The Daily Telegraph of St. Johns, New Brunswick, printed July 10 the following powerful appeal to Rev. Dr. McCrea of that city, who had a few days before delivered an oration for the lodge, during a patriotic celebration. The letter was written by Rev. A. J. McFarland of the Reformed Presbyterian Church, and is herewith reproduced almost entire:—
DEAR BROTHER: Having carefully read and considered your oration delivered in Mechanics’ Institute, on Dominion day, in praise of Speculative Masonry, will you suffer a word of friendly comment and criticism? You can the better afford me this liberty, since your effort was received with such general commendation and applause. Allow me to say that while I admired the ability and shrewdness you displayed, it pained me exceedingly to see a ministerial brother, for whom I have learned to entertain a profound respect, eulogize, in such an unwarrantable way, the order of Freemasonry. Your brethren of the lodge will doubtless be jubilant in that they have secured a minister of the gospel in your high standing to “sound the praises of Masonry.” But this is particularly what I lament, that an institution which I feel is so unworthy of Christian favor and patronage, should be able to point to your willing support and endorsement as an evidence of its respectability. It has ever been the reply of Masons to any objection to the order: “Surely it cannot be bad, or such good men as Rev. So-and-so would not belong to it.” But, however this may in former times have satisfied to silence objections, the fact that many good men have left the order in shame and disgust, and have proclaimed to the world at the risk of their lives the true inwardness of the institution, renders people slower to believe in its goodness and nobleness. I have long had, dear brother, a very decided and settled conviction that the order of Freemasonry is one with which no Christian, much less a Christian minister, should have any connection, and your oration has only tended to strengthen this conviction. You say that on the platform of Masonry, Jew and Gentile, Christian and Brahmin, can stand side by side. This is true, “and pity ’tis, ’tis true.” But what is the great leading principle in this platform, as stated by yourself? It is the “belief in God.” Yes, but what is God? You say, “the Creator, the Architect of the universe, the God of providence.” But this, after all, is not very explicit; for the Brahmin claims all this for his god. So whatever you may have done for the Brahmin, I don’t see that you have done any great thing for the Christian, and an ambassador of the Lord Jesus Christ, when you put him on a platform along side a Brahmin who believes in and worships his heathen god. You speak of the Bible as an indispensable article of furniture in every rightly constituted lodge. But I ask you, What Bible? In these lands, I know it is the Christian Bible; but what Bible does the Brahmin Mason use? Surely it is not the Christian’s Bible. What Bible will the Mahommedan use? Will it not be the Koran? What Bible will the Mormon Mason use? Will it not be the Book of Mormon? Here, then, is a strange mixture. Brahmin lodges, Mahommedan lodges, Mormon lodges, and Christian (?) lodges, each using a different Bible from the others, and yet all learning alike the principles of the order. Again I ask how it comes that a minister, and especially a Christian minister, can find anything “noble” in a sworn alliance on such a platform as this. But you aver that “your system is permeated and throbs through and through with the spirit of religion,” and you cite in evidence the prayers and worship of the lodge. Every well conducted lodge begins and closes its proceedings with prayer. May I venture to ask you as a Presbyterian minister, who I know believes in the Westminster Shorter Catechism, What is prayer? Is it not the “offering up of our desires to God for things agreeable to his will, in the name of Christ?” Can it be prayer to offer desires to God, and ignore the name of Christ? Is it not indispensable to our right approach to God that we come in the name of Christ? I am sure that you and I have one faith on this point. Our common faith is formulated by our Saviour, when he says: “No man cometh unto the Father but by me.” “I am the door; by me, if any man enter in, he shall be saved.” “Whatsoever ye shall ask in my name, that will I do, that the Father may be glorified in the Son.” Christ is the one and only mediator appointed by the Father. Man cannot come to God immediately. Our only way of access is through and by the merits of Christ. God is dishonored by prayers which are offered contrary to his appointed way. “He that honoreth not the Son honoreth not the Father.” But the Masons do not pray in the lodge in the name of Christ. Your platform does not warrant it. Your platform logically and of necessity forbids it. Masons are not required to believe in Christ. Your Jew brother, and your Unitarian brother, and infidel brother, to say nothing of the Brahmin, Mahommedan, and Mormon, would not allow it. So it comes to this, after all, that your praying in the lodge is only and wholly a solemn farce. It is an insult to Christ. It is a dishonor to God. God does not hear Masonic prayer. Your order is indeed “permeated and throbs through and through” with something like religion, but I would not call it religion. Better call it senseless mummery, or, better still, audacious blasphemy. How a Christian, and a Christian minister, can consistently enter into a sworn alliance with an order that thus dishonors Christ, is something I cannot reconcile. I could not but observe, too, that in your oration as published, there was no mention of Christ, or even indirect reference to him. In this respect your address was truly Masonic in the strictest sense. Surely this was not intentional on your part. I cannot bring myself to believe that you would knowingly bring dishonor to the Master we serve, that blessed Lord who died for us, and whose honor we should everywhere sacredly maintain. But pardon the allusion, when I say that as I read your address, and saw the absence of any reference to Christ, I could not help thinking of Absalom’s exclamation to Hushai: “Is this thy kindness to thy friend?”
You refer to heaven as the “lodge on high,” into which you and your brother Mason “hope to enter through the mercy of your God.” Yes, and your Brahmin brother hopes to enter the Grand Lodge above, through the mercy of his heathen god, and the Mahommedan brother, and Jew brother, and Unitarian brother, and infidel brother, and unregenerate brother, and all good Masons, whether they believe in Christ, Confucius, Mahomet, Joe Smith, or nothing, hope to go to heaven, to the “lodge on high,” through the mercy of their Masonic god. So we are to understand that Masonry is a saving institution. But what are the conditions of salvation in Masonry? Not, surely, the conditions of the Bible, which, as you and I believe, are faith in Christ, repentance unto life, and sanctification by the Holy Spirit. These cannot be the conditions on which Freemasonry proposes to save its members, for thousands of Masons in the world do not accept of the Christian’s Bible. The teachings of Masonry on this subject may be summarized in one brief sentence: “Obey Masonic law and live.” Salvation by Masonry is not salvation by the gospel. The teachings of Freemasonry are another gospel, in which there is no recognition of Christ and of the doctrine of justification by faith in his blood. This must be so, since, as you say, the Jew and Brahmin are on the same platform with you and share with you the hope of entering the “lodge on high,” through the mercy of the Masonic god. I know that you, personally, do not believe that God shows saving mercy to sinners except through Christ; but how, then, can you address your Jewish and Unitarian and unbelieving brethren as those who are to be associated with you hereafter in the “lodge on high,” as the possible spectators of the future progress of Masonry in this lower world.
Another great fundamental truth which you say enters into your platform, is the brotherhood of man. If I understand you correctly, you would represent the churches as sadly deficient in teaching faith in God and the brotherhood of man; for you claim that these tenets are the “strength of your order,” and say, “when these aspects of life are set in the forefront of the churches, then, and not till then,” do you expect “that Masonry and kindred orders will be superseded.”
But what does this doctrine of brotherhood, and boasted benevolence, as held and illustrated by Masons, amount to after all? It excludes all women, old men in their dotage, young men in their nonage, all deformed persons,—in short, it initiates none who are likely to become chargeable to the order. And yet you call this a benevolent institution, and would bid the churches come and sit at its feet and learn, and see illustrated the great doctrine of the brotherhood of man. Here is a true picture, as I believe, of the Masonic idea of brotherhood and benevolence: Suppose a large family consisting of an aged father and mother, five full-grown stalwart sons, two daughters, woman-grown, several small children and a crippled son, together with a servant or two. Suppose these five able-bodied sons organize a mutual aid and benevolent Society. Suppose the other members of the family apply for admission to this Society. The aged father applies, and they blackball him because he is too old; the mother and daughters apply and are told that women cannot be members of this Society; the younger children plead for the protection of their strong brothers, and they are told they are too young. The servants are blackballed because they are too poor, and to the piteous pleading of the little cripple, these heartless brothers say, they want nobody in their Society that is physically unsound. Would not everybody say it is a misnomer to call such a Society a benevolent institution? And yet such an unmitigated sham and fraud is the boasted benevolence of Masonry. Masonic benevolence is the refinement of selfishness.—Christian Cynosure.