AdventAI

THE QUESTION CORNER.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 61, No. 50., December 16, 1884

THE THIRD JUDGE.

Who was the third judge of Israel?

A. N.

Answer : Shamgar. See Judges 3 : 31.

THE BREATH OF LIFE.

A Pennsylvania superintendent is in deep theological trouble, as the following letter plainly shows :—

“There were some texts of Scripture used in the lesson on the nature of man that I cannot understand as they are there explained. One is Eccl. 12 : 7. The Spirit spoken of cannot be the breath in the body; for, don’t you see, if the breath by simply going out into the surrounding atmosphere could be said to return to God, we could just as reasonably say the dust returns to God by mingling with the surrounding dust. When Nicodemus came to Jesus he told him that he must be born again; that is, born of the Spirit; and in Rom. 8 : 9, 10, 11, it is made very plain that we have a spirit that God takes to himself at death, and will restore it at the resurrection, which is our eternal life. I cannot explain this as I would if I could talk it to you; but I think these texts that are used in regard to the Spirit apply only to the sons of God, and not to the sinner or man in an unconverted state. I do not think this spirit that comes by the new birth has any consciousness after death; it is simply the earnest of our inheritance until the redemption of the purchased possession. Eph. 1 : 13, 14.”

The spirit spoken of in Eccl. 12 : 7 is ruach, the primary meaning of which is breath. See Gesenius. It must be the same as that breathed into man by God at his creation; for the way in which man dies, as described in the text before us, is just the reverse of the process by which he was created, as described in Gen. 2 : 7. Notice : In his creation, man was formed of the dust; in his dissolution, the dust returns to dust as it was. In his creation, the breath of life was given him by the Creator; in his dissolution that breath of life went back to God who gave it. In his creation, the breathing into his nostrils the breath of life caused him to live; in his dissolution, the taking away of that breath caused him to die. The conclusion, then, cannot be questioned, that the spirit which goes back to God at man’s death is the breath of life which God gave man at his creation.

But now the question arises, What is this breath of life? In answer, it may be positively said that, so far from its being something possessed by man alone, all the animals have it in common with him. Compare the following : “Breathed into his nostrils the nishmath chayyim, breath of lives.” Gen. 2 : 7. “Two by two of all flesh, wherein is the ruach chayyim, spirit of lives.” Gen. 7 : 15. “All in whose nostrils was the nishmath ruach chayyim, breath of spirit of lives.” Gen. 7 : 22.

I conclude, therefore, that the breath of life was the life principle,—that by which the complicated machinery of man’s organism was made to throb with life. It was something more than common air, for the perfectly formed, yet lifeless, man was surrounded with that before. Air, or breath, may be said to support life after it is given; but it is not life itself. The life principle was imparted to the lifeless organism by God. He chose to impart it through the breath. He might have imparted it in many other ways, or by a simple command, but he chose to breathe it into man’s nostrils; and because the breath was the means of conveying the life from God to man, it is called the breath of life. This life was not intelligent or conscious, much less immortal. The spirit’s going to God at death, is not the breathing out of the air which filled the lungs into the surrounding air,—but the taking away by Jehovah of the life principle, which having been imparted in and through the breath or spirit, is also taken away in the same manner.

Concerning the case of Nicodemus and the passage in Rom. 8 : 9-11, it need only be said that the spirit there referred to is the Holy Spirit, and not an inherent part of man’s nature. The Spirit of Christ which dwells in the true Christian, places him in such a relation to God that his life is said to be hid with Christ in God; and at the resurrection, he is raised to eternal life by the Spirit of Christ that he enjoyed in this life. This relation to God the unconverted man does not of course possess; the Spirit of Christ does not dwell in him. C. C. L.