ANSWERS BY W. H. LITTLEJOHN.
250.—NO MAN HAS ASCENDED TO HEAVEN.
Did not Moses, Enoch, and Elijah ascend to heaven? If they did, how do you explain John 3:13, in which the Saviour declares that no one had gone to heaven save himself? P. L. A.
ANS. It is probable that when the Saviour said that no man had ascended up to heaven but he that came down from heaven (himself), he meant to be understood as affirming that no man among the living had ever gone to heaven. The context seems to warrant such a conclusion. In verse 11 he complains that his witness was not received, though he had seen that to which he bore testimony. In verse 12 he asks how they could believe him if he should speak of heavenly things, inasmuch as they had not credited his statements in regard to earthly things that were somewhat mysterious. In verse 13 he continues the same line of thought by declaring that no one (i. e., among the living) had ascended to heaven save himself; thus giving them to understand, 1. That as no other living man besides himself had been to heaven, he alone was competent to tell them in regard to things therein; 2. That as they had never been there, they had no right to dispute his word in the matter; 3. That if they did not accept his testimony, they must remain ignorant of heavenly things, as there was not another man to whom they could have access who had ever seen them; 4. That so long as they rejected what he said respecting the new birth, which takes place on this earth where all could see its effects, it would be of no use for him to tell them of the greater mysteries of a land which no one among them had ever entered.
251.—THE SPIRITS IN PRISON.
I am told that 1 Pet. 3:18-20 proves that Christ preached to the dead during the three days that his body was in the grave. Is such a doctrine really found in that passage? P. L. A.
ANS. It is not. If it is, then it would conflict with the other scriptures which teach that there is no probation after death; for Christ could have no object in preaching to the dead unless the dead can repent and be converted; but if they can repent and be converted, then there must be probation after death. There is, I believe, no dispute that the parties to whom Christ preached were the antediluvians or their spirits. Verse 18 declares that Christ was quickened by the Spirit, i. e., the Spirit of God. Verse 19, shows that by the same Spirit by which he was quickened (i. e., the Spirit of God) he went and preached to certain spirits in prison. Verse 20 proves that these spirits were disobedient while Noah was building the ark. They must therefore have lived when God for the space of one hundred and twenty years warned men of the coming flood, and offered them pardon provided they would repent. It must be, consequently,—since, as seen above, repentance is not preached to man after death,—that it was offered to them while they were still alive; i. e., in the days of Noah. It was no doubt at that time that Christ by the Spirit of God preached to them through Noah for the purpose of persuading them to repent and be saved. Gen. 6:3.
There are but two apparent objections to this view. One lies in the fact that these mentioned are called spirits; the other, in the fact that they were said to be in prison. By consulting Clarke’s Commentary on 1 Pet. 3:18-20 you will find an extended discussion of this subject in which he proves conclusively that the term “spirits,” as found in these verses, might have been translated persons with perfect propriety. In the same connection he also shows that the expression “in prison,” was applicable to those who lived in the days of Noah, as they were condemned to death, the execution of their sentence being suspended for a time to see if they would repent. For a complete exegesis of this and all other passages usually quoted to prove or disprove the consciousness of the dead, see “Man’s Nature and Destiny.”