AdventAI

The Sabbath and the First Day of the Week in Early Christianity

By R. F. Cottrell

From Review and Herald, Vol. 61, No. 35., August 26, 1884

THE SABBATH AND THE FIRST DAY OF THE WEEK IN THE FIRST CENTURIES OF THE CHRISTIAN ERA.—NO. 4.

In his “History of the Sabbath,” Eld Andrews truly says: “The festival of Sunday is more ancient than the Christian religion, its origin being lost in remote antiquity. It did not originate, however, from any divine command nor from piety toward God: on the contrary, it was set apart as a sacred day by the heathen world in honor of their chief God, the sun. It is from this fact that the first day of the week has obtained the name of Sunday, a name by which it is known in many languages. Webster thus defines the word: ‘Sunday; so called because this day was anciently dedicated to the sun, or to its worship; the first day of the week; the Christian Sabbath; the day consecrated to rest from secular employments, and to religious worship; the Lord’s day.’”

Many testimonies might be quoted to the same effect. The North British Review defends its introduction into the Christian church as follows:—

“That very day was the Sunday of their heathen neighbors and respective countrymen, and patriotism gladly united with expediency in making it at once their Lord’s day and their Sabbath. . . . If the authority of the church is to be ignored altogether by Protestants, there is no matter; because opportunity and common expediency are surely argument enough for so ceremonial a change as the mere day of the week for the observance of the rest and holy convocation of the Jewish Sabbath. The primitive church, in fact, was shut up to the adoption of Sunday, until it became established and supreme, when it was too late to make another alteration; and it was no irreverent nor undelightful thing to adopt it, inasmuch as the first day of the week was their own high day at any rate; so that their compliance and civility were rewarded by the redoubled sanctity of their quiet festival.”

Other testimonies of like character might be quoted. The careful reader will notice that no divine command is given as a reason for the change, but it is treated as a mere matter of human choice; “opportunity and common expediency” are thought to be “argument enough for so ceremonial a change.” Their heathen neighbors observed Sunday as a festival to their chief god; they could not change the custom, and so they were “shut up to the adoption of Sunday.” Was it not patriotism, expediency, and civility, that caused the Jewish church so frequently to adopt the customs of their heathen neighbors and worship their gods?

The first testimony in behalf of first-day observance which has any claim to be regarded as genuine, is that of Justin Martyr, written about A. D. 140. He wrote an apology in behalf of the Christians to the Roman emperor. It is evident from his language that the Sunday was at that time widely celebrated by the heathen in honor of their god, the sun. He mentions in his apology three times that the Christians held the assemblies on the day of general observance. Sunday therefore makes its first appearance in the Christian church as identical in time with the weekly festival of the heathen; and Justin, who first mentions this festival, had himself been a heathen philosopher.

It is evident that in the first observance in the Christian church of the first day of the week as a festival, it stood no higher in authority than other voluntary festivals. Mosheim says:—

“Many also observe the fourth day of the week, on which Christ was betrayed; and the sixth, which was the day of the crucifixion.”

Says Heylyn:—

“Take which you will, either the fathers or the moderns, and we shall find no Lord’s day instituted by any apostolic mandate; no Sabbath set on foot by them upon the first day of the week.”

Domville says:—

“Not any ecclesiastical writer of the first three centuries attributed the origin of Sunday observance either to Christ or to his apostles.”

Dr. Edwards, in his Sabbath Manual, testifies as follows:—

“Hence Irenæus, bishop of Lyons, a disciple of Polycarp, who had been the companion of the apostles, A. D. 167, says that the Lord’s day was the Christian Sabbath. His words are, ‘On the Lord’s day every one of us Christians keep the Sabbath meditating on the law and rejoicing in the works of God.’”

Of this testimony Sir Wm. Domville says:—

“I have carefully searched through all the extant works of Irenæus, and can with certainty state that no such passage, or any at all resembling it, is there to be found. The edition I consulted was that of Massuet (Paris, 1710); but to assure myself still further, I have since looked to the editions by Erasmus (Paris, 1563), and Grabe (Oxford, 1702), and in neither do I find the passage in question.”

Those who quote this testimony refer the reader to Dwight’s Theology, instead of Irenæus. Where did Dr. Dwight obtain this testimony? Mr. Domville says of Dwight:—

“He had the misfortune to be afflicted with a disease in his eyes from the early age of twenty-three, a calamity (says his biographer), by which he was deprived of the capacity of reading and study. The knowledge which he gained from books after the period above mentioned was almost exclusively at second hand, by the aid of others.”

Domville states another fact which without doubt gives us the origin of this quotation:—

“But although not to be found in Irenæus, there are in the writings of another father, namely, in the interpolated epistle of Ignatius to the Magnesians, and in one of its interpolated passages, expressions so clearly resembling those of Dr. Dwight’s quotation as to leave no doubt of the source from which he quoted.”

“Such, then, is the end,” says Eld. Andrews, “of this famous testimony of Irenæus, who had it from Polycarp, who had it from the apostles!”

A few extracts from Chambers’ Encyclopedia, the edition of 1880, shall close this paper:—

“Hitherto we have spoken of the observance of Saturday, the day of rest prescribed to the Jews, and to which exclusively the name of Sabbath day was anciently applied, and still continues to be given by every nation but our own and its offshoots. At what date the Sunday, or the first day of the week, began to be generally used by Christians as a stated time for religious meetings, we have no definite information either in the New Testament or in the writings of the fathers of the church. By none of the fathers before the fourth century is it identified with the Sabbath, nor is the duty of observing it grounded by them either on the fourth commandment or any precept or example of Jesus or his apostles, or on any ante-Mosaic law promulgated to mankind at the creation and continuing in force after the coming of Christ.”

“Unquestionably the first law, either ecclesiastical or civil, by which the sabbatical observance of that day is known to have been ordained, is the edict of Constantine, A. D. 321.”

“But it was not till the year 538 that abstinence from agricultural labor on Sunday was recommended, rather than enjoined, by an ecclesiastical authority (the third council of Orleans), and this expressly ‘that the people might have more leisure to go to church and say their prayers.’”

From these extracts we learn, 1. That Sunday Sabbath-keeping, unlike every other institution human or divine, is without a date, unless it dates from the edict of Constantine. 2. That none of the fathers before the fourth century grounded its observance on the fourth commandment, or on any precept or example of Christ or his apostles. 3. That agriculturists had no Sabbath till the council of Orleans gave them one, A. D. 538, the very year which begins the 1260 years of papal rule. 4. That the reason for this was that the people might have more leisure, implying that they were in the habit of laboring on that day. Truly the “Christian Sabbath,” unlike any divine institution, came into being “gradually,” without a beginning date. Apostasy generally appears gradually.

R. F. COTTRELL.