THE following question and answer relative to tithing is taken from the S. S. Times of Sept. 13, 1884:—
“I am a firm believer in the duty and privilege of tithing, and have for several years been in the habit of laying aside one-tenth of my salary as belonging to the Lord. I have found it very pleasant to have a little sum by me to which I could turn when different calls for the Lord’s cause were made upon me, but your note on 2 Sam. 24:24 puts me in a quandary. You say, “Would David have counted it a good way to make an offering to the Lord to buy a plate of ice-cream?” etc. I am opposed to church fairs, “pound socials,” etc., as a means of raising money to carry on church work. I have freely expressed my opinion on the subject in our church society, but thus far stand nearly alone. We have, occasionally, a strawberry or ice-cream festival, with two purposes in view, promoting sociability, and raising a little money. I, as one of the elders in our church, have usually attended at such gatherings, with my family, and have patronized freely all the ordinary means used for raising money at such places, as I knew that the net proceeds would be used scrupulously for the work of the Lord’s house. I have thus often used more money than I would have deemed it best to use for any other cause, but I thought I was doing right to use for such purposes a part of my tithe money. Your note would seem to take an opposite view, and I am perplexed. I have acted conscientiously in the course I have pursued; and I think that in actual practice the fund needed for the purposes for which the festivals have been held has been increased by just the amount I have spent, so that if I had stayed at home the fund for church use would have been decreased by just the amount I spent. I have not patronized such places with my own enjoyment in view, but to help in all things to carry forward our church work. Now, what should I have done?—remain at home and refuse to support anything of the kind, or go and charge my expenses to my personal expense account?”
“Our correspondent believes that one-tenth of his income belongs to the Lord absolutely. He’s sound so far. He is opposed to church-fairs and all such indirect ways of getting for and giving to the Lord. Good again! He speaks right out and tells his brother church-members that he doesn’t approve that sort of thing. There also he’s right. But because of the hardness of their hearts, he is inclined to suffer with them while he is trying to bring them to his standard of convictions; so he goes into their peddling contribution gatherings, and gives his share toward the cause which he approves, even while he disapproves the popular method of working for it. Well, he has good authority for such a concession, if it is wise to adopt it in this case. That is for him to decide. But, about the counting the ice-cream and strawberries which he himself eats, as ‘given to the Lord,’—that is another matter. If that cream and those strawberries are really worth eating, they ought to cost something. That prime cost oughtn’t to come out of the Lord’s money, even if the profit on the sale of them goes into the Lord’s treasury. In other words, if our brother has five dollars of the Lord’s money that he proposes to put into the Lord’s treasury by way of that ‘sociable,’ by all means let him see to it that five dollars—a hundred cents on the dollar—goes into Lord’s treasury. If he has to eat a dollar’s worth of ice-cream and strawberries in order to get his five dollars on its way into the Lord’s treasury, don’t, don’t let him charge that swallowed-dollar to the Lord! Let him pay that out of his own pocket. One chief objection to this indirect way of raising money, either by church-fairs or pew-rents, or charity-balls, and one chief attraction of this method also, is, that it enables a person to eat, or carry home, or dance away so many dollars’ worth, and then charge it to the Lord as on ‘charity account,’ or on account of ‘tithes.’ If our readers can’t understand the line of distinction which we here draw, we must leave it to them to study out as best they can.”