THE SABBATH AND THE FIRST DAY OF THE WEEK IN THE FIRST CENTURIES OF THE CHRISTIAN ERA.—NO. 5.
As we come to the close of the second century and the beginning of the third, a controversy in the church begins to arise respecting the exaltation of the Sunday-Lord’s day above the Sabbath of the Bible. As the Sunday was exalted to greater honor, in the same proportion was the ancient Sabbath degraded and dishonored. Let those who talk about lost time, and the impossibility of ascertaining the true numbers of the days of the week, mark the unmistakable fact that this objection to the Lord’s Sabbath had not at that time seen the light. No question of that kind existed. The Sabbath and the first day of the week were two definite and distinct days in the minds of all. There was no question in respect to the identity of either. The only strife was upon the question which should be the greater. Sunday was from that time arising to greater honor, while the Sabbath was declining in the esteem of many.
“It is a remarkable fact,” says Eld. Andrews, “that the first instance upon record in which the bishop of Rome attempted to rule the Christian church was by an EDICT IN BEHALF OF SUNDAY. It had been the custom of all the churches to celebrate the passover, but with this difference: that while the eastern churches observed it upon the fourteenth day of the first month, no matter which day of the week this might be, the western churches kept it upon the Sunday following that day, or rather, upon the Sunday following Good Friday. Victor, bishop of Rome, in the year 196, took upon him to impose the Roman custom upon all the churches; that is, to compel them to observe the passover upon Sunday. ‘This bold attempt,’ says Bower, ‘we may call the first essay of papal usurpation,’ and Dowling terms it the ‘earliest instance of Romish assumption.’ The churches of Asia Minor informed Victor that they could not comply with his lordly mandate.”
Victor was baffled in his attempt, and the victory was not obtained for Sunday in this struggle, as Heylyn testifies:—
“Till the great Council of Nice [A. D. 325] backed by as great an emperor [Constantine], settled it better than before; none but some scattered schismatics, now and then appearing, durst oppose the resolution of that famous synod.”
Constantine urged the following strong reason for this measure:—
“Let us then have nothing in common with the most hostile rabble of the Jews.”
Hatred to the Jews had much to do in depressing the Lord’s Sabbath and elevating a heathen festival to its place. While they rejected the Sabbath that they might have nothing in common with that “odious brood,” the Jews, they seemed not at all to question the propriety of holding a festival in common with the heathen, and that without precept or example from Christ or his apostles, which at that time had never been claimed. The fact is, heathenism, with its old grudges against the Jews, was flowing into the once fair church, transforming it into a temple of heathen superstitions and idolatries.
In order to degrade the Sabbath, a part of the western churches, with the church of Rome at their head, turned the Sabbath into a fast, while they regarded Sunday as a joyful festival. A part of the eastern churches, however, refused to comply with this ordinance, and a long struggle ensued, the result of which is thus stated by Heylyn:—
“In this difference it stood a long time together, till in the end the Roman church obtained the cause, and Saturday became a fast almost through all parts of the western world. I say the western world, and of that alone; the eastern churches being so far from altering their ancient custom that in the sixth council of Constantinople, A. D. 692, they did admonish those of Rome to forbear fasting on that day on pain of censure.”
Wm. James, in a sermon before the University of Oxford, thus states the time when this fast originated:—
“The western churches began to fast on Saturday at the beginning of the third century.”
This shows that this struggle commenced in the third century, or following the year 200. Neander thus states the motive of the Roman church:—
“In the western churches, particularly the Roman, where opposition to Judaism was the prevailing tendency, this very opposition produced the custom of celebrating the Sabbath in particular as a fast day.”
Dr. Charles Hase, of Germany, states the object of the Roman church as follows:—
“The Roman church regarded Saturday as a fast day in direct opposition to those who regarded it as a Sabbath. Sunday remained a joyful festival in which all fasting and worldly business was avoided as much as possible, but the original commandment of the decalogue respecting the Sabbath was not then applied to that day.”
“Thus the Sabbath of the Lord,” says Eld. Andrews, “was turned into a fast in order to render it despicable before men. Such was the great effort of the Roman church toward the suppression of the Sabbath of the Bible.”p. 570
There is abundant evidence to show that the early fathers did not claim any divine warrant for Sunday observance, or make it a day of rest from ordinary labor. Those who desire further light as to how they did regard the day are referred to the “History of the Sabbath” by Eld. J. N. Andrews, chapters 17 and 18, or to the pamphlet, “The Complete Testimony of the Fathers.” Either can be obtained by addressing, REVIEW AND HERALD, Battle Creek, Mich. R. F. COTTRELL.