In last week’s REVIEW mention was made of a sermon by W. F. Crafts, in advocacy of a more strict observance of Sunday, which he calls the Sabbath, in which he urged its recognition as a religious institution. But many of the world’s people are learning how to answer the vain and foolish arguments of the clergy on this point, as the accompanying article plainly shows. A writer signing himself “Truth-Teller,” in the Chicago Tribune of July 29, though erroneously calling the Sabbath a Mosaic institution, answers Mr. Crafts’ arguments in the following forcible style:—
“A clerical gentleman, Mr. W. F. Crafts, now of the First Union Presbyterian Church of New York, delivered a long discourse Sunday evening in the First Congregational Church, West Side, on the topic, ‘The Continental Sunday and the Danger of its Introduction into America.’ The discourse is a singular admixture of false assumption and erroneous deduction. He persisted in treating the Constantine Sunday as the same institution as the holy Sabbath of the Jews instituted by Moses 1,800 years before Constantine was born! Throughout his entire discourse Mr. Crafts slurred over and ignored the vital point that the Sabbath-day and Sunday are not the same day at all. He concealed from his hearers the fact that the ‘holy Sabbath-day’ is the seventh or last day of the week, whereas Sunday is the first day of the week. He concealed from his audience the reason given in the Jewish Scriptures for the institution of the Sabbath-day, and he also concealed from them the truth that there is no scriptural authority either in the Old or New Testament for discarding the seventh day of the week or Saturday as the Sabbath, and substituting the first day of the week or Sunday as a holy day. It is a wonder that some man did not rise in the audience and ask Mr. Crafts for his authority for abolishing the Sabbath of Moses and substituting the Sunday of Constantine. It would have surely puzzled the clerical gentleman to explain it satisfactorily or to show that Sunday is the day specified in the fourth commandment. Mr. Crafts took for his text a passage from the last chapter of Nehemiah, denouncing the ‘profanation’ of Saturday—not Sunday; of the last day of the week instead of the first. Why did not Mr. Crafts point out this fact to his hearers? Was it honest or truthful to suppress it? If he had turned to the twentieth chapter of Exodus and read from the 8th to the 11th verses, inclusive, his audience would have heard the fourth commandment stated and explained. The reason is there given why Moses selected the seventh or last day of the week instead of the first or some other day of the week. The reason for keeping Saturday is that, ‘in six days the Lord made heaven and earth, the seas and all that in them is, and rested on the seventh day [last day of the week] wherefore the Lord blessed the Sabbath-day [last day of the week] and hallowed it.’ The same commandment also explicitly commands: ‘Six days shalt thou labor and do all thy work [viz.: Sunday, Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday], but the seventh day [Saturday] is the Sabbath [or resting day] of the Lord thy God; in it thou shalt not do any work,’ etc.
“These passages from Moses’ writings explain the whole Sunday business,—its origin, the particular day chosen for rest, and the reason therefor.
“Now the day selected by the Rev. Crafts for a holy day turns the whole thing wrong end foremost. He insists that everybody shall rest and worship on the very day the Almighty, according to Moses, ordered his chosen people to work and do secular business! On the first day of the week (Sunday) God, according to Moses, began his great work of creation. By Friday night, or the sixth day, he had completed it, and Saturday, the seventh or last day of the week, he had finished his labors and rested. God, as per Moses, commanded his chosen people to imitate his example and do likewise, and they have strictly observed the order for 3,700 years.
“Where does Mr. Crafts get his Scripture authority for upsetting all this arrangement, and ordering people to be idle on the day the Almighty began to labor, and to work on the very day that Jehovah commanded them to rest, and to rest on the day that he directed them to begin working? Mr. Crafts knows very well that there is no divine authority for abolishing the Sabbath (last day of the week) as a holy day and substituting the heathen day of the sun (Sun’s day). He is well aware that the first day of the week is not the ‘Sabbath-day’ of the Bible, and that no Scriptural injunction or command applies to it, and if he was candid and honest with his congregation he would confess the fact. As a theological student, Mr. Crafts knows that the first day of the week (Sunday) had its first official recognition in an edict of the Emperor Constantine in 321, ordering that all work should cease in the cities Sunday, but permitting necessary husbandry to be attended to by the farmers. In the early ages of Christianity it was not supposed that Sunday had taken the place of the holy Sabbath established by Jehovah himself, according to Moses and inspired Scripture. Sunday as a religious day is called the ‘Lord’s day,’ and traces its origin as such to a practice of the early Christians to meet early Sunday morning to celebrate the resurrection of Christ. It was purely a voluntary practice until Constantine issued his edict, and it is not the Sabbath of the Bible, and its observance has no relation to the work of creation, or the rest of the Almighty on the seventh day from his six days’ labor. Our Sunday is not the Sabbath of the Bible, and has no divine origin, but is a human institution begun among the early Christians to commemorate Christ’s resurrection, by an early morning service, and was made a holiday by a Constantinople monarch, and was never observed by any Christian people as an austere holy day, except by the Puritans and those whom they could influence in this country and Great Britain. The continental observance of Sunday at present is practically the same as it always has been ever since Constantine issued his edict in A. D. 321. Mr. Crafts is undoubtedly aware of all these facts, but it don’t suit his craft to avow them from his pulpit.”