The Scriptures plainly teach us that “sin is the transgression of the law.” 1 John 3:4; Rom. 7:7. Now the sin not unto death must be some transgression of the law for which the penalty of death is not meted out. But when we take the reasoning of James on the law of God, we find ourselves in a dilemma; for he says (chap. 3:10), “Whosoever shall keep the whole law [of ten commandments] and yet offend in one [commandment; the term “point” is supplied by the translators], he is guilty of all.” See also context. I think there is but one solution of the problem in harmony with the Scriptures. Briefly stated, the sin not unto death is, doubtless, the sin of ignorance. See Lev. 4; Num. 15:27-29. Those who in all sincerity have observed the first day of the week as the Sabbath, not knowing that they were transgressing the law of God, did so ignorantly; and not being brought to their knowledge, it was not imputed to them as a sin unto death. But the sin unto death (1 John 5:16), or the sin of presumption, of which an example is given in Num. 15:32-36, consists in persisting in a wrong course after light has come; and that light can come only in God’s appointed way,—through his word. Ps. 119:130. I think an example of this sin for which we should not pray is given in Heb. 6:4-8. It is doubtless wrong for us to spend precious time that might be much more profitably employed in praying and laboring for the restoration of those who have become apostates from, and open enemies of, the truth. 1 Sam. 16:1. The sin not unto death, of which Sunday-keeping has been in time past a notable example, may be illustrated as follows:— A child sees his father go into the garden, and with a hoe stir up the soil, and cut up the weeds. In the father’s absence the boy takes the hoe, and nearly ruins the garden, cutting up the precious plants, as well as noxious weeds. Seeing father coming, he goes to meet him, and with beaming face takes him by the hand, leads him into the garden, explaining in his artless way what he had done to please his father. Harm, of course, had been done; but it had been done in love and ignorance. The father kisses his son, and, showing him the mistake he had made, carefully teaches him a better way. So with those who have kept the first day of the week in all sincerity holy unto the Lord. But let all beware when Bible evidence begets doubt in the mind of the sacred character of the first day, lest selfish motives or worldly considerations turn the scale against the only day that God has ever declared “holy of the Lord.” Isa. 58:13.