In the Morning Star, Dover, N. H., June 25, is an article headed as above, by Rev. J. M. Bailey, D.D., which exhibits wonderful effrontery in naked assertions, presuming very greatly upon the credulity of the readers. His leading position is that the time of the Sabbath has not been accurately kept. He says, “We do not know how many times it has been changed, or lost and re-established.” Again he asks, “Who with any confidence will plead for the identical time appointed by God when that time has been lost again and again with no possibility of restoring it.” And he draws this conclusion: “Sticking for identical time or any other than the established seventh part is absurd.” He asks, “What difference does it make when we begin to count? If number makes any difference, commence on Monday and it will make it all right. Indeed, this is the easiest way to correct it.”
If the seventh-part-of-time theory is true,—if God has not given a specific, sanctified seventh day, but has left it with men to choose the day,—we can hardly see how that “the influence of keeping Saturday and working Sunday” can be “destructive of the Christian Sabbath;” for Saturday is a seventh part of time, as well as any other day. But the writer has learned to be guarded in his words of expression. He says, “The established seventh part.” That means Sunday. But the question arises, If uniformity in the day is essential to the quiet observance of the Sabbath, as all must admit, and if God has not by his word and providence established and preserved the day, by what authority shall it be established? Have not all equal rights in choosing the day? Has God clothed majorities with divine right? A particular day is indeed essential; and we shall find that God was aware of it, and by a wisdom not exceeded by that of men appointed the day, and by his providence he has preserved the knowledge of it to mankind.
The following statement would be truly amusing, were it not the deliberate utterance of a grave doctor of divinity. Speaking of the change from Old Style to New he says, “The English were so slow in adopting it that they were obliged to jump eleven days, calling the 3d day of Sept. 1752, the 14th day, bringing the Sabbath into the middle of the week.” Now who ever read of this marvelous event in English history? And how long was it before England came into harmony with the rest of mankind in respect to the week, as she now is? Or did the whole world, Jews, Mohammedans, and Christians, adopt the change when the English did? Now supposing the said 3d of September came on Sunday, would calling it the 14th make it Wednesday? Would it not be Sunday all day? and would not the next day be Monday? Were not the English then observing Sunday, the first day of the week? and have they not observed it ever since? The fact is, the cycle of seven days, the oldest division of time, is God’s arrangement, and no change in the number of days in months or years can affect it. And from Eastern Asia to Western America all nations are agreed in the reckoning of the days of the week.
Again we quote: “When Moses established the Sabbath he did not even pretend to count from the creation, but from the falling of the manna which might have been any day of the week for all that we know.” To this we reply that God, and not Moses, established the Sabbath, when he rested upon the seventh day, and then blessed and sanctified it because he had rested upon it. And the commandment which he gave with his own voice at Sinai is a perfect refutation of every attempt to make the day of the Sabbath indefinite and changeable. Let us see. “Remember the Sabbath day.” This refers to something in the past, and is equivalent to, Remember the rest day. “The seventh day is the Sabbath,”—rest. Whosep. 697 rest is it?—“The Sabbath of the Lord thy God; IN IT thou shalt not do any work.” Why is this? “For in six days the Lord made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that in them is, and rested the seventh day; wherefore [for this reason], the Lord blessed the Sabbath day and hallowed it.” This refers us directly back to the creation, in the record of which it is said, “He rested on the seventh day from all his work which he had made. And God blessed the seventh day and sanctified it; because that in it he had rested from all his work which God created and made.”
Sabbath means rest. God worked during six days. Can any one of those days ever become his rest day? Not till he shall rest upon it. He rested on the seventh day of the week. Can that fact cease to be a fact? can the seventh day ever cease to be his rest day?
Now if the Lord still requires us to obey the fourth commandment by keeping his Sabbath, and yet has suffered the day to be lost so that we cannot possibly find it, an impossibility is required, and we cannot be blamed, though we work on his rest day. The inevitable conclusion of our friend’s logic throws the blame on our Creator.
Before we thus impeach him, let us see whether his providence has not preserved to us the day of his rest. When the Lord gave manna to his people, he pointed out his Sabbath by giving none on that day. A month before the Sabbath law was given at Sinai, Moses said, “This is that which the Lord HATH said, To-morrow is the rest of the holy Sabbath unto the Lord.” Ex. 16. And after this when God spoke the commandments, he proclaimed this Sabbath as the day of his rest at creation.
Jesus kept the Sabbath. Did he not know which was the day of rest at the creation? His disciples kept it “according to the commandment” after his death. If so, they must have kept the day specified in the commandment. From that day to this, Jews and Christians have been, and are, agreed in numbering the days of the week. The Jews and a part of the Christian church, sometimes more and sometimes less, have kept the seventh day, while a large part of the Christians, especially in the later centuries, have kept the first day because it was “the first day of the week.” Those who make reckless assertions that time has been lost would do well to look those facts in the face.
Our friend makes the customary voyages around the world both ways to find an objection to the Creator’s arrangement in making “the Sabbath for man,” and yet placing him on a round and rolling earth. It is not worth the time and space to follow him. But we notice a part of what he says of the change of the day. Says he, “It appears that the day of ‘convocation’ was changed from the seventh to the first on the very day of the resurrection of Christ. What he said to his disciples about it to convince them, we have no means of knowing. He met some of them several times that day and then appeared in their assembly where they were met with closed doors ‘for fear of the Jews,’ and sanctioned their meeting by breathing on them the Holy Spirit and sending them forth as the Father had sent him. Probably for fear of the Jews, what he said against Judaism or in favor of the Christian Sabbath was not published.” This “convocation” or “assembly” consisted of the eleven. Mark 16:14. They had one common abode. Acts 1:13. They were at home and had closed the doors for fear of the Jews. What were they doing? Eating their supper—“they sat at meat.” Mark 16:14. Admit that he “sanctioned their meeting.” What else did he do? He “upbraided them for their unbelief and hardness of heart, because they believed not them which had seen him after he was risen.” Were they met to celebrate his resurrection, before they believed he was risen? “He showed them his hands and his feet” to convince them of what they did not believe, and further, he took some food and ate in their presence to satisfy them of the reality of his resurrection. See Luke 24:36-43. It is very true that “what he said to the disciples to convince them” of the change of the Sabbath, “we have no means of knowing.” Is this evidence that he said anything about it? “Probably for fear of the Jews, what he said against Judaism or in favor of the Christian Sabbath was not published.” And this silence of the inspired record is the best evidence he can offer that a “Christian Sabbath” was instituted that day! Paul did not keep back anything that was profitable for the church for fear of the Jews; but he did keep back the Sunday-Sabbath.
When holy angels behold the attempts which are constantly being made on every hand to sustain a human tradition which sets aside the plainest possible expression of the will of God to man, they must certainly be amazed at the daring presumption of men, and be filled with wonder that a creature formed in the image of God and endowed with reasoning powers but a little lower than the angels, could voluntarily so degrade his noble, God-given powers as to put forth such silly and contemptible quibbles, for the want of better arguments, as are constantly being resorted to for the purpose of sustaining the practice of Sunday-keeping against the commandment of the Most High! “Be astonished, O ye heavens, at this, and be horribly afraid, be ye very desolate, saith the Lord. For my people have committed two evils; they have forsaken me, the fountain of living waters, and hewed them out cisterns, broken cisterns, that can hold no water.” Jer. 2:12, 13.
R. F. COTTRELL.