AdventAI

The Danger of Socialism

From Review and Herald, Vol. 61, No. 26., June 24, 1884

Writing in review of Professor Ely’s “French and German Socialism” in the current Methodist Quarterly, Dr. Whedon concludes that we are by no means free from the danger of Socialism. And he adds: “Our two palliatives are universal suffrage, which greatly forestalls resorts to violence, and the absence of entails, which divides up great estates. But legislation must have a sharp eye to the dangers of war between capital and toil.” If Socialism were purely political in character as relating to government, the evil of universal and largely illiterate suffrage might act as a palliative; but in the present aspect of the matter universal suffrage does not seem desirable;—certainly it has worked injury here where men are driven to the polls, and votes are bought as meat at the shambles. Here we would like to have suffrage less universal. But in this country when Socialism shows its head, it will take an agrarian form, and it will wage war, not on the government as in Europe, but on the huge corporate monopolies which were unknown when this government was established. The fact is, and it will not “down,” we are fast drifting into a socialist, or, as it is called, an anti-monopoly war, which not only carries a bad outlook for the corporations, but for the laboring man as well. It is a clear case where in avoiding Scylla the ship runs its bow against Charybdis. In fact, Mr. Herbert Spencer’s “Coming Slavery” seems to have already come, as illustrated by a recent occurrence in Philadelphia.

It seems a large manufacturing firm in that city found that it would be necessary to reduce either the number or the wages of its employees. The facts of the case were fully and fairly stated to the men, who at once decided to accept a reduction of wages rather than have any of their number discharged; and in this amicable way the matter was supposed to be settled. But at this juncture an outside organization stepped in, and declared that the workingmen who were members of the society had neither the right nor the “power to negotiate rates of wages with their employers,” and they ordered the men to quit work; and the poor slaves, to the number of six hundred and fifty-nine, felt it their duty to obey their masters. This is a striking illustration of the fact that mankind are constructed upon pretty much the same lines, and that the man who figures as manufacturer or laborer is equally inclined to lord it over his fellows when the first occasion arises. Trades unions have accomplished good, and they have done incalculable harm. In either case as between the triumph of capital and trades unions, it is a case of bossism, involving the issue which shall be master and which slave. To determine this we need neither more capital nor a larger number of trades unions. But we need education in the moralities, and the prevalence of religion; and positively we do not need that extension of universal suffrage which, if Mr. Spencer’s conclusions are logically followed out, will place a ballot in the child’s hand that holds the rattle, and the one will answer the same purpose as the other.—Christian at Work.