AdventAI

SCRIPTURE QUESTIONS

By W. H. Littlejohn

From Review and Herald, Vol. 61, No. 28., July 8, 1884

ANSWERS BY W. H. LITTLEJOHN.

252.—THE FOREKNOWLEDGE OF GOD AND THE DAMNATION OF THE SINNER.

1. Did God know in the beginning that any one man whom he would create, would eventually be damned?

2. If so, did he not create that man on purpose to damn him?

3. Is it not reasonable to suppose that God voluntarily closed his eyes in the beginning to the fate of man, in order to avoid responsibility for his final loss?

S. D. A.

Ans. 1. I think that he did. It would be limiting the foreknowledge of God to say that he did not. Infinite knowledge implies a perfect understanding of all the details of every fact and circumstance, which either has taken place or shall take place. The difference between the wisdom of finite man and that of the Infinite One lies right here: The former knows but a few things, and those things imperfectly; the latter knows all things perfectly. A knowledge of general results, with ignorance of the details, is but partial knowledge, and cannot, therefore, be predicated of Jehovah, if it be true that he is infinite in the attribute of wisdom as well as those of power, goodness, etc.

Very many Scripture illustrations of the foreknowledge of God might be adduced if it were necessary to demonstrate that fact. One or two only will be given, and these will be of a nature to prove that his foreknowledge embraces details as well as general results. “And in very deed for this cause have I raised thee up, for to show in thee my power; and that my name may be declared throughout all the earth.” Ex. 9:16. The foregoing had reference to Pharaoh, the king of Egypt. From it we can discover that Pharaoh was placed on the throne of his kingdom because God knew beforehand just what he would do under certain circumstances. Those circumstances were furnished by the pouring out of the plagues. God told Moses beforehand just what those plagues would be, and just what Pharaoh would do and say because of them. Ex. 7:1-6; 3:9-22. But how could the Lord have foretold what Pharaoh and the children of Israel would do and say previous to the time at which they said and did it, unless he was gifted with prescience, or foreknowledge?

Again: we have a record in Ex. 14 which shows that God knew beforehand that Pharaoh and his host would follow the Hebrews, and that they would all be drowned in the Red Sea. But if he knew that Pharaoh and his army were to die under the circumstances under which they did die, then he also knew beforehand that they all would be lost eternally; since the facts attending their destruction rendered their final damnation assured. Should inquiry be made as to when God first knew the particulars respecting the bondage in and the exodus from, Egypt, the reply is, He doubtless did so from the beginning. Certain it is that he predicted that these events would occur, four hundred years before they took place. To Abraham he said: “Know of a surety that thy seed shall be a stranger in a land that is not theirs, and shall serve them; and they shall afflict them four hundred years; and also that nation whom they shall serve, will I judge; and afterward shall they come out with great substance.” Gen. 15:13, 14.

Has any one a doubt that when God addressed the language quoted to Abraham, He knew that it was Jacob who was to go down into Egypt, and not Isaac? Is it not distinctly stated, also, that the captivity of Joseph was a part of God’s great plan in regard to the bondage, the exodus, etc.? Did not God foreknow that Jacob and his family would suffer for bread on account of the anticipated famine, and did he not send Joseph into Egypt years before it occurred in order that he might be prepared to give the necessary relief to his father’s family? If so, then he knew beforehand the details of the history of both Jacob and Joseph, as well as the facts concerning the drought that produced the famine to which allusion is made above. Gen. 41:1-32. Can it be true, therefore, that God was acquainted with these minor details in the history of Jacob and Joseph, and yet was ignorant of that which was of infinitely greater consequence,—their final destiny in the world top. 443 come? To say that he was, would be to take a position which is most absurd.

Again: If God knew that these events would take place twenty, forty, or fifty years before they transpired, then it was possible for him to be acquainted with them for a period of time indefinitely long, or indeed from eternity. A master-builder prepares beforehand his drafts, and in his mind’s eye can see every brace and pin and beam, and makes the necessary provision for them. Assuredly, the great Architect of the universe is not less familiar with the history in detail of the living stones that are to enter into the grand spiritual temple that he is erecting. These stones are the saints of God (1 Pet. 2:5), and in order that each may fill his proper place, it must be known beforehand (1) who are to be saved, and (2) what sort of character they will develop.

As evidence that God has a definite plan for the government of this world, and that he foresees the part which individuals as well as nations are to play in its history, attention might be called to the prophecies which abundantly support such a theory. Isaiah, for example, declared one hundred and seventy-four years before the event took place that Cyrus, mentioning him by name, would overthrow Babylon, and release the Jews from their captivity. Isa. 44:28; Jer. 25:9-11. He also gave quite fully the particulars respecting the overthrow and final disappearance from the map of the world of the great metropolis of the East. Elisha foretold the murder of Benhadad by Hazael, and his future oppression of the people of God. 2 Kings 8:12-15. The rise of the papacy, and the continuance of its persecution of the saints for exactly twelve hundred and sixty years, were predicted over one thousand years before it had any existence.

The Spirit of God revealed to Ananias and to Saul the future ministerial career of the latter, covering many years, and filled up with most important transactions, even before that career had been entered upon. Acts 9:10-15. Christ declared to Peter beforehand the manner of his death. John 21:18, 19. He also foretold the destruction of Jerusalem and the manner of its overthrow, pointed out to the disciples the nature of the event that they should regard as the signal for their flight to the mountains, mentioned the prominent transactions to take place in the history of the Church until the end of the world, announced the death and resurrection of Lazarus, etc., etc. Matt. 24: John 10:1-15.

But why multiply illustrations to prove that God and Christ anticipated the events of history, public and private, and the relation that each individual will sustain to those events? The Bible is full of them; reason also teaches that such must be the case. Just how God is enabled to foreknow these matters, we are of course unable to determine. Nor is this to be wondered at when it is remembered that we are finite in our capabilities while God is infinite in his. It is enough for us to know that things of this nature are true, even though we cannot fathom them, philosophically speaking. Indeed, no man can believe in special providences who does not also believe in foreknowledge; and he who does not believe in special providences knows but little, if anything, of the joys that flow from faith in Christ. Rom. 8:28.

2. To the second question, I answer: No. Foreknowledge on the part of God that a certain individual will eventually be damned, by no means implies that it was the deliberate purpose of the Most High to bring that person into being in order to damn him. That such is the case, might be proved in a variety of ways. If it were true that no good purpose of sufficient importance to justify the creation of a human being could be secured unless that being were to be saved finally, the case would be somewhat different. If, however, it is susceptible of proof that the life of a sinner may be fraught with consequences of infinitely greater moment to God and the universe than is the matter of his individual fate simply, then we must conclude that the securing of these consequences furnished the preponderating motive in the mind of the Deity in bringing that sinner into being, and that the final damnation of the transgressor is the result of his own act rather than the ultimate design of God in bringing him into the world.

Let us test the question, therefore, whether the life of a wicked man who has doomed himself to destruction can be made in any way to contribute to the glory of God and the good of mankind. To do this, let the case of Cain answer for an illustration. His posterity reached many millions in number. From among them, doubtless, a host will be saved. Undeniably, also, those of his posterity who will be lost will greatly exceed those who will be saved; but the time will ultimately be reached when those of the descendants of Cain who are to be lost will have suffered according to their deserts, and will have ceased to be; while those among his posterity who have been true to duty will have entered upon a life of glory and felicity that will measure with the life of God. Obad. 17; Ps. 37:29-40. In view of these reflections, will any man say that it would have been better if Cain had not existed? Again: in view of these same considerations, who will urge that the temporary punishment of the first murderer and those of his offspring who were like him in character, furnish to Jehovah the real motive for creating him? Is it not obvious to the most casual observer that he who knows the end from the beginning gave to the first son of Adam a place among the living because he saw that his existence would result in more good than harm when the endlessness of the reward of the good who should descend from him was taken into the account? So, too, in the case of every transgressor who has ever lived. Either directly or indirectly his existence was in some way necessary to the realization of a plan that is, as a whole, infinitely beneficent. We read that the redeemed shall be made up from men of every nation, kindred, tongue, and people on the whole earth. Rev. 7:9. It follows, therefore, that the great majority, though not saved themselves, are the progenitors of those who are to be saved, and consequently that the creation of such was by no means in vain.

Were it true that in a few instances wicked men should have left behind them no children, still it would by no means follow that they have not filled an important place in God’s great plan. In so vast a machine as human society there are many pins and bolts that could not be dispensed with without injury to all concerned, and yet the unpractical eye might fail to detect the necessity for the existence of these pins and bolts. Men act and re-act upon each other. Every word that a man utters, and every act that he performs, leave their impress upon those about him. The Scriptures well say that no man liveth to himself or dieth to himself. The great events of history are the resultants of many small acts and words, even as the mighty flood that sweeps everything before it, is made up of the myriads of raindrops that, having fallen on hill and mountain and in the valley, have at last been gathered by rivulet and brook and stream, until they have united in the formation of the resistless torrent.

Thus it is seen that it is not requisite that one should believe that God has made any man for the sole purpose of damning him. Such a conclusion is monstrous in the extreme. To damn means to condemn, and in the Scriptures it usually carries with it the idea of punishment. But punishment is retributive, and therefore implies wrong-doing on the part of the one punished. Again: wrong-doing pre-supposes free moral agency; but if God has made any man for the express purpose of damning him, then God would be a fiend, and the man in question, however wicked, would be deserving of universal sympathy. The whole difficulty arises from a perversion of both reason and Scripture. Admit the doctrine of free moral agency on the part of men as it is taught in the word of God, and evidenced by the experience of every person, and the subject is relieved of all embarrassment. God made his creatures free as it regards the ability to do right or wrong; because such freedom was necessary to the dignity of manhood. Having sinned, he lets them live for a variety of reasons, among which are (1) that they may repent and reform; (2) because it is necessary that the wicked should be permitted to exist in order that from their posterity the righteous may be developed and other features in the great plan of salvation realized.

3. I answer emphatically, No! I am aware that in making this reply I am differing quite widely with some whose judgment I value very highly; but if I answer your question at all I must do so in harmony with my own convictions. To my mind, such a course would be entirely unworthy of the Deity, as it would indicate either moral cowardice or ignorance of the plainest principles that enter into the question of responsibility. To say that God’s foreknowledge of events would excuse any man for doing the wrong that God foreknew he would do, would, as we have seen, exonerate men for every sin that they may commit. Were not the crucifixion of Christ and the very insults that his enemies offered him, predicted centuries before they occurred? If so, then God foreknew that they would take place. But does it therefore follow that the murderers of the Saviour were not accountable for what they did? You answer, No. But the same principle that governs in that case governs in all. If the fact that God knew what they would do before they did it in no wise affected their accountability, then his foreknowledge would not affect the accountability of other transgressors. Admitting that this is the case, then it must be conceded that God would not have closed his eyes to the prospective career of any man for the sake of any benefit which might accrue to that person. It must be, therefore, that if he did it at all, it was in order that he might shield himself from the charge of creating men whom he knew were destined to be lost. But who does not see that such a plea would prove to be no defense to the Almighty (if indeed he needed any) for bringing into being those whom he will ultimately cast off? The Saviour once said to a certain class, “This is your condemnation, that light came into the world, and ye received it not because your deeds were evil.” John 3:19. We are just as responsible for refusing or neglecting to obtain the light that we might have, as we are for failing to act upon that which we have already. The man who should hurl a hand-grenade into a crowd, and then offer in defense for the murder thus committed that he had closed his eyes before he performed the murderous act, and that consequently he was not responsible for the results, would be treated in the most summary manner by the court. This plea would fasten upon him the crime with which he was charged so firmly that no power under heaven could release him from the punishment prescribed by the statute. Neither would the fact that he had closed his eyes at the time he did the deed secure for him the least abatement from the penalty. Indeed it would rather aggravate his offense, by proving that it was characterized by that deliberation and coolness that are at all times the highest evidence of desperate criminality in the offender. Just so with the mighty God of the universe. The closing of his eyes to the fate of those whom he was about to create would in no wise affect the character of the deed which he intended to perform. But it would reflect upon the rectitude of his purpose and the perfection of his wisdom.

We repeat, therefore, in conclusion, that the great God, when bringing man into existence, and granting to him all the possibilities of glorious immortality, was engaged in a work so beneficent in its nature that he might with the most perfect propriety use the very words that he did actually employ at the close of the sixth day of creation, on which man was made: “And God saw everything that he had made, and, behold, it was very good.” Gen. 1:13.

253.—ADAM’S FIRST DAY VS. GOD’S SEVENTH DAY.

If A. M. C. will send to the REVIEW AND HERALD Office for the work entitled “Synopsis of Present Truth” (price $1.00), she will find in it, among other things, a complete refutation of the theory that God’s seventh day was Adam’s first day. The subject is one that would require so much space for the proper discussion of it, that it could not be examined properly in the question department. All that we can say here is, when a mother would be justified in calling the day following the one on which a child was born, the first day of its existence, or when it would be proper for a bridegroom and bride to date the commencement of their married life from the day that succeeded the one on which they were legally united in wedlock, then, and not till then, will it be true that God’s seventh day was Adam’s first day. The force of these remarks will be felt fully when it is remembered that Adam and Eve were made and became man and wife on God’s sixth day.