The Sabbath and the First Day in the First Centuries
By R. F. Cottrell
THE SABBATH AND THE FIRST-DAY OF THE WEEK IN THE FIRST CENTURIES OF THE CHRISTIAN ERA.—NO. 1.
ALL well-informed persons know that the ancient Sabbath was the seventh day of the week, now called Saturday, and that it stood without a rival till the beginning of the Christian era. Since then the first day of the week has been introduced as being more worthy of veneration than the ancient Sabbath. It has finally assumed the title of Christian Sabbath, and at the present time a great majority of those called Christians observe the first day of the week, and not the seventh. But all who do this do not offer the same reasons for their practice. One class claims divine authority for the change of the day, and that the keeping of the first day is in obedience to the fourth commandment; the other, that the commandment enjoining the observance of the Sabbath has been abolished, and that consequently they are at liberty to choose any day for rest and worship they may judge best or most convenient. Therefore they observe the day most generally observed, not, however, on account of any requirement of the law of God. Those who still hold to the ancient Sabbath, the seventh day, give as their reason that God rested on that day, and then blessed and sanctified the day, because he had rested upon it, and that they believe that the Sabbath commandment is unchangeable in every respect, and perpetually binding upon mankind for whom the Sabbath was made. Mark 2:27. Those who claim a change of the day agree with them in the perpetuity of the Sabbath law, alleging, however, that the day of the Sabbath is indefinite and changeable. The third class agree with the first, that the day of the commandment is definite and unchangeable, still requiring the observance of the original seventh day if it were binding at all; but they teach that the law has been abolished, and consequently that no Sabbath is now binding. Putting together the testimonies of these two parties who observe the first day, the position of those who observe the seventh day is fully sustained, namely, that the original Sabbath law is still binding, and that it requires the observance of the same definite seventh day. All questions in respect to divine institutions should be settled by appeal to the Scriptures only, as they are the only infallible guide in such matters. But the evidence of a divine institution of the first-day Sabbath in the New Testament being found to be decidedly weak and unsatisfactory, its advocates appeal to the uninspired testimonies of the so-called Christian fathers to make up the deficiency. Hence we are driven to an examination of early church history to refute the claim by showing that the evidences from this source fall far short of proving the point at issue. In the investigation of their testimonies it will be seen that the early Christians began the observance of the first day of the week as a festival purely as a voluntary act, not one of them ever appealing to the teachings of Christ or any apostolic command for its institution; that it cannot be proved that any writer ever called it the Lord’s day till near the close of the second century; and that it was never called the Sabbath by any writer whatever for more than five hundred years after Christ. It is also noticeable that in all their discussions in respect to the Sabbath and the first day, these were always considered as two distinct days, no question being raised in respect to the identity of either. The idea of lost time, or of any difficulty in ascertaining which was the seventh or the first day of the week, never was thought of in those early days. The seventh part of time theory had not then been invented, there being no necessity for it, because the thought of enforcing the observance of the first day by the fourth commandment had not entered the mind of man. The only question was, Which day had the greater claim to be507 held sacred—the Sabbath (by which title they always understood the seventh day of the week, now called Saturday), or the first day, the day of the Lord’s resurrection, which about the end of the second century began to be honored with the title of Lord’s day? It cannot be shown that they ever pretended to derive this use of the term from John’s reference to the Lord’s day in Rev. 1:10; nor was any attempt made in the first five centuries to transfer the title of Sabbath to the first-day, or to enforce the observance of the latter by the fourth commandment or any other passage of scripture. But a double deception has been practiced upon the people to justify them in keeping the first day instead of the rest day enjoined by the God of the fourth commandment. In the first place they have been made to believe that the testimony of those Christian writers who lived but a little this side of the apostles, could be relied upon as about as good evidence as the apostles themselves; and in the second place spurious assertions as coming from those fathers have been handed out to the people, making them say that which they never did say. These frauds have been pointed out and abundantly proved in the “History of the Sabbath” by Eld. J. N. Andrews, to which I refer the reader, as it is too great a task to travel over the same ground. I will give some of his conclusions, which are fully sustained by the testimonies which he quotes:— “Next to the deception under which men fall when they are made to believe that the Bible may be corrected by the fathers, is the deception practiced upon them as to what the fathers actually teach. It is asserted that the fathers bear explicit testimony to the change of the Sabbath by Christ as a historical fact, and that they knew that this was so because they had conversed with the apostles, or with some who had conversed with them. It is also asserted that the fathers called the first day of the week the Christian Sabbath, and that they refrained from labor on that day as an act of obedience to the fourth commandment. “Now it is a remarkable fact that every one of these assertions is false. The people who trust in the fathers as their authority for departing from God’s commandment are miserably deceived as to what the fathers teach. “1. The fathers are so far from testifying that the apostles told them that Christ changed the Sabbath, that not even one of them ever alludes to the idea of such a change. “2. No one of them ever calls the first day the Christian Sabbath, nor indeed ever calls it a Sabbath of any kind. “3. They never represent it as a day on which ordinary labor was sinful, nor do they represent the observance of Sunday as an act of obedience to the fourth commandment. “4. The modern doctrine of the change of the Sabbath was therefore absolutely unknown in the first centuries of the Christian church.” Again, after the examination of seven successive witnesses which are claimed to have called Sunday the Lord’s day in order to make it appear that the Lord’s day of Rev. 1:10 was the first day of the week, and showing that every one of them whose testimony could have any bearing on the question at issue were fraudulently quoted, he comes to the following conclusion, namely, that “Sunday is not called the Lord’s day till ninety-eight years after John was upon Patmos, and one hundred and sixty-three years after the resurrection of Christ!” It is an easy matter for reckless talkers to dispute this conclusion; but to disprove it by facts of history is quite another task, one that will not be undertaken. The Sunday “Lord’s day” does not stand even upon a sandy foundation, for “the sand is wanting.” It is time that souls who have a desire to know the truth that they may obey God and live, should be undeceived in matters pertaining to their duty to God. The Judgment is before us, and nothing but truth and heart obedience will pass the test of that tribunal.