JEWS ADOPTING SUNDAY-KEEPING

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 10, 1884

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 61, No. 24.

Read the full edition

JEWS ADOPTING SUNDAY-KEEPING.

ONE of the most significant movements now in progress in this country, is that which the Jewish Church is agitating in some quarters to change their day of worship from the Sabbath to Sunday. A telegram from New York to the Post-Despatch of St. Louis, dated May 22, 1884, stated that such a movement was in progress in the congregation of Temple Emanuel, No. 521, Fifth Avenue. The rabbi, Gustav Gottheil, urged as circumstances which demand a change, that there is a lack of interest in the congregation, the attendance on public worship is decreasing, and the services are held on a day (the seventh day) when it is very inconvenient for many to attend. For these reasons he thought the manual should be revised, the services be rendered principally in the English language, more congregational singing be employed, and the day of worship be changed to the first day of the week. The report proceeds:—
“In relation to this matter, Dr. Gottheil said last evening: ‘This is a subject on which my trustees and myself are in perfect accord. The matter has been discussed by us for a long time past, and finally they said to me, “Write us a letter on this subject embracing these views, and we will submit it to the congregation.” Knowing these

CHANGES MUST COME,

feeling that the time was ripe for presenting my views, I did so.’
“‘Was the matter a surprise to your congregation?’
“‘Not in the least. There was no secret about the matter. Everybody knew what was to come, and expected it.’
“‘Are the Hebrew congregations independent and free to make such changes?’
“‘Certainly. Each congregation is a law unto itself, and may worship according to any form it may see fit to adopt.’
“‘Will there be much opposition to it in the congregation?’
“‘I think not. That there will be some is to be expected; but there will be no trouble, no serious disagreement, no change made without careful deliberation, and none except it be approved by the enlightened sentiment of the congregation. There are always some opposed to any change, fearful of departing from established forms; but changes are going on all around us, and that which was eminently proper for one age becomes obsolete, and is no longer useful in the next. The committee which has the subject under consideration is composed of the wisest and best men we have, and before deciding upon any change they will discuss it in all its bearings and from every standpoint. I feel sure that their unanimous decision will be unhesitatingly accepted by all of the congregation. There has never been any disagreement in our temple, and I don’t think that there ever will be. Nothing will be done hastily, and nothing except what seems exactly right.’”
There are some who seem to think it an impossible thing that Sunday-keeping should come to secure a general support in this country. But when we see the Jews turning from the established convictions and the uniform practice of over thirty-three centuries to give it support, what may we not expect in other directions?