BY N. J. BOWERS.
In the Chicago Weekly Inter Ocean of May 8, 1884, in its S. S. Lesson Department, are some statements copied from the Christian Union concerning the resurrection of the body, upon which, from the character of that paper as a representative church periodical, and from the reputation of the author of the statements, who is said to be “one of the oldest and best known Sunday-school teachers in the country,” and from the nature of the statements themselves, I have thought it proper to make some comments.
The author in question is, if I mistake not, the editor of the publication referred to, and a gentleman of Christian character and note in the religious world; and it is for this reason to be the more regretted that he has published statements to the world so utterly in opposition to the plain declarations of God’s word. In this is fulfilled that old and true saying, “Great men are not always wise.” Job 32: 9. Is it any wonder that there is so much open and undisguised disbelief in the revealed truths of the Bible among the masses, when Christian teachers themselves open the way by perverting or mystifying its obvious and plain teachings ? Indeed, the marvelous thing is that there is not more.
1. The writer says: 1. “I do not believe in the resurrection of the body.” I reply, here is a flat denial of one of the plainest doctrines of the New Testament. Read Mark 12: 25, 26; Luke 20: 35–38; Matt. 22: 29–32; Luke 14: 14; John 5: 28, 29; 11: 23, 25; Acts 23: 6; 24: 15; 26: 8; Rom. 8: 11, 23; 1 Cor. 15: 35, 51–55; Phil. 3: 21; 1 Thess. 4: 14–16. These statements of the Lord Jesus Christ and of his chief apostle are plain, and admit of no question. They at once and forever settle the matter if their words mean anything at all. If they teach any kind of resurrection at all, they teach the resurrection of the body.
2. “The phrase, ‘resurrection of the body,’ does not occur in the Bible.” This may be granted; but the doctrine of the bodily resurrection is plainly taught in the Bible, as I have shown. (See references just given). However, the prophet Isaiah says: “Thy dead men shall live, together with my dead body shall they arise. Awake and sing, ye that dwell in the dust: for thy dew is as the dew of herbs, and the earth shall cast out the dead.” Isa. 26: 19. The dead body shall arise, shall be resurrected. “The earth shall cast out the dead.” Matthew says: “And the graves were opened; and many bodies of the saints which slept arose, and came out of the graves after his resurrection, and went into the holy city, and appeared to many.” Matt. 27: 52, 53. Here we have in the Old Testament and in the New, expressions very similar to the phrase “resurrection of the body,” so similar, indeed, as to admit of no practical difference in meaning. The writer in question will not find the phrase “immortality of the soul” in the Bible, nor will he find anywhere in the Bible immortality affirmed of the soul as a thing distinct and separate from the body; yet he believes the doctrine.
3. There are so many scientific objections against the resurrection of the body. They are “so great as to be well nigh invincible.” Yes, there are objections against this doctrine; so there are against every truth in the Bible; so there are objections against about every thing in the world. Infidels have plenty of objections against the authenticity, credibility, genuineness, and integrity of the Scriptures; but an objection is not a proof or a demonstration. We may well be suspicious of a large share of that which now-a-days is floating about calling itself “science.” It has a respectable name, and that is about all. It is no science at all. When “scientific” gentlemen agree among themselves more closely, we will look with some less doubt upon their statements. We also want more proof and less “perhaps,” and “it may be,” and “it is likely,” and “if so and so be true, so and so must necessarily follow,” etc., etc. There is the “science” of evolution which has evolved any amount of scientific baby-talk of late years, and has well-nigh demonstrated one, at least, of its chief points of faith, viz.: that some people may have descended from the ape.
4. It is “not indeed beyond the conceivable power of the Almighty” to resurrect the body, but it is “incredible.” If it is not beyond the power of the Almighty to raise the dead, then the “well-nigh invincible” objections of science amount to nothing. God will do what he has promised in spite of all such “science.” The resurrection of the body then is possible, inasmuch as an impossibility is inconceivable. If it is conceivable or possible, as the Doctor declares it is, then the science that would prove it impossible is folly, and is fit only to heap contempt upon. It is “incredible” that Christian teachers should “credit” such objections. All true science is of God, and never gets in the way of any of his purposes. Indeed, it cannot; it has its assigned place and must keep it. The apostle put the question to the skeptical Agrippa, “Why should it be thought a thing incredible with you that God should raise the dead?” Acts 26: 8. We put the same to all the doubters and Agrippas of today who also think it “incredible,” especially those who retain respect for the word of God, and who are looked upon as the leaders in Christian thought and culture.
5. “I doubt whether any intelligent man really believes it,” i. e., the resurrection of the body. Is it a mark of intelligence to reject the testimony of Isaiah, Jesus, and Paul? If it is, many may be certainly counted on as lacking in good sense. Does the writer measure the intelligence of other people by his own private standard?
6. “But I disbelieve in the resurrection of the body, chiefly because it is directly opposed to the clear and explicit teachings of the Scriptures, and because, rooted in pagan materialism, it confirms paganism in our theology, and administers to us the cruelty of a pagan comfort in our sorrow.” It is hard to believe that the editor of a Christian periodical could make use of such reckless statements. a. Where in the Scriptures is the doctrine of the resurrection opposed? Echo answers, “where?” The question will forever remain unanswered, because the truth is that the Scriptures plainly and in many places teach the doctrine. Read again the passages noted in the second paragraph of this article. Also in the Old Testament read Ex. 3: 6 (compare Matt. 22: 31, 32); Job 14: 12–15; 19: 25–27; Isa. 25: 8; 26: 19; Dan. 12: 2; Hos. 13: 14, (compare 1 Cor. 15: 54, 55). Do these texts teach the resurrection of the body? If not, what do they teach? Anything? b. The doctrine “rooted in pagan materialism.” Indeed! Are the Jewish and Christian Scriptures rooted in pagan materialism? c. “It confirms paganism in our theology.” Do the teachings of prophets, Jesus, and the apostles “confirm paganism in our theology?” They must, in part, as they taught the doctrine in question. Read again the references given. The fact is, the doctrine that renders the resurrection wholly unnecessary, viz., the immortality of the soul, does precisely this very thing. The Doctor has the saddle on the wrong horse. d. It “administers to us the cruelty of a pagan comfort in our sorrow.” Astonishing! The apostle Paul administers to the church just this kind of comfort. See 1 Cor. 15: 58; 1 Thess. 4: 18: “Wherefore comfort one another with these words.” Did the apostle “comfort” the church with a pagan or a Christian hope? Judge ye!
7. The doctrine of the resurrection of the body “is distinctly, emphatically, vigorously, repudiated by the New Testament, no where more distinctly than by Paul in the fifteenth chapter of First Corinthians.” We have already shown how the New Testament repudiates (!) the doctrine of the resurrection. We note again the texts. Mark 12: 25, 26; Luke 14: 14; John 5: 28, 29; Acts 23: 6; 24: 15; 26: 8; 1 Cor. 15; Rom. 8: 11; Phil. 3: 10, 11, 21; 1 Thess. 4: 14–16. With a concordance other places may be found. Do these scriptures teach the resurrection of the body? Yes, if they teach any kind of a resurrection, or anything at all. They as certainly teach it as Matt. 28: 6; Mark 16: 6, 9; Acts 2: 31, 13: 33–35; 26: 23, teach the resurrection of Jesus, or as Ex. 14: 22, 29, and 1 Cor. 10: 1 teach that Israel passed through the Red Sea. As to 1 Cor. 15 “distinctly” teaching the non-resurrection of the body, it is a statement so plainly and absurdly false as to require no refutation. Read the chapter.
8. “The doctrine of the resurrection of the body is opposed to the spirit of the Scriptures.” Another mistake. The spirit or true sense of the Scripture is the true meaning and teaching of the Scripture. The Scriptures mean to teach the resurrection of the body in the passages I have adduced if they mean anything.
9. “We believe that the body is the man;p. 693 we confound the dress with the friend, the tenement and the tenant. We cannot, will not believe in the invisible reality.” We get in this statement, the root so to speak, of the writer’s opposition to the doctrine of the resurrection. This “pagan materialism,” as he is pleased to call it, leaves no place for what may be called his pagan immortal-soulism or modern Spiritualism in embryo. This is why he opposes the doctrine so vigorously, and nothing strange should be thought of it if he is right; because, if the one is true, the other is false. He pursues a consistency rarely exhibited by those believing in the immortality of the soul and its conscious, intermediate state; for, if this is true, there is no need of the resurrection of the body. Yes, we believe “the body is the man.” Proof: “And the Lord God formed man of the dust of the ground.” Gen. 2: 7, 3: 19; 1 Cor. 15: 45, 47; Job 14: 10–12. A living man is a living body; a dead man is a dead body. The word “man” is a few times used in a secondary sense, (as in Rom. 7: 22; 2 Cor. 4: 16), to denote a certain condition of the mind; but this “inward man” has a close relationship to the “outward man,” and indeed is a part of it in one sense. “We cannot, will not believe in the invisible reality.” Indeed we will not believe in the “invisible” man or “tenant” of modern theology. This “invisible reality” is invisible alike to the physical senses and to the teachings of the Bible.
10. “The soul passes instantly and without a break from its earthly to its spiritual condition.” I suppose the writer means to be understood that the soul, on the death of its “tenement,” takes its flight to the “world of spirits;” and this is probably what he means by the resurrection. But it cannot be. In what sense could such a thing be “the resurrection of the dead?” The body is not resurrected at all, and “the soul passes without a break” to its spiritual condition. It does not die, and is not raised from the dead. What, I repeat, is the resurrection of the dead at the hour of death?
11. “The day of Judgment comes for each soul when, in the wisdom of divine grace and love, that boundary is passed beyond which not even divine grace and love can rescue it from its self-chosen death.” Then, according to this, “the heavens and the earth are [not] reserved unto fire against the day of Judgment and perdition of ungodly men.” 2 Pet. 3: 7. “And they that have done evil shall [not] come forth unto the resurrection of damnation.” John 5: 29. Whom shall we believe, Jesus and Peter, or a great Doctor of Divinity?
12. “They who are in Christ come not into judgment at all, but have already passed from the domain of selfishness into the state of allegiance to Christ.” Here we have the great doctrine of the judgment set aside. The wicked are judged at death, and the righteous, having “passed from the domain of selfishness,” are not judged at all. But the wise man informs us, “God shall judge the righteous and the wicked: for there is a time there for every purpose and for every work.” Eccl. 3: 14. It seems the apostle was mistaken when he said God had appointed a day in the which he would judge the world. Acts 17: 31. If Paul had been a D. D. he might not have made the statement. This day or time was future in Paul’s day, but, according to the view under notice, it was already going on and had been for we know not how long. Again, the same apostle says, “We shall all stand before the judgment seat of Christ,” and “so then every one of us shall give account to God.” According to the Doctor the righteous are never judged; according to Paul “we all,” and “every one of us,” shall be. In Rev. 11: 18, “the time of the dead that they should be judged,” is brought to view. The doctrine we are here opposing knows of no such time. Read also 2 Pet. 2: 9; 3: 7; Jude 6; Rev. 20: 12.
13. Who can say there is no future day of Judgment?
It is a matter for regret that those whose mission it is to instruct the people in the truths of the Bible should, on the contrary, lead them away from them. The cause of Christ is wounded in the house of his professed friends. The plainest and most important truths of Revelation are ignored or denied by the great and learned of to-day. May God pity them and the people deceived by them. So called science will delude many. The apostle warns us to avoid the “oppositions of science falsely so called, which some professing have erred concerning the faith.” 1 Tim. 6: 20, 21. Hymenaeus and Philetus, through “profane and vain babblings,” which we are to shun along with pretended science, erred concerning the truth, saying the resurrection is passed already; and overthrew the faith of some. 2 Tim. 2: 17, 18. Science falsely so called is to-day putting the resurrection in the past. All the dead “have had their resurrection; it took place when they died.” The faith of some will be overthrown. Beware!