AdventAI

EVERLASTING

By H. H. Burkholder

From Review and Herald, Vol. 61, No. 49., December 9, 1884

BY H. H. BURKHOLDER.

Great stress is placed upon this word to prove the doctrine of the endless punishment of the wicked, but with what reason the following facts will show.

The Hebrew word, which is the equivalent of the Greek, is thus used: “I will give thee the land of Canaan for an everlasting possession” (Gen. 17:8); and in verse 13 the covenant of circumcision is called “an everlasting covenant.” And yet the Jews were driven from the land of Canaan, and the covenant of circumcision was abolished, eighteen hundred ago! The priesthood of Aaron is called “an everlasting priesthood” (Exod. 40:15); and yet it was put aside by God’s authority, and the priesthood of Christ set up in its place.

Now, did Jehovah use the word “everlasting” as meaning endless? If he did, then he has broken his promise to the Jews, or, if not this, the priesthood of Christ is an imposture, and the old covenant is still in force.

In Matt. 25:46 we find a text that is regarded by many as settling forever the endless duration of punishment: “And these shall go away into everlasting punishment: but the righteous into life eternal.” The argument here is that “eternal life” and “everlasting punishment” are set against each other, and that one is just as long as the other. We admit that the word is often used to signify a strict eternity; but in such cases it takes its force from the subject or persons to whom it is applied. For example, in the expression “everlasting God,” everlasting means endless, because God is immortal, not by any force of its own. The word “everlasting” borrows its endlessness from God, not God from “everlasting.” So, in all cases, the adjective is modified by the noun. A strong horse, a strong mind, strong drink, strong language—in each one of these phrases “strong” has a different meaning, according to the nature of the subject or noun. So of a wise man, a wise God; in the last case the word “wise” means infinite wisdom, but not in the first; and the meaning of infinite is not in “wise” but in “God.” It is the same with “everlasting;” it never has the force of endless in itself. In order to make it mean endless when applied to punishment, it must be shown that punishment is in its nature as necessarily endless and infinite as God is.

Now my reply to Matt. 25:46 is, that the life of the blest is not presumed to be endless because of the word “everlasting,” but because of God’s infinite goodness,—the same reason which weighs against the presumption that the punishment of the wicked is endless. Show that there is as much reason from the nature of God to suppose that evil and suffering will be endless as that good and happiness will be, and there may be some force to the argument. In conclusion, will you please read Isa. 10:17, 18; Mal. 4:1–3; also Obad. 15:16.

—The holy soul ought to be so strong it would not feel burdens.—C. P. Masten.