(See Instructor of October 15, 1884.)
(NATURE OF MAN.)
CRITICAL NOTES.
ECCLESIASTES 12:1, 5-7. Verse 1.—We are taught in this verse that the best time to seek the Lord is now, in youth, and the sooner the better. And experience abundantly proves that it is easier to believe, hope, pray, love, and obey than it can be in old age, when all the vital powers are impaired, and evil habits are firmly fixed. Old age is represented as a very disadvantageous time to seek God. Its days are called “evil days,” and no pleasure is taken in them as they glide along. Infirmities of mind and body weigh down the individual; he has little inclination to engage in religious exercises, and finds it hard to do so if he would. Of course all this is upon the condition that he has put off giving his heart to the Lord until old age. In Christ his last days may be peaceful and serene, full of the purest pleasure and the deepest joy. In a series of beautiful metaphors the infirmities of old age are set forth in the verses which follow, until finally the “mourners go about the streets,” and man is borne to his long home, the grave, where he waits for his change, not being awakened or raised out of his sleep until the heavens are no more. Job 14:10-14.
Verse 6.—In this verse death is represented by four metaphors. With Clarke it is quite easy to apply these as follows: The silver cord means the spinal cord, which resembles silver in color and preciousness; its loosing, the letting down of the nervous system just before death, “the last loosing being the fall of the under jaw, the invariable and never-failing evidence of immediate death.” The golden bowl is the brain, in the cranium. It is called a bowl from its resemblance to such a vessel, the container, the skull, being put for the thing contained, the brain. It is said to be broken at death because it is rendered unfit to perform its functions. The fountain is the heart, the spring whence the blood gushes up; and the pitcher is the vena cava, the great vein which brings the blood back to the right ventricle of the heart. The cistern is the left ventricle; and the wheel is the great aorta, the artery which receives the blood from the left ventricle and distributes it to different parts of the system.
This is the application made by Dr. Clarke; but there is one evident inconsistency to be seen in the fact that a pitcher is not used to bear water to the fountain as the vena cava brings blood to the heart. Perhaps, after all it was not intended that a minute application of each figure be made to some organ of the body. If so, commentators have made sorry work in finding the right interpretation; for some have made the silver cord mean the lacteal vessel of the breast, and the golden bowl mean the brain, the heart, or the gall, while the pitcher has in turn stood for the liver, the lymph, the stomach, and the chyle, and the wheel has signified the kidneys, urinary passages, and bladder, or the peristaltic motions of the bowels, or the motion of the lungs! All this confusion arises from the fact that it is easy to find a likeness where many exist; but almost impossible to be certain of the particular likeness the author had in mind when he wrote.
It seems to me these interpretations are all too minute. They look for the likeness at too great a depth; I think it lies nearer the surface. Before pointing it out, however, let me call attention to the fact that the word for bowl is in Zech. 4:2, 3, used to signify a vessel for oil, or an oil lamp. It may signify the same here. We have, then, in the verse three distinct pictures, and all are marred. Before being marred they all fitly represent man in life; after being marred, they as fitly represent him in death. First, we have a lamp with a golden bowl, suspended by a silver chain; so is man in life,—useful, ornamental, pleasing: but now the chain is severed, or the bowl is broken; so is man in death,—usefulness gone, beauty destroyed, to the senses repulsive. Secondly, we see a person at a fountain with a pitcher to draw; but the pitcher is broken at the fountain, and becomes a useless thing and a source of disappointment. Like this is man in death,—alike useless and disappointing. The wheel broken at the cistern teaches the same lesson.
Verse 7. “In the examination of this text, and all others of a like nature, let it ever be remembered that the question at issue is, Has man in his nature a constituent element, which is an independent entity; and which, when the body dies, keeps right on in uninterrupted consciousness, being capable of exercising in a still higher degree out of the body all the functions of intelligence and activity which it manifested through the body, and destined, whether a subject of God’s favor, or of his threatened and merited wrath, to live so long as God himself exists?”
“Does this text assert anything of this kind? Does it state that from which even such an inference can be drawn? We invite the reader to go with us, while we endeavor to consider carefully what the text really teaches. Our opponents appeal to it as direct testimony. Let us see how far we can go with them.”
“1. Solomon, under a series of beautiful figures, speaks in Eccl. 12:1-7 of the lying down of man in death. Granted.”
“2. Dust, or the body, and spirit are spoken of as two distinct things. Granted.”
“3. At death, the spirit leaves the body. Granted.”
“4. The spirit is disposed of in a different manner from the body. Granted.”
“5. The spirit returns to God. Granted.”
“6. This spirit is therefore conscious, after the dissolution of the body. Not granted.”
“Where is the proof of this? Here our paths diverge from each other. But how could the spirit return to God, it is asked, if it was not conscious?”
“Answer: In the manner Job describes. ‘If he [God] set his heart upon man, if he gather unto himself his spirit and his breath, all flesh shall perish together, and man shall turn again to dust.’ Job 34:14, 15. This text speaks of God’s gathering to himself the breath of man: something which no one supposes to be capable of a separate conscious existence. Moreover, this spirit and breath, given for awhile to man, God calls his own; and depriving man of it he calls ‘gathering it to himself,’ an expression fully as strong as ‘the spirit shall return to God who gave it.’ This proposition we are therefore compelled to reject as unsustained.”
“7. This spirit is therefore to exist forever. This conclusion also we fail to see, either expressed or even in the remotest manner implied. Thus the only two propositions which are vital to the position for which our friends contend, are wholly assumed.”
“But if the word ‘spirit’ here does not mean what it is popularly supposed to mean, what is its signification? and what is it that returns to God? It will be noticed that that which returns to God is something which God at first ‘gave’ to man. And Solomon introduces it in a familiar manner, as if alluding to something already recorded and well understood. He makes evident reference to the creation of man in the beginning. His body was formed of the dust; and in addition to this, what did God do for man or give unto him?—He breathed into his nostrils the breath of life. This is the only spirit that is distinctly spoken of as having been given by God to man. No one claims that this, like the body, was from the dust, or returns to dust; but it does not therefore follow that it is conscious or immortal.”—Nature and Destiny, pp. 66-69.
Genesis 5:7:—Upon this passage the following candid admissions are taken from Prof. Bush’s commentary on Genesis:—
“The phrase ‘living soul’ is in the foregoing narrative repeatedly applied to the inferior orders of animals which are not considered to be possessed of a ‘soul’ in the sense in which that term is applied to man. It would seem to mean the same, therefore, when spoken of man that it does when spoken of beasts, viz., an animated being, a creature possessed of life and sensation, and capable of performing all the physical functions by which animals are distinguished, as eating, drinking, walking, etc. . . . Indeed, it may be remarked that the Scriptures generally afford much less explicit evidence of the existence of a sentient immaterial principle in man, capable of living and acting separate from the body, than is usually supposed.”
Calvin also says: “Whatever the greater part of the ancients might think, I do not hesitate to subscribe to the opinion of those who explain this passage of the animal life of man; and thus I expound what they call the vital spirit, by the word breath.”—Commentary, Vol. 1, p. 112.
C. C. L.