IS THERE ANY DEGREE OF IMPERFECTION IN THE REVELATIONS OF GOD TO MAN?
By George I. Butler
IS THERE ANY DEGREE OF IMPERFECTION IN THE REVELATIONS OF GOD TO MAN?
This is an important question, and one which we would approach with the deepest reverence. It is one which the Bible itself should settle. How reasonable to suppose that if God gives us a revelation he will instruct us in it of its design and in what sense we should regard it. It is as proper for us to consult its pages upon this subject as any other contained in it. In answer to the question, “Is there any degree of imperfection in God’s revelations to man,” we would say on general principles, It is perfect for the purpose for which it is given, but may not be perfect used for some other object. To illustrate: There are many tools constructed to do a certain work, and they are excellent if used to perform that work; but if used for some other work than that they would be found unsuitable. God had an object in view in giving inspiration to men. It would be a reflection upon divine wisdom to suppose that when he bestowed it he made a mistake, and that it would not accomplish its purpose. But it would be no such reflection if it were applied to some other purpose to suppose it would not accomplish this object for which it was not designed. We believe some people make a mistake here, and expect of revelation that for which it was never intended by its Author. If they make this mistake, they should not hold him or his book responsible for their blunder. What was God’s design in giving his word? We answer, That he might afford such instruction to man as would enable him to lead a life that will be pleasing to God here, and secure salvation hereafter, and to enable him to recover himself from a sinful state in this world. We claim that this revelation is perfectly adapted to enable man to accomplish these objects, and develop a proper character. It reveals to him enough of God to show him what kind of a being he is. It gives enough of the history of the past to show God’s overruling providence in the affairs of men, and how he gives men free chance to act, and rewards and punishes obedience and disobedience. He reveals enough of the future to show the plan of God concerning man, the ultimate reward of the upright, and the condemnation of the wicked. It sets before man a perfect standard of moral principle by which he may form a perfect character if he will use the helps offered. And the whole is so arranged and designed as to develop a faithful, humble, trusting, and obedient spirit if we follow the instruction given. That this is the design of inspiration the Apostle Paul declares. 2 Tim. 3: 15–17. He says that “the Holy Scriptures are able to make us wise unto salvation, through faith which is in Jesus Christ. All scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness, that the man of God may be perfect, thoroughly furnished unto all good works.” Here the objects of giving inspiration are beautifully set before us. It is “to make us wise unto salvation.” There never was a person who tried with all his heart to understand and obey the Scriptures, who will be lost. They are perfectly adapted to this purpose. They are “profitable for doctrine, reproof, correction, and instruction in righteousness.” On every one of these points they are full and perfectly adapted to giving all the information any person needs. There is nothing wanting. In the moral instructions of the Bible there is not a flaw. They are complete; and the person who perfectly follows these instructions will be a perfect man, morally and spiritually, and have such a character as God can accept. But this scripture does not say that such a person will be a perfect scientist, or philosopher, or historian, that he will have a perfect knowledge of all God has done or all he will do. The Bible does not profess to be perfect and complete as a history or a prophecy, in the sense that it gives a record of all the past or all that will occur. It tells the truth as far as it goes, but often does not tell all we would like to know. It does tell all we need to know in order that we may “be wise unto salvation.” The object of the book is to save a lost race from sin and its consequences; and it is perfectly adapted to this object. For example, as a history. How glad we would be to know more about creation and the early history of the race. The account is very meager indeed. But it is sufficient to show us that God made the heavens and the earth and the race of man, and that he will punish the disobedient. How glad we would be to know more about Elijah’s early life and that of many of the prophets; and how many instances in Kings and Chronicles there are where reference is made to histories which we cannot find in the Bible. We know the Bible account is incomplete. How precious it would be if we had a full account of all the early life of Jesus and all his sayings and doings. They must have been very many; for St. John says the world would hardly contain all the books if they were written. The histories we have, then, contain but a small part of those most interesting things.345 The Bible is not complete or perfect as a historical narrative. But it does give us all we need to know of Jesus to make us wise unto salvation, and much more than we are usually willing to obey. It does not profess to be full and complete as a prophecy. 2 Pet. 1:19: “We have also a more sure word of prophecy; whereunto ye do well that ye take heed, as unto a light which shineth in a dark place, until the day dawn, and the daystar arise in your hearts.” This scripture shows most forcibly the importance of the prophecies we have. But the apostle’s illustration of its uses is one which clearly proves it to be incomplete. It is that of a light, like a lantern, or a lamp in a dark place, “until the day dawn.” We all value a light in a dark place at night. But how far short it comes of the light of day itself. So prophecy sheds a precious light on our pathway now in this world of sin. It is of inestimable value. But how imperfectly does it compare with the dawning of the day itself, when all darkness shall flee away, and “we shall see as we are seen, and know as we are known.” Prophecy gives us sufficient light to get safely through the darkness of earth, like a lamp in a dark night, and this is all it professes to do. Hence, we say, Prophecy is imperfect in the sense of quantity or degree, though the light which is given through it is of inestimable value. We here notice another scripture which we have already quoted several times in this series of articles. Num. 12:1–8. The first verses state that Aaron and Miriam, the brother and sister of Moses, spoke against him because of the woman he had married. They said, “Hath the Lord indeed spoken only by Moses? hath he not spoken by us?” Because of Moses’ meekness he evidently made little reply. But the Lord summoned all three to the tabernacle, and he spoke to them from the pillar of the cloud at the door of the tabernacle as follows: “Hear now my words: If there be a prophet among you, I the Lord will make myself known unto him in a vision and speak unto him in a dream. My servant Moses is not so, who is faithful in all my house. With him will I speak mouth to mouth, even apparently and not in dark speeches; and the similitude of the Lord shall he behold: wherefore, then, were ye not afraid to speak against my servant Moses?” It is evident from this and other Scriptures that Aaron and Miriam were both prophets and had visions. Ex. 15:20. They evidently felt that because of this fact they were equal to Moses in the sense that they were blessed with revelations as well as he; therefore they took occasion to criticise his course. God was displeased with them for this, and informed them that there was a difference between his manner of communicating through Moses and that through the ordinary prophet, by visions and dreams, as he had also through them. With Moses he spake “mouth to mouth;” that is, he spake directly to Moses “as a friend speaketh unto his friend.” Ex. 33:11. He showed to Moses “his similitude,” that is, his personal appearance. But with them the case was very different. He spoke to them in a “vision, or a dream;” that is, in “dark speeches,” as he expresses it in verse 8. Therefore, because they had taken occasion to criticise Moses, thus placing themselves on an equality with him, God was greatly displeased with them. Aaron and Miriam were both superior to Moses in age, which usually gave persons a preference in that period of the world. God had also used them both in his work, Aaron being the High Priest. Were it not for this one fact, that God had given Moses greatly the preference by manifesting himself much more fully to him, we could discover no impropriety in the elder brother and sister questioning his conduct so far as position was concerned. But this is precisely the basis upon which God places his censure of their course. His manner of communicating through Moses was greatly superior to the one by which he gave light through them. This showed that God took Moses into greater nearness to himself than he did them; and therefore it was wholly out of place for them to criticise Moses’ conduct. And Miriam, who seems to have been foremost in this, went out of his presence a leper. God’s special displeasure was upon her. The bearing this has upon the subject is plain. God’s method of communicating through Moses by directly speaking to him, and personally manifesting himself to him, is much superior to that of speaking through visions and dreams. We conclude, therefore, that there must be some degree of imperfection in the latter method; for the former could not be more than perfect. This imperfection must be indicated in the words which God himself used on this occasion. The one method he speaks of as being “mouth to mouth;” the other as “dark speeches.” None of us will dare to criticise these words which the Lord himself uses. They do imply, to say the least, a lack of perfect clearness in this manner of communicating. Before drawing any further conclusions from this Scripture we notice another from the apostle Paul, which is a very important testimony on this subject. 1 Cor. 13:8–13. “Charity never faileth; but whether there be prophecies, they shall fail; whether there be tongues, they shall cease; whether there be knowledge, it shall vanish away. For we know in part, and we prophesy in part. But when that which is perfect is come, then that which is in part shall be done away. When I was a child, I spoke as a child, I understood as a child, I thought as a child; but when I became a man, I put away childish things. For now we see through a glass, darkly, but then face to face; now I know in part; but then shall I know even as also I am known. And now abideth faith, hope, charity, these three; but the greatest of these is charity.” This language occurs in a lengthy discourse by this great apostle commencing in chapter 12, and continuing through chapter 14. It commences with the declaration, “Now concerning spiritual gifts, brethren, I would not have you ignorant,” and closes with “Wherefore covet to prophesy and forbid not to speak with tongues. Let all things be done decently and in order.” In this discourse he introduces quite a number of subjects besides this one, such as the unity of the church, charity, proper order in the church, etc.; but it mainly relates to spiritual gifts and especially to prophecy. These gifts are placed in the church for its benefit, to enable it to accomplish its great object, the salvation of its membership and of sinners. Or, as he expresses it in another place, speaking of the same subject, “For the perfecting of the saints, for the work of the ministry, for the edifying of the body of Christ: till we all come in the unity of the faith and of the knowledge of the Son of God, unto a perfect man, unto the measure of the stature of the fullness of Christ.” Eph. 4:12, 13. The object of these gifts and of prophecy, then, is wholly that of our salvation from sin and death. They are blessed helps, means of grace in a world of darkness and temptation. They are to be desired or “coveted” (chap. 12:31), yet charity, or love, is of greater importance, and hence should be desired more. Charity never faileth; but prophecies and these gifts shall fail, or cease, when the perfect state is reached. But this crowning grace of love will be the ruling principle of the eternal world. In this scripture we have quoted, the apostle instructs us relative to the length of time these gifts will continue, and in regard to the nature and design of prophecy and the ground it was intended to cover, its degree of perfection, and the measure of light it was intended by the Creator to bestow. He gives us two illustrations to enable us the better to understand the subject: that of the child before its mind is fully developed, and that of the “glass,” or ancient mirror. In no other scripture in the Bible is this particular subject so clearly elucidated. Let us closely examine this, point by point: “Charity never faileth;” “prophecies shall fail;” “tongues shall cease;” “knowledge shall vanish away;” “we prophesy in part;” “when that which is perfect is come, then that which is in part shall be done away.” We know, therefore, that the gift of prophecy, or having visions, will not be continued after the perfect or eternal world is ushered in. All these special gifts of tongues and knowledge which are given to help us in this world of darkness will cease then. They will be no more necessary than a candle would be in the blazing sun of August. The objects they were designed to enable us to bring about will have then been fully consummated. We notice specially, however, that they were not designed to be removed till the “perfect” is reached. That will never come till this night of sin gives place to the eternal day of glory long foretold. We have here, then, the most emphatic evidence of the perpetuity of these gifts in the church, including prophecy, till the “perfect” day comes. God designed them for the church during all this period. When his people live up to the conditions on which they are to be given, and his work needs them, they will appear even till the “perfect” day dawns. Then there will be no further use for them; probation will have closed, and all will have been saved who can be saved. But not so with “charity,” or love. The “perfect” state is where that will shine brightest. It is a plant of heavenly growth here, which has been dwarfed by the cold of unbelief, the darkness of error, and the misanthropic influences of sin. But there it will blossom and bear fruit in the fullness of eternal glory. Every heart will be filled with it. But what ground is prophecy designed to cover in this world? “We know in part and we prophesy in part.” Prophecy, therefore, is not designed to cover all. It is only in part. There are thousands of things we would like to know about God, Christ, angels, and the eternal world, that have never been revealed to us. We can never know them till we reach the eternal state. This world is but the preparatory, that the reality. In order to ever know them we must make use of the light given us through prophecy. Then at last the day will dawn before us. This light “in part” is given us solely that we may understand how to reach that state. It is full and perfect so far as affording us all the instruction we need on that special point. But “in part” when it speaks of other things. He now illustrates the subject by the condition of childhood. The gradual development of a child’s mind is one of the most interesting things in nature. How sweet their childish prattle! Their efforts to speak, how interesting! What dim and indistinct conceptions of subjects they are able to give us compared to the knowledge of a full-grown man! Yet we greatly prize the knowledge they do possess, and long to have them acquire more. The understandings and reasonings of a child are crude and imperfect. Yet the great apostle takes this very condition to illustrate the feebleness of the light of prophecy as compared with the far greater light of the eternal day. The knowledge the child obtains is valuable as far as it goes, and it may be sufficient for it to perform the work it has to do. But far greater knowledge will be required for manhood. So our knowledge of heavenly things is weak and childish as compared with that of heavenly beings. But what we have is very precious, and makes us long for more. The apostle continues to illustrate the same subject by a glass, or mirror, through which, or in346 which, we see “darkly.” Dr. Clarke gives some excellent thoughts on this expression. He concludes that by a “glass,” as our translation gives it, is meant an ancient mirror made of some kind of metal, which reflected but imperfectly, the modern glass being unknown. No doubt this is correct. He thinks the expression “through a glass darkly,” is explained by the Jewish writers, who used quite commonly a term very similar. A revelation such as that through Moses, given in clear and express terms, they spoke of as a “clear and lucid glass;” while one given through visions or dreams they characterized as a glass or “speculum” which was not clear. He quotes from Dr. Parkhurst a definition of this term “darkly.” He says it is from the Greek word ainigma, the perfect passive of ainisso, to hint, intimate, signify, with some degree of obscurity; an enigma in which one thing answers or stands in correspondence to, or as the representative of, another which is in some respects similar to it. Now, in this life, we see by means of a mirror, reflecting the images of heavenly and spiritual things in an enigmatical manner, invisible things being represented by visible, spiritual by natural, eternal by temporal; but then, in the eternal world, face to face, every thing being seen in itself and not by means of a representation or similitude. We think this an excellent criticism or explanation. It brings forcibly to our minds the expression in Numbers 12:6–8, when this very distinction is made between the manner of communicating light through Moses, “mouth to mouth,” and in “dark speeches” by “visions and dreams.” The one was superior to the other. There can be no question that the apostle Paul has in view in this illustration in which he speaks of seeing “through [or in] a glass darkly,” this method of revealing prophecy by visions and dreams. This is the special subject of his discourse, which is closely connected and logical throughout, if we take this view of it; but disconnected, illogical, and wandering if we do not. It agrees perfectly with what the Lord said to Moses in Num. 12, with what he said through Peter of the word of prophecy, and with the evident facts which can be seen in visions and revelations themselves. Divine things are revealed in part, and with some degree of obscurity. The images are reflected but partially. The lamp of prophecy in a dark place is of inestimable value; because if we diligently follow its light, it will lead us safely through our dangers, just as a lantern will show us the dangers in our pathway, though it does not give us such a degree of light as the sun does. We are forced, then, by the language of Holy Writ, to draw the conclusion that there is some degree of imperfection, so far as clearness and fullness of light is concerned, in revelations from God through prophecy, ever remembering, however, that what is given is true and good. We might make this conclusion doubly certain by considering visions and dreams in the Bible itself. Could Daniel understand his own visions until they were explained to him? Some points were not fully explained. In the books of Ezekiel, Zechariah, the Revelation, and in fact every prophecy, there are many things which the best of minds have puzzled over. Evidently many of them were not designed to be understood until the time was come when the key of fulfilling events should unlock their secrets. In Paul’s writings there were “many things hard to be understood, which the unlearned and unstable wrest to their own destruction.” The great moral truths of the Bible are made very plain, so that any who desire to obey them can do so. Other portions of Scripture are not made so plain. The mind needs the special illumination of the Holy Spirit to understand them. This is best for us, so that we will be tested to see whether we care enough about the light which God has given to seek for it with prayer and strong pleadings. Thus the concealed truth beckons us on to seek for heavenly wisdom and light from God, that we may understand his word. If all was made perfectly plain, we should not be incited to make such an effort, and our spiritual attainments would not be so great. The Bible is not therefore like an open space, in which all its rich treasures lie in plain view, to be grasped without effort; it is rather like a deep mine, which we must explore with light from God’s Spirit and with earnest effort, being sure that rich treasures await our careful and energetic explorations. What, therefore, may at first seem like a fault in the Scriptures,—like a lack of clearness,—is really a blessing in disguise, testing us and leading us deeper into spiritual experiences. G. I. B.