THE unfavorable criticisms provoked and the misapprehensions which arise respecting sermons are not chargeable to the preaching alone, in all cases. The hearing is often in fault, as well. An excellent discourse becomes very ordinary in the hands of a bad hearer, while a poor one may be made quite tolerable and profitable by being rightly heard.
As to the preaching: 1. It ought to be clear. If there is any place that demands perspicuity of style, it is the pulpit. If there is any theme that deserves a lucid treatment, it is the gospel. As the aim of preaching is instruction in order to faith, with a view to the salvation of men, obscurity, from whatever cause, is to be studiously avoided. “If the trumpet give an uncertain sound, who shall prepare himself to the battle?” When Ezra and those who officiated with him read the law before the people, they caused the people to understand the law. “So they read in the book of the law of God distinctly, and gave the sense, and caused them to understand the reading.” Neh. 8 : 8. Paul’s advice is, “Seek that ye may excel to the edifying of the church;” and for himself he says, “Yet in the church I had rather speak five words with my understanding, that by my voice I might teach others also, than ten thousand words in an unknown tongue.” Preaching that is not clear neither instructs the mind nor moves the heart. It neither edifies nor saves.
2. Preaching ought to be scriptural. “Preach the word.” Let it agree with the Scriptures, whether it accords with the theologians or not. The dangerous places in the sermon are where fancy is indulged in and speculation ventured upon. When we stick to what is revealed we are on safe ground. “If any man speak, let him speak as the oracles of God.”
3. Preaching should lift up Christ, that men may see and know him. It is not to be with excellency of speech or of wisdom, for the purpose of displaying the learning or eloquence of the preacher. No language is too chaste with which to set forth Christ and his claims. There is no learning too extensive with which to unfold the treasures of the word. Follow Paul, who says: “And my speech and my preaching was not with enticing words of man’s wisdom, but in demonstration of the Spirit and of power: that your faith should not stand in the wisdom of men, but in the power of God.”
As to the hearing: 1. Men, generally, are as inaccurate in their hearing as in their speaking. It is, hence, no unusual or strange thing for a speaker to be misunderstood. Hearing well is an art to be acquired. The habit of fixed attention is to be formed. There is need of ready apprehension, knowledge of language, power of discrimination, and facility in drawing conclusions, such as must necessarily be left to the hearer himself.
2. Hearing should be done with fairness and charity. Let the preacher have the benefit of a doubt, where one exists as to his meaning. Credit him with orthodoxy until he is clearly and unquestionably heterodox. If his language bears two constructions, adopt the best one, for his sake. Sometimes equivocal terms are used through an inadvertence of the speaker. Some allowance should be made for man’s fallibility. No one is absolutely correct at all times and in all particulars. The judgment, taste, and perception are liable to faults. Departures from the truth are more frequently undesigned than malicious.
3. It is evident that all hearers do not hear alike. Different minds are impressed by different statements, and differently impressed by the same utterance. Two men look at an imposing scene in nature, or a great work of art, and one is attracted by one feature, the other by a different one. Their descriptions of the object viewed might, therefore, differ in some particulars, but not be contradictory. Witnesses often vary in the details of their testimony, while their statements are not inconsistent with each other. So, in our congregations, we have varying witnesses of what is uttered in the pulpit, who have seized and retained, each for himself, what, according to his state of mind, needs, or taste, made an impression upon him. To all such as listen to the word, there is one charge of great gravity: “Take heed how ye hear”; and to all, this: “Let every man be swift to hear, slow to speak, slow to wrath.”—P. C. B. in the Interior.