If the writer were to state upon his own authority that infidelity and Universalism were making rapid inroads among the religious denominations of to-day, and should point to this fact as proof that the words of the prophet were being fulfilled where he says that “in the last days perilous times shall come,” and men having the form of godliness shall deny the power thereof,—there would be some ready to cry, “You’re a ‘pessimist.’ Why do you always look upon the unfavorable side of matters, and are never able to see anything good in the religious world?” But as the writer does not propose to advance his own opinions in this article, he will have no words with any who may be thus disposed to criticise, but will call their attention to the language of Paul in 2 Tim. 3:1-5, and leave them to shout “pessimist” at him if they will.
Meanwhile, the reader’s attention is called to statements of President Northrup, of Yale College, and to comments upon the same by the Interior (itself a Presbyterian paper), which reveal the startling fact that, in the Professor’s own words, the Congregational churches of the East “have made a step toward modified Universalism.” Here is the article entire, as it appeared in the Interior of Oct. 9:—
“President Northrup, of Yale, gave the Congregational Club of St. Paul an account of the revolution which has quietly been accomplished in the Congregational churches of the East. He said:—
“‘It is a fact that the church has made a step toward modified Universalism. The revolution is not the effect of preaching, nor the work of any sect or school; but of a silent change in the thought and methods of modern life.
“‘Second, the sense of sin—the intense conviction of sin that prevailed in preaching and religious experience and literature—has almost entirely gone.
“‘Third, a very diminished importance now attaches to creeds. Whether this has made Christianity more or less aggressive and effective remains to be seen.’
“President Northrup’s statements were received with applause, and they are printed in the Advance without comment, which shows that the theology of the churches is not differentiated by longitude. He said (we quote the report of the Advance):—
“‘“We cannot go backward. The love of God in Christ, and not the terrors of the law, must be the chief power in the work. Sinai no longer terrifies, but Gethsemane and Calvary still touch the hearts of men. The central power in the religious life to-day is the life of Christ.’ These facts were presented by President Northrup with an earnestness and manly courage that won all hearts, and although he prefaced his paper with the remark that he only knew about church life in the East, the applause that followed his address showed that the sympathy of the Club was with him. Rev. J. L. Scudder told with much feeling how he had struggled out of the theology of Union Seminary into a gospel that is actually adapted to his own needs, and the needs of the many young men in his congregation.’
“Well, if you cannot go back, then you must go forward. ‘Gethsemane and Calvary still touch the hearts of men.’ Yale College and Andover and the churches have not gotten entirely away from the gospel yet. There is still a feeble show of sensibility to its appeals. But how long will this last in a forward movement which has left no sense of sin behind, and has no respect to scriptural truth—to creeds? When the sense of sin is almost entirely gone, what is there left of Gethsemane and Calvary but a tragedy, and what appeal has it to make to anything but sentimentality? Why not present the softer and more artistic death of Ophelia from the pulpit, to touch the hearts of men? The amazing thing is, that avowals and confessions like these should be applauded in the St. Paul Congregational Club, and printed without comment in the Advance. It is to say that the theology of Congregationalism is affected through and through with dry rot. If sin counts for nothing, neither does salvation count for anything. If truth is not valued, neither is falsehood abhorred. There is nothing left but the sentimentality which carries bouquets and attar of roses to criminals awaiting execution under the civil law. And how long will this kind of religion last? What is left of it is nothing else than a fading reminiscence, a forgotten habit, a dream, a tale that hath been told. Dr. Scudder got away, after a struggle with his conscience, from the theology of Union Seminary to a sentimentality adapted to the ‘wants of his people.’ His people do not want to be convicted of sin. They do not want the burden of accepted truth. So the word of God must be adapted to what they do want! That is an heroic, Pauline, Christlike gospel, is it not? And ‘we cannot go backward’ to the awful significance of Calvary, and to the awful teachings of Christ. No more of Sinai—with its ‘thou shalt not.’ This is not only the dry rot of theology, but the dry rot of morality as well. If there be a remnant, and we know there is a large one in the Congregational churches, who are willing to stand with Elijah and Paul, they cannot be too soon in declaring themselves. This ‘modified Universalism’ is not as good as Universalism, which, at least, has sincere and positive convictions.” C. C. L.