AN IMAGINARY CONVERSATION ON A VERY IMPORTANT THEME.
BY ELD. W. H. LITTLEJOHN.
Mr. Thoughtful.—“I enter your room this evening, Mr. Biblist, with no reluctance, I assure you. My mind has been occupied during the whole day with the topic that we had under discussion at our last sitting; and there are several questions that I would like to propound for your solution.”
Mr. Biblist.—“Very good, sir; you can proceed to state your difficulties, and I will remove them if possible.”
Mr. T.—“There are two that occur to me just now. They are these: 1. What was there in the type of the scape-goat sent into the wilderness to answer to the punishment of Satan in the lake of fire? 2. How do you explain the statement found in Lev. 16:10 to the effect that the scape-goat was to be used in making ‘an atonement’?”
Mr. B.—“Well, Mr. T., I will give you credit for searching out two of the most difficult questions that you could have asked in connection with this subject. They are not entirely new to me, however, and I will answer them to you as I did to my own mind when they first suggested themselves to me. It is true that there is nothing in the type that seems to foreshadow the destruction of Satan in the lake of fire. I account for it in this way: The casting of Satan into the lake of fire will take place at the end of the thousand years that will commence with the resurrection of the just at the coming of Christ, and end with the resurrection of the unjust. The cleansing of the most holy place in the heavenly sanctuary closes with the judgment of the righteous at the coming of Christ. It would not have been proper, therefore, that anything should appear in the services connected with the cleansing of the most holy place of the Mosaic tabernacle that would foreshadow events to take place after the closing work in the most holy place in the heavenly temple. “Let me state it another way: The wicked will have no part in the atonement made by the blood of Christ. You will remember that the sins of penitent confessors alone were carried into the holy place of the tabernacle, and that they alone were atoned for and confessed over the head of the scape-goat. It follows from this that the atoning service in both the earthly and the heavenly sanctuary related to the righteous exclusively. This being true, the atoning service in the heavenly sanctuary will end just before the coming of Christ, since the cases of the saints are decided before that event in order that they may be resurrected or changed when it takes place. In connection with the judging of the saints the case of Satan is brought up. It is decreed that he shall be punished for the sins that he has caused the people of God to commit, and then an angel is commissioned to bind him and lead him away into the desolated earth as soon as it is broken up by the earthquakes of the last days. Subsequently the same angel casts him into the lake of fire; but this event was not shadowed forth in the type because it will not take place in immediate connection with the closing work in the most holy place in the heavenly temple. Do you comprehend the argument, Mr. Thoughtful?”
Mr. T.—“I think I do, sir. It is this: The casting of Satan into the lake of fire was not prefigured in the type because it was not to take place in immediate connection with that which the type shadowed forth, that is, the cleansing of the most holy place in the heavenly temple.”
Mr. B.—“Precisely so, sir. You comprehend my meaning quite fully. Now to your second question. It is said that the scape-goat was to be presented alive before the Lord to make an atonement with him. Mark it. It is not for him (the goat), but with him (the goat) that the atonement was to be made. An atonement is that by which reconciliation is made for sin. We have seen that the scape-goat typified Satan. If, therefore, the atonement was made for the goat, it would imply the salvation of Satan, a thing that is out of the question; but as it is said that the atonement was to be made with the scape-goat, I understand that the expression simply implies that Satan (the antitype of the scape-goat) in some way is to play a part in the scheme for the reconciliation between God and penitent men. That part consists in his suffering in his own person for the sins that he has induced the righteous to commit, and which the high-priest in the typical service confessed over the scape-goat, laying his hands upon his head. It seems, therefore, that before God could consistently pardon men for their sins, he felt compelled to insist that Satan, who was a party to man’s criminality, should, in the presence of the universe, and in connection with the making of the atonement by Christ, have the sins of the saints rolled back upon his head in so far as he was responsible for them. In other words, that no atonement would have been satisfactory to God that did not involve the punishment of the great deceiver in a manner so public that the people of God would witness his doom, and be most profoundly impressed with the exceeding sinfulness of sin. It is certain that an atonement could not have been made with the scape-goat in the primary sense of that word (that is, a sacrifice for sin); since Paul says in Heb. 9:22, that “all things are by the law purged with blood, and without shedding of blood is no remission;” and since the scape-goat was not slain. The only remaining sense, therefore, in which an atonement could be made with the scape-goat was that of using the scape-goat as he was used in connection with the services of the day of atonement, to illustrate the fact that Satan would eventually suffer for the sins of the saints as one of the necessary conditions to God’s plan of reconciling men to himself. That God had a right to make such a condition, no one can dispute; that it was both just to Satan and instructive to men cannot be denied; that it was very properly made prominent in the services of the typical day of atonement, must be obvious to every one.”
Mr. T.—“I thank you for your explanations, Mr. B.; they are quite satisfactory, and now I am more than ever anxious to have you locate the time, if it be possible, when these momentous events are to take place.”
Maud.—“That is the way I feel too, father; I wish that you and Mr. T. would be kind enough to avoid these nice points of doctrine, until you have settled the point of time. I have been waiting for that now for two evenings.”
Mr. B.—“Be patient, Maud; you should remember that the points we have been examining are important ones, and that it is necessary for every one to consider them carefully before he can become intelligent on the subject of the sanctuary. It is because they are unwilling to do this that so many Seventh-day Adventists are unable either to comprehend or defend the faith of our people on that point. The fact is, to speak plainly, many persons are so lazy mentally that they will not put forth the necessary effort to understand one of the grandest questions in the book of God. It is of but little use to be able to locate the exact time when the great day of atonement was entered upon in heaven, until one can give a good reason for believing that it must have commenced at the date in question. “But I must enter upon my task. To-night I can do but little more than to lay the foundation for my argument. I wish in the first place to call your attention to the fact that the day of atonement covers a section of the judgment work. It will not take long to do this, as the services performed thereupon related to the confession of sin for the people on the part of Christ before the Father and the pleading of his (Christ’s) blood before Him (God) for their final and complete remission.”
Mr. T.—“Do you not believe that Christ made an atonement for our sins on the cross?”
Mr. B.—“No, sir, I do not. He died on the cross, thus laying the foundation for the making of the atonement through his blood in the close of the world’s history and at the time of the Judgment.”
Mr. T.—“But do we not read in Rom. 5:11 that we have already received the atonement? Yes; here it is: ‘And not only so, but we also joy in God through our Lord Jesus Christ, by whom we have now received the atonement.’”
Mr. B.—“Your text would be in point, sir, if it were a correct translation of the original, which it is not. I read from the Encyclopedia of Religious Knowledge, Article Atonement: ‘And as to Rom. 5:11 it is well known that the original word there used is not ilasmos, but katallagēn, and should have been rendered reconciliation.’ In harmony with what I have just read, the New Version reads, ‘Through whom we have now received the reconciliation.’ Dean Alford’s translation has it the same, substantially, as the New Version, ‘Through whom we have now received our reconciliation.’”
Mr. T.—“I see that I shall be compelled to surrender my strong text.”
Mr. B.—“Yes; and I believe that there is not a passage among those usually employed to prove that the atonement took place at the cross that will justify such a conclusion. The doctrine itself is contrary to reason. When sin is once atoned for, it is fully disposed of, and can never be charged to the account of the offender again. To reason, therefore, that the sins of those who are converted were atoned for on the cross, would be to argue that such persons could not be lost; a doctrine which you as a Methodist, Mr. Thoughtful, will not be very likely to endorse, and one that is contrary to the plain declarations of the Scriptures. Let me read a text on this point. Here it is in Eze. 18:24: ‘But when the righteous turneth away from his righteousness, and committeth iniquity, and doeth according to all the abominations that the wicked man doeth, shall he live? All his righteousness that he hath done shall not be mentioned: in his trespass that he hath trespassed, and in his sin that he hath sinned, in them shall he die.’ The class mentioned in this passage are converted men, since they are spoken of as beingp. 595 righteous. It follows, therefore, that converted men can be lost, since those in question died in their sins. But if the atonement was perfected at the cross in an absolute sense, then either a man can be lost after his sins have been atoned for, or else he can be converted without having his sins atoned for, and be lost. Either of these positions is fatal to the doctrine of an atonement completed at the cross; since it would be absurd to reason that there are two classes of converts, the sins of one of which were atoned for at the cross, while those of the other were not atoned for there, and never will be. At your leisure you can read Heb. 6:4-6, which confirms the doctrine of Eze. 18:24, or the possibility of a man’s becoming a castaway after his conversion. “Now let us consider the atonement for a moment in the light of the sanctuary question. In its service the sins of the people were confessed and carried, in connection with the blood of the victim that represented Christ, into the first apartment of the sanctuary for 364 days in the year. During this time no final disposition was made of them. They remained under the eye of God, the blood of the victim testifying the penitence of the offender and his faith in Christ. All this time these sins were not atoned for. They stood against the parties who had committed them. On the last day of the year—called by way of distinction, the day of atonement—all these sins were carried into the most holy place by the high priest, confessed again before God, and finally atoned for in figure through the offering of the blood of the Lord’s goat and the ceremony of the scape-goat. This, says the 30th verse of Leviticus 16, was done that the people might be cleansed from all their sins before the Lord. It follows, therefore, that they had not been cleansed from the sins that they had confessed, previously to the day of atonement. Having seen that the yearly round of the tabernacle service represented the whole period of probation, we see that the lesson taught by that round of service is simply this: Up to the time of the antitypical day of atonement, sinners will continue to confess their sins before God, pleading in connection with those confessions the shed blood of Christ. When the day of Judgment is reached, Christ, our high priest, will offer before his Father his own blood for the purpose of making an atonement for the sins of his people. Then those sins will be pardoned absolutely, and Satan, the antitypical scape-goat, will have them rolled back upon his head. Previous to this time, confessing sinners had been pardoned conditionally, and the favor of God secured as the result of faith in Christ and the atonement to be perfected by him in the future. All this while, however, the record of their sins was preserved; and in case they apostatized, they would be punished for those sins in the Judgment—agreeably to Eze. 18:24—as fully as if they had never repented of them. This is in harmony with Heb. 9:24-26, where we learn that Christ, unlike the high priest, was to enter into the most holy place but once to put away sin by the sacrifice of himself; not, of course, by sacrificing himself in the most holy place in the heavenly temple, but by presenting there in behalf of his people the blood that he shed for them on Calvary. “This is also in harmony with reason; for the plan that men should receive conditional pardon upon repentance, and absolute pardon if faithful, at the Judgment, is much more consistent with wisdom, than that their sins should be atoned for before they were committed and while they were still on probation. “Now that we have seen that the day of atonement typified a portion of the Judgment work in heaven, the next point I wish to make is that the Judgment will commence some little time before the coming of Christ.”
Mr. T.—“Why, I supposed that the Judgment would commence after the coming of Christ. Is not that the general view?”
Mr. B.—“Yes, sir; but it is, nevertheless, erroneous. When Christ descends to this earth, he will not raise the dead and then decide whether they belong respectively to the righteous or the wicked; but he will destroy the living wicked, and resurrect the righteous dead out from among the wicked dead. Here is the record in 1 Thess. 4:16, 17: ‘For the Lord himself shall descend from heaven with a shout, with the voice of the archangel, and with the trump of God: and the dead in Christ shall rise first; then we which are alive and remain shall be caught up together with them in the clouds to meet the Lord in the air, and so shall we ever be with the Lord.’ In the third chapter of Philippians, Paul declared that he was willing to lose all things that he might know Christ and the power of his resurrection, and the fellowship of his sufferings, being made conformable unto his death; if by any means he might attain unto the resurrection of the dead. Paul was not afraid that he would fail altogether of being resurrected. He knew very well that the Lord had promised that all that are in their graves should hear his voice and come forth.”
Maud.—“What did he mean, then, father?”
Mr. B.—“I will tell you, Maud. There are to be two resurrections, a thousand years apart; the first will be that of the righteous, the second that of the wicked dead.”
Mr. T.—“How do you prove that, sir?”
Mr. B.—“I will prove it, Mr. Thoughtful, by reading to you Rev. 20:5, 6. Here it is: ‘But the rest of the dead lived not again until the thousand years were finished. This is the first resurrection. Blessed and holy is he that hath part in the first resurrection; on such the second death hath no power, but they shall be priests of God and of Christ, and shall reign with him a thousand years.’ You will observe that this passage proves the two things that I have assumed: first, that there are to be two resurrections; secondly, that they are to be a thousand years apart; but I see that our time is up, and I will postpone further consideration of the subject until to-morrow evening.”