AdventAI

A GRADUAL CHANGE.

By C. C. L.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 61, No. 42., October 21, 1884

The Sabbath question is every day coming more prominently to the front. The public mind is being aroused and enlightened upon the subject, and people everywhere, who have not seen and rejected the truth, are anxious to learn the facts in the matter. Hence we find the religious press plied with questions from “anxious inquirers,” who want to know if the fourth commandment is still binding, how the Sabbath came to be changed and who changed it, whether there is a command in the Bible to keep the first day of the week holy, etc., etc. The answers to some of these questions are noteworthy, partly from the inconsistencies they contain, but chiefly on account of some plain truths they tell and the remarkable admissions they make. Take, for example, the following from the Christian Union of Sept. 11:—

“Please inform me, through your column of Inquiring Friends, when and by whose authority obedience to the fourth commandment was changed from the seventh to the first day of the week? I have recently made the acquaintance of ‘Seventh-day Adventists,’ who maintain that the change did not take place during the days of the Apostles, but several (one or two) centuries afterwards, by order of one of the popes, to win over and favor the worshipers of the sun. Also please inform me in what year the first pope began his supremacy.”

“The fourth commandment simply requires men to labor six days and rest on the seventh; it does not attach any importance to the day, but only to the proportion of time. The day was not changed by any ecclesiastical authority from the seventh to the first; the change was a gradual one. In the early church for a time the seventh day was observed as the Sabbath and the first day as the celebration of the resurrection. Gradually, as the Jewish elements in the church grew proportionately less, and the Gentile elements proportionately greater, the seventh-day observance was dropped and the first-day observance took its place. In our judgment no other authority is required for such a change than is involved in the broad declarations of Paul in such passages as Romans 14:5, 6, and Col. 2:16. The supremacy of the pope was, in similar manner, the result of a gradual development; the title Pope or Papa was taken by all bishops in the first century, and it was not until the fifth century that it was used as a specific title for the Bishop of Rome, about which time also that bishop began to exercise a supreme authority over other bishops.”

The above answer is remarkable for the admissions it makes. Let us collect and number them:—

1. “The day was not changed by any ecclesiastical authority from the seventh to the first.” Then it is admitted that the change was not made by either Christ or the apostles. But that an ecclesiastical power, the papacy, did have much to do with making the change is well known.

2. “The change was a gradual one.” Gradually the seventh-day observance was dropped, and the first-day observance took its place. This fact, admitted by the Christian Union, is sufficient, upon its very face, to arouse suspicion that the first-day came in, not by any rightful authority, but as a usurper. The cause given for this gradual change will be noticed soon.

3. “In the early church for a time the seventh day was observed as the Sabbath and the first day as the celebration of the resurrection.” By the admission of its opponents, then, the seventh day was kept as the Sabbath by the early church; and in the words of its advocates the first day was observed by the early church “as the celebration of the resurrection.”

4. The supremacy of the pope, like the change of the Sabbath, was the result of a gradual development.

These admissions completely sweep away the foundation from the claim that Sunday is a religious institution whose observance is binding upon Christians at the present time; for if the change of the Sabbath was made by no ecclesiastical authority, if the early church still kept the seventh day as the Sabbath, while they observed the first day only to celebrate the resurrection upon it, what is left of Sunday but a voluntary institution, which one is at liberty to observe or not as he pleases? Indeed, this is evidently just the position the Christian Union would take; for it maintains that the fourth commandment “does not attach any importance to the day, but only to the proportion of time.” By what authority this statement is made, is a mystery. Certainly no one would obtain such an idea from the commandment itself. The entire wording is utterly inconsistent with the theory that any seventh day after six days’ work was intended. Indeed it would be difficult to conceive how a particular day could have been pointed out to the Hebrews more definitely. To them “the seventh day” was as definite as “Saturday” is to us. The only other name they ever had for that day of the week was “Sabbath.” When, therefore, the commandment says that God rested on the seventh day, that the seventh day is the Sabbath, and that God blessed the Sabbath day and hallowed it, the Hebrews could have understood it in no other way than that the seventh day of each week, known to us as Saturday, was intended. This conclusion is confirmed by the undeniable fact that they did so understand it, and this understanding had the divine approval, and by the further fact that the world so understood it until A. D. 1595, when Nicholas Bound invented this “seventh-part-of-time theory,” here advocated by the Christian Union. No importance attached to the day, but only to the proportion of time!—How, in reason, then, could God bless and sanctify the Sabbath day, if the Sabbath were not necessarily a day at all, but could be kept during the dark part of the day, in rainy or cold weather, or at any other time that might suit the caprice or convenience of any individual?

The Christian Union attributes the decline of seventh-day observance to the decrease of Jewish elements, and the increase of Gentile elements, in the church. This is doubtless true, at least it coincided with these; but it would certainly be a futile search to try to find in the decrease of Jewish, or the increase of Gentile, elements in the church a divine authority for the change of the Sabbath, such as any sincere Christian who keeps the first day would desire to find. But did the reader notice from the perusal of the answer under review that the gradual development of Sunday observance coincides with another “gradual development,” namely, the supremacy of the pope? Mark the steps by which, according to the Christian Union, the supremacy of the pope was developed: 1. “The title Pope or Papa was taken by all bishops in the first century.” 2. In the fifth century it began to be used as a “specific title for the Bishop of Rome.” 3. About this time the bishop of Rome began to exercise supreme authority over other bishops. Now notice, in connection with the foregoing, the development of first-day observance: 1. In the early church the first day was observed only in celebration of the resurrection, while they still kept the seventh day as the Sabbath. 2. In 321 the first law, either ecclesiastical or civil, by which the sabbatical observance of the first day is known to have been ordained was enacted by the still Pagan emperor Constantine. (He received baptism only on his death bed.) 3. In 538, about the time when the bishop of Rome “began to exercise a supreme authority over the other bishops,” the third council of Orleans put forth the first ecclesiastical utterance with reference to first-day observance by recommending abstinence from agricultural labor on that day, “that the people might have more leisure to go to church and say their prayers.”

In view of Daniel’s prophecy that the papacy would seek to change times and laws, and further in view of the boast of Catholic authorities that the Catholic church is alone responsible for the change of the Sabbath from the seventh day to the first day of the week, this coincidence (if such it be called) is to say the least, very remarkable.

But this article is already too long; and the Christian Union’s statement that in its judgment the broad declarations of Paul in such passages as Romans 14:5, 6 and Col. 2:16 are sufficient authority for this gradual, unauthorized change of the Sabbath, will have to be reserved for another article.

C. C. L.