to teach, and if no man may judge us in reference to the Sabbath, as is claimed from Col. 2:16. There can no more be a first-day Sabbath than a seventh-day Sabbath, on this hypothesis.

I.—I see that such is the case, though this seems to be generally overlooked; and I have often wondered how first-day keepers could be so short-sighted as to urge these texts against the seventh day, when they are just as much against the first day as the seventh.

S.—It is astonishing that they should do so; and we can account for it only on the ground that their zeal to overthrow the seventh day so blinds them to their own interests as to lead them to try to establish a proposition, which, if true, demolishes as with a charge of dynamite their own cherished Sunday institution. Every Sunday-keeper has just as much interest as we seventh-day observers have, to prove that these texts have no reference to the weekly Sabbath.

I.—True; but I don’t think either they or you can prove it.

S.—Very well, let us see what can be proved. I assume, first, that you have carefully read the 14th of Romans entire, so as to be able to grasp the subject upon which the apostle is reasoning and take in the scope of his argument. And now if you will answer a few questions, I think we may come to understand each other better on this subject. If Paul refers to the Sabbath in verse 5, does it not follow that his subject is the decalogue, or ten commandments?

I.—Yes; for the fourth commandment of the decalogue is the only law we find respecting the Sabbath.

S.—Now what class does he introduce in verse 1?

I.—Those who were weak in the Christian faith.

S.—How does he say they should be treated?

I.—We should not judge them for their doubtful thoughts, as the margin reads.

S.—And what did these doubtful thoughts have reference to, according to verses 2 and 3?

I.—To the subject of eating, the question of meats and drinks.

S.—Exactly so; but is there anything about meats and drinks in the ten commandments?

I.—No.

S.—Then the decalogue is not the subject of Paul’s discourse; and when he speaks of days he has no reference to the Sabbath of the decalogue.

I.—That would certainly follow, if the ten commandments are a distinct law by themselves.

S.—And are they not a distinct law? How can any one confound them with other laws, when they alone were spoken by the voice of God, they alone written on the tables of stone, they alone had a receptacle of exquisite workmanship and immense value in which they were carefully secluded from everything else, and they alone were the commandments in reference to which all the imposing atonement services of fifteen hundred years were performed. They alone define the duties which mankind universally owe to God and to one another. God calls these commandments alone “a law.” Ex. 24:12. The same distinction is recognized in the New Testament; for Christ affirms in the strongest manner the perpetuity of some law not only through time but even through eternity (Matt. 5:17–20); and yet another law he blotted out and nailed to his cross. Eph. 2:15; Col. 2:14. Paul says of one, the moral law, that it is not made void by faith in Christ (Rom. 3:31), and yet of another law that faith in Christ does entirely set it aside (Gal. 5:2–4); and both he and John vigorously demolish the nonsense of antinomianism when they say that sin is the transgression of the law (1 John 3:4), that by the law is the knowledge of sin (Rom. 3:20), that where no law is there is no transgression (Rom. 4:15), and that sin is not imputed when there is no law. Rom. 5:13. Some law, therefore, remains unabolished by the cross by which now, as in all time past, men are shown to be sinners.

I.—These facts and texts certainly seem to distinguish the ten commandments as a law by themselves; but is the ceremonial law ever spoken of by itself in equally exclusive terms?

S.—Certainly. Paul in Heb. 9:8–10 speaks of the law of service of the first covenant and the first tabernacle, and says that it stood “only in meats and drinks and divers washings and carnal ordinances, imposed on them until the time of reformation.” Here you see a law consisting of the very things of which Paul speaks in Rom. 14, and which was to last only to the reformation or the introduction of the new dispensation by Christ. These Christ accordingly took out of the way, nailing them to his cross; and these included seven annual sabbaths connected with the three great Jewish festivals—two with the passover, the Pentecost fifty days later, and four with the festivals of the seventh month. But it seemed a great step to many to drop all these at once when embracing Christianity. With light at first more or less dim, and a conscience very tender, they were disposed still to regard this ceremonial distinction in days, and in meats and drinks. With reference to such Paul says, Bear with them, do not judge, or condemn them, nor put a stumbling block in their way. With further light and further experience they will come into the full liberty of the gospel and see clearly the relation of the typical to the antitypical dispensation. But the gospel gives no man any liberty to sin, that is, to violate any one of God’s moral laws. Such being the scope of the apostle’s argument, you see he can have no reference whatever to the weekly Sabbath, which is one of the moral laws.

I.—This, indeed, would seem to be the case; yet there is one expression that puzzles me with such a view. Verse 5 reads, “another esteemeth every day alike,” and would not “every day” include the Sabbath, and leave it to our own discretion whether to observe it or not?

S.—Not at all; for the Lord himself speaks of the secular days of the week as “every day,” not including his Sabbath at all. This is proved by an incident which occurred in the Wilderness of Sin, as recorded in Ex. 16. The Lord told Moses that he would rain bread from heaven for the people, and they should go out and gather a certain rate “every day.” At the same time it was designed to withhold the manna on the seventh day, and that none of the people should go out to gather it on that day; and the whole arrangement was for the purpose of testing the people to determine whether they would walk in God’s law or no. This case is therefore right to the point, and is absolutely conclusive on the question before us. It shows that the expression “every day” does not necessarily include the Sabbath, and that Paul might use the expression in treating upon the feast days of the Jews, without having any reference whatever to the Sabbath of the Lord. Add to this the fact that the same apostle has so written in other places about the law and faith in Christ as to involve himself in positive contradiction if he here refers to the Sabbath, and it becomes one of the clearest certainties that he does not refer to the Sabbath at all in the 14th of Romans.

I.—I admit that this clears the subject of all difficulty so far as Romans is concerned, but what about Col. 2:16, “Let no man judge you in respect of . . . the Sabbath”?

S.—Not “the Sabbath,” but “sabbaths,” referring to the annual sabbaths of the Jews, already spoken of, of which there were seven in the course of the year. These were connected with meats and drinks, of which he speaks in the first part of the verse. By reading the whole passage, verses 14–17 inclusive, you will clearly perceive the apostle’s subject here. It is the “hand-writing of ordinances”—an expression never applied to the ten commandments; it was that which could be “blotted out,” which was not true of the letters cut in the stone; it was that which was “against us” and “contrary to us,” which could not apply to the moral law, for Paul says that is “spiritual, holy, just and good” (Rom. 7:12, 14), nor to the Sabbath, for that “was made for man” (Mark 2:27), and we are to esteem it “a delight, the holy of the Lord, honorable” (Isa. 58:13); it was that which could be “nailed to the cross,” which would be most inconsistent as applied to the tables of stone; it was the “meats, drinks, holy days, new moons,” etc., of the typical system, which had no connection whatever with the moral law; and finally it was that, and only that, which was “a shadow of things to come,” but the body of which is of Christ. But the weekly Sabbath was not a shadow, it antedated all types and figures, it pointed forward to nothing in the work of Christ, but was simply a memorial of the great work of Jehovah in the creation of the world. Paul therefore has no reference in Col. 2:16 to the Sabbath of the Lord.

I.—I have nothing to answer against this conclusion. It seems clear that the apostle refers only to the typical system.

S.—You intimated that a passage or two in Galatians troubled you. I should be pleased to notice them.

I.—I have nothing here to urge with much confidence; but I have heard Gal. 4:10 quoted to show that we are under no obligation to keep the Sabbath, as Paul speaks of the observance of days and months and times and years, as beggarly elements which gender bondage.

S.—It will be easy to show that he has no reference here to the Sabbath of the fourth commandment. The system to which he alludes, whether it be the ceremonial service of the Jews, or some system of heathen worship, has “months and times and years” connected with the days. But the moral law has nothing of this kind. It has simply a rest-day occurring weekly, with nop. 313 months or times or years connected with it. Paul, therefore, has no reference to the Sabbath of the Lord. The observing of “times” was among the abominations of the heathen (Deut. 18:10), and to some such practices the apostle may allude.

I.—I see that is easily answered. The other passage is Gal. 3:24, 25: “The law was our schoolmaster to bring us to Christ; but after that faith is come we are no longer under a schoolmaster.”

S.—We have often called upon those who use this text to tell us whether they wish to be understood that it releases us from any moral obligation or not. But we have never yet found one with sufficient stamina to face the issue. If they say, yes, we simply turn them over to the scorn and indignation of the whole Christian world. If they say, No, then, we reply, there is no controversy between us; for all we contend for is that every moral principle has come over into this dispensation unchanged and unimpaired, as it existed before. We say that the ten commandments, including the Sabbath, are these unchanged moral principles. If any one disputes this, that leads to another issue which we have not time to discuss here. But however this may be, it is easy to show that the passage contains no proof of the abolition of the Sabbath. The law of which Paul here speaks is something that was designed to point out and lead forward to Christ. This at once suggests the type, the shadow of things to come. But as already noticed, the Sabbath contained nothing that typified, pointed out or foreshadowed, anything in the work of Christ for the redemption of the world. The typical service with its sacrifices and offering did do this; and this typical system is sometimes spoken of as “the law.” But this does not prove that there is not another law moral in its nature separate and distinct from it in every respect. The failure to discriminate between the two is the mistake that many make. How, it may be asked, did this typical system bring us to Christ?—It taught that there was no remission except by blood; but it showed also that the blood of bulls and goats could not take away sin; for these sacrifices had continually to be repeated. See Paul’s argument on this point in Heb. 10:1–14. Hence the necessity for a more perfect sacrifice. And if the Jewish nation had learned aright the lesson of this schoolmaster, this παιδαγωγός, pedagogue (one who leads and instructs the child before he is of age), they would have seen the necessity of Christ’s sacrifice and been ready to accept him when he came. But the substance having now taken the place of the shadow, the type of the antitype, we are no longer under the teaching of that system; it is no longer necessary.

I.—I see no objection to your argument on this point.

S.—Is the way then clear for you to fulfill your pledge to keep the Sabbath?

I.—It is, and I shall henceforth keep it.

S.—Manly and honest decision! in which may God bless you, as he will do; for so he has promised. He says: “Blessed is the man that doeth this, and the son of man that layeth hold on it; that keepeth the Sabbath from polluting it, and keepeth his hand from doing any evil.” Isa. 56:2.