We recently heard it said of a minister who occupied one of the most conspicuous pulpits in America, that he had little or no hold upon either the consciences or affections of his people, and that there was deep dissatisfaction with his ministrations. Practically, the man has proved a failure. And yet he is not an antiquated, desiccated specimen of a theologian. He has kept abreast of what is called the advanced thought of the age. He has no narrow-gauge views of either faith or practice. “No pent-up Utica” contracts his powers. He doesn’t indulge in cant, and abhors a holy tone. His sermons sparkle with gems of thought, brim with humor, and are enriched with elegant epigrammatic forms of expression. He is bright, smart, happy; but his whole spirit and speech indicate the professional performer, rather than the earnest and spiritual ambassador who has just come from God’s presence into the presence of his people, and who is directly going back into God’s presence to report. Nobody thinks of him as a man “full of faith and of the Holy Ghost,” but full of fun and all manner of jokes. People come away from the service saying, not, We have heard great and awful truths to-day; but, “I tell you, he’s smart”—the thought being rather of the preacher than of the preacher’s theme, than which there could be no surer and sadder evidence that he is failing to fulfill his high vocation. He makes the impression of levity and insincerity, and so he utterly fails to make men feel the overshadowing powers of the world to come.
On the other hand, who has not been awed and almost overwhelmed in the presence of some humble, and comparatively uncultured man, whose whole deportment made us to feel that he had been with Jesus? The very presence of such a man in a church is a benediction, and though he makes havoc of “the king’s English,” his words for all that are like “apples of gold in pictures of silver.” They have weight, and that is a great matter with words spoken in the name of the Lord.
In the case of the minister to whom we made reference in the beginning, we do not affirm that he is insincere, but merely that he has cultivated a carriage and a style of speech that produce an impression of insincerity. He has possibly simply fallen into bad habits—for we are bound to take the most hopeful view—or that he is overdone with a certain sort of culture that has damaged the development of his spiritual life; but in any event the effect is such as is deeply to be deplored.—Baptist Teacher.