THE LAW AND ITS PENALTY.—NO. 2.
By R. M. Kilgore
We must now view our subject from another standpoint, looking at conditions as they have existed since the fundamental was ignored. The Father could extend forgiveness to the erring for the first offense, and restore them to his favor, on condition of repentance and submission. This would be in harmony with his character. But for him to threaten them with immediate and final punishment, without an opportunity to return to their former allegiance, would be contrary to his character. He proclaims himself, “The Lord God, merciful and gracious, longsuffering, and abundant in goodness and truth, keeping mercy for thousands, forgiving iniquity and transgression and sin, and that will by no means clear the guilty.” Ex. 34: 6, 7. He shows mercy; he forgives iniquity, and pardons the transgressor; but when his authority is trampled upon, his law repeatedly ignored, and his mercy slighted, the guilty shall not go unpunished. When sin has become an established fact, then a penalty must be proclaimed. Otherwise, the throne of God is endangered, and his government is imperiled; for rebellion is unlimited in its demands. Evil-doers must be intimidated and brought to justice. The innocent must be protected, and put on their guard against the encroachments of evil workers. Fear is a word which now greets their ears, heretofore unheard, and its meaning unknown. “There is no fear in love; but perfect love casteth out fear; because fear hath torment. He that feareth is not made perfect in love.” 1 John 4: 18. The transition from a state of innocency to that of sin and rebellion changes the relation existing between God and his creatures who are exposed to these influences. His treatment of them, and dealings with them, must also change. The pure and holy ones “kept not their first estate, but left their own habitations.” “God spared not the angels that sinned, but cast them down to hell, and delivered them into chains of darkness, to be reserved unto judgment.” Jude 6; 2 Pet. 2: 4. Now that sin had found a foothold in God’s fair universe, a shield must be thrown around his creature man, who is lower than the angels. He will become the object of assault, and the fierce temptations and deceptions of his fallen foes. He is in danger of being led from the path of love, and will lose his innocency. He must be put on his guard and protected. God’s great “goodness and truth” manifest themselves; and the Two great Commandments are drawn out, and delivered in negative precepts, as relations come into existence requiring them, taking a form somewhat like the following:— The law in its original form was not adapted to man surrounded by sin. To keep man in the right channel the law must take that form which will put him on his guard against entering the wrong channels. If he can be kept from going the wrong road, the result will be he will travel the right one. Hence the “Thou shalt not” is so often repeated. One exception is made, and that is primarily addressed to children, who were to be placed under the care and protection of their parents, whose duty it would be to shield them with precepts of a negative form. While the form of the law is changed, not an additional new duty is imposed that was not embraced in the original enactment. It would be impossible for any creature to love God with all his heart, and violate the precepts in the first table of the new form; or to love his neighbor as himself, and transgress a single one contained in the second table. Hence David says, “I have seen an end of all perfection: but thy commandment is exceeding broad.” Ps. 119: 96. Not a sin can be committed that is not traceable, either directly or indirectly, to a violation of one or more of these negative precepts. Not an approved virtue but that is commanded by them. Truly “the law of the Lord is perfect.” Ps. 19: 7. So perfect was it that when spoken by the voice of the great God, and a copy of it was written with his own finger on two tables of stone, he could add “no more.” Deut. 5: 22. Not even a penalty could be added without changing the nature of the law as originally enacted. The existence of sin necessitates promises of a reward for obedience and faithfulness, of punishments for unfaithfulness and disobedience; also a further revelation divulging the penalty. To illustrate: we will now return to that family who are enjoying the sweet and unalloyed influences of one another’s society on that isolated island. Here, another family, exiled for their wickedness in another land, is transported. The father is a traitor and villain; the sons unite and sympathize with their father in all his crimes. Now listen to that guilty father and mother as soon as they discover their unwelcome neighbors. Hear them relate to their children their history and character. Now it is duty to give them good counsel, and caution them to keep away from those bad boys, telling them they must not do this or that, nor say this or that, nor go here or there; for it is wrong. They will tell them that those wicked451 men were exiled as a punishment for doing evil things, and that God will also punish them in a lake of fire. “Now if you do not obey us we will punish you, and if you die wicked God will also punish you; for the sinners God eternally banishes from his presence.” Man must be tested, and the beautiful garden of Eden is selected as the place where the trial is to be made. Everything lovely and beautiful surrounds him. With one exception, he has unlimited access to all its trees laden with desirable fruit. The test of obedience and loyalty rests on the following expressed conditions:— “And the Lord God commanded the man, saying, Of every tree of the garden thou mayest freely eat; but of the tree of knowledge of good and evil, thou shalt not eat of it; for in the day that thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely die.” Adam could not mistake the nature and intent of the penalty. Theologians tell us that three deaths are embraced in this penalty. Cruden says they are, 1. “Spiritual death, or a separation of soul and body from God’s favor in this life.” 2. “Temporal death, signifying the separation of the soul from the body.” 3. “Eternal death, the perpetual separation of the whole man from God’s heavenly presence and glory, to be tormented forever with the devil and his angels.” Can it be possible that three installments are embraced in the penalty? Let us see. If spiritual death is included, a separation of the sinner from the favor of God is just what he enjoys. His separation has opened up new avenues of thought and knowledge. He knows now what he never would have known. He is pleased at the results. The change is an agreeable one. Says he, “If this is what death is, I am glad I have died. I care not for the favor of God.” If eternal death is included, it destroys the effect of the temporal death; for, once separated, his soul and body remain so eternally. If it is eternal, then man can never live again, for there is no release from it. Eternal death will never relinquish its hold upon its victim. But Paul says: “As in Adam all die, even so in Christ shall all be made alive.” Then man is to be released; therefore it could not mean eternal death. Again: Christ suffered a voluntary death in man’s stead. He has died the same death that man would have had to die. If it was eternal death, then Christ is gone, and his resurrection becomes a fabulous tale. If temporal death is intended, and means the separation of the soul from the body, then it is not death at all; for the soul, which we are told is the real man, escapes all the pain and affliction incident to the death scene, and takes its flight to other regions; if righteous, where greater felicity awaits it, and is, by the transition, made more happy, and it can shout, “I am glad that I have died. I am free, for a time at least, from the body—the old mortal clog.” This, therefore, could not be the intent of the penalty. In the language of another, “We have the authority of Paul for stating that through Christ we are released from all the penalty which the race has incurred through Adam’s transgression. ‘As in Adam all die, even so in Christ shall all be made alive.’ If the death in which we are involved through Adam is death spiritual, temporal, and eternal, then all the race is redeemed from these results through Christ, and Universalism is the result.” We cannot accept this, and we conclude, therefore, that the penalty was a literal death, an utter extinction of life, a cessation of all the faculties of the whole man. This is reasonable, since it reduces man back to the state from which he was brought by his creation. That it is so, the sentence of death pronounced upon Adam after he had sinned serves best to interpret the intent of the Lawgiver. “In the sweat of thy face shalt thou eat bread, till thou return unto the ground; for out of it wast thou taken: for dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return.” The execution of the penalty upon Adam, at the end of his eventful life, illustrates unmistakably the extent of the penalty. “And all the days that Adam lived were nine hundred and thirty years; and he died.” His consignment to the dust was absolute, unless some conditions are expressed that will break death’s unlimited power. In the next paper we will notice the remedy offered to man by which he may be extricated from death’s power.