DEFEAT OF JUSTICE

25%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 24, 1884

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 61, No. 26.

Read the full edition

DEFEAT OF JUSTICE.

It seems to stand without denial that the death penalty in this country is really informally abolished. In this city alone last year there were sixty-eight murders and three executions; and during the same time there were in the United States over 1,500 convictions for murder—we do not know how many thousand murders were committed—and only ninety-three of these fifteen hundred were hanged. These facts are almost incredible, but they are nevertheless true, and are in sharp contrast with the statistics of other nations, as set forth by Mr. Mulhall in his Statistical Dictionary, which clearly show that murders exceed by three hundred per cent in this country the number committed in England, France, or Germany. Mr. Mulhall shows murders to abound as follows:—
Country Murders to 10,000,000 population
England 237
Belgium 240
France 265
Scandinavia 266
Germany 279
Ireland 294
Austria 310
Russia 323
Italy 504
Spain 533
United States 820
This is food for the thoughtful man, and indicates that capital punishment laws are far less a deterrent of crime here than in any other country. Why? The reason is not hard to find. The popular unwillingness to take life has led to the providing of successive appeals. In our own State no murderer need be hung for a year after his trial if his counsel but resort to the appeals provided for by law, which he always does if a little money for the payment of expenses is insured. Then, bribery is a common element in the jury box. The bribed juryman falls back upon “conscientious scruples,” or something of the kind, and compromise finally comes to the relief of a tired jury, and the sentence of imprisonment for life, with possible commutation later, follows. The bribed juror speedily disappears in the crowd, is lost sight of, has pocketed his bribe, and very likely removes to some other place. The London Spectator hits the truth when it declares that the “sound American majority is too easy-going;—it will enforce its will at intervals, but it will not keep up the incessant watchfulness” needful to constant security. We indeed suppress mobs where monarchical governments would hesitate to shoot them down—Cincinnati is a case in point—but we do not demand the constant, unvarying, stern enforcement of the law. Clearly the laws must be changed in the direction of increased severity or laxity: we must take away the pretexts by which the penalties are delayed and ultimately escaped, or we must modify our laws to such a degree that juries will not hesitate to enforce them.—Christian at Work.