THE JEWS AND SUNDAY

7%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Feb 16, 1886

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 7.

Read the full edition

THE JEWS AND SUNDAY.

The Rabbinical Conference held last November in Pittsburg, Pa., unanimously adopted the proposition to hold services in the Jewish synagogues on Sunday as well as Saturday; and a late number of the Jewish Reformer is devoted to a discussion of this proposition.
Alluding to this matter, the New York Independent of Feb. 4, 1886, says:—
“We would like to contribute one suggestion toward the settlement of this very serious matter. The difficulty which the Jews find is this: The community so generally makes Saturday a day of labor and Sunday a day of rest from business, that synagogues can get only the smallest audiences on Saturday, while on Sunday the people can be easily got together. Yet the Mosaic law requires that the day of rest and worship shall be the seventh in the week. Now let us suggest that the difficulty be avoided by their beginning the week on Monday instead of on Sunday. Days are variable things. Whether the day is Saturday or Sunday depends on which direction you take in crossing the Pacific Ocean. The Mosaic law nowhere requires the seventh day of the week to come on Saturday. The Jews can, if they will, make it come on Sunday, by beginning their week on Monday. They have made many greater changes than that.”
Two statements in the foregoing we are glad to see: first, that this is a very serious matter; and secondly, that the week is called “the week,” and is thereby recognized as a definite period of time. But having made these admissions, the writer then seems to plunge the subject into inextricable difficulties:—
1. The day to be observed is apparently made contingent on surrounding circumstances, as if the commandment was worded something like this: “Remember the Sabbath day to keep it holy. The seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God; in it thou shalt not do any work, etc., provided, all the community observe that day, and you can gather a congregation to worship in the synagogues. If not, take any other day you please.” But no such contingencies are recognized in the commandment.
2. Reference is made to what the Mosaic law requires. By “Mosaic” we are, of course, to understand that system of worship which, so to speak, originated with him—those institutions of which he was, under God, the visible author. But the Sabbath did not originate with him. It was not communicated to the people through him, any more than were the commandments not to steal and not to kill. It came directly from God to men. The institution and the law for its observance were both given to Adam, while he was yet in his innocency. Such a person as a Jew was not then even contemplated, unless Adam was one. And when God spoke from Sinai, he enunciated those great and perfect principles of righteousness which are binding upon the whole human family. Having spoken these, and there being six more of the same nature to follow, did he inadvertently introduce as the fourth in the series a commandment which was merely local and temporary in its nature? Does Deity become thus confused? and did that condition continue till he had with his own finger engraved that also with the immortal and immutable nine upon the imperishable tables? He calls the Sabbath, not the “Sabbath of Moses,” nor “of the Jews,” nor “your Sabbath,” but always the “Sabbath of the Lord,” or “my holy day.” The Hebrews, in a world wholly apostate, were for a time set apart by God to be his peculiar people. What was the sign of this relationship between them? It was the observance of the Sabbath. Has the worshiper of the true God any other sign, or can there be any other sign, of such relationship to-day? When a person takes God to be his God, he takes him with all the claims which God has upon him, and all the obligations which exist on the part of the individual to obey God; he takes him with whatever pertains to him. But God has a Sabbath which is his because his rights are involved in it; but he made it for man, and gave it to him, because man’s highest good is involved in it. And this institution which God made, not to use himself, but for man to use for his own good and in honor of his Maker, belongs to all men, and is to be used by all men whose God the Lord is. And whose God is he? Is he the God of the Jews only? The apostle has taken the pains to affirm expressly that he is the God of the Gentiles also. Rom. 3: 29. Whoever, therefore, claims that God is his God, falsifies that claim if he refuses to keep the Sabbath which belongs to that God whom he professes to acknowledge.
3. But from the stand-point of the Independent, that the Sabbath is a Mosaic institution, how shall we understand its appeal to that law to regulate the practice even of the Jews themselves? Is that law still binding upon them? If not, why does it not urge them to make the change on the ground that the Christian system has superseded the Jewish? But if the Mosaic law has not passed away, if it has not become obsolete and given place to a more perfect dispensation, if by observing it we do not deny Christ and fall from grace, and if the Jews are still under obligation to keep it, then it is still binding upon all.
4. Again, the Independent claims that the Jews could change their count so as to make Sunday the seventh day, and then could keep it according to the Mosaic law, or rather that so keeping it would be obedience to the Mosaic law. But many Christians call Sunday the seventh day, and keep it as such. Indeed, it is becoming quite popular with many, who see no other way to face the letter of the fourth commandment, to claim that Sunday is the original seventh day. Are such by so doing keeping the Mosaic law? If not, how would the Jew keep it by doing the same thing? And if they are, then Seventh-day Adventists are not the only “Judaisers” after all. But Christians will not acknowledge that they are keeping the law of Moses, even though doing that which, on the part of a Jew, would be just that and nothing more. Then we inquire what law they are keeping in the observance of Sunday? Or are they keeping that day without any law? Where is the law for it? Is there any law for Christians or any one else, to keep a Sabbath, or any seventh day, except that law which the Independent is pleased to style “Mosaic”? How is this?
5. There seems to be still another difficulty in the way of the suggestion made by the Independent. After the Jews have kept the seventh day as they now observe it, their week has come to an end. It is now suggested that they then begin their count on Monday. But what would they do with the intervening Sunday? If they work on that day and right on till the next Sunday, they work seven days; but the law says they must work only six. If they rest on that day as a Sabbath, they bring two Sabbaths together, which is certainly contrary to the law. Moreover, they are keeping the first day of the week, they having just finished their week, by keeping the seventh day the day before; but the law says, however we may reckon the week, that it must be the seventh day; and with all the Sunday legerdemain, we doubt if two successive days can both be made out to be the seventh day, from the same starting point. Can any one tell us how they could make the change suggested without infringing their law?
6. We find the week also fearfully mixed according to the position suggested. “The Jews can,” it is declared, “if they will, make it [the seventh day of the week] come on Sunday.” Then some one else can make it come on Monday, and another on Tuesday, and so on through the week, so that of the whole period of seven successive days, we find that every one of them is the seventh day of the week. Then where are the other days? Oh! every one of these days is also the first day, and every one the second, and so on through to the seventh. This mixes things worse than the doctrine of the Trinity, for here we have seven in one and one in seven; any day of the week is any and all of the others; and all the days of the week are any one. We can readily conceive that as the week consists of seven days, any period of seven days may be said to constitute a week, duration only being considered; just as we may speak of a year, whether reckoned from January to January or from March to March; and any day might be the seventh day of such random weekly period. But mark, it is “the week,” not a week that is under discussion. And really is not “the week” everywhere recognized as a definite and well-established cycle? If a man performing some act on Monday should declare that it was on the fifth day of the week, would not all Christendom at once correct him, and say, No, sir; it was on the second day of the week, not the fifth? Among all the nations where the week is an established measurement of time, can a single instance be found in which the week of one people differs from that of another? Does not the week of the remotest antiquity correspond exactly to the week of to-day? Do not the most recent archæological discoveries bear wonderful testimony to this fact? To go still further back, did not the week come, in the direct providence of God, from the events of the creation of the world—the work of God in six days and his rest on the seventh? and was not an arrangement there established, at least in the matter of Sabbath-keeping, from which men could not depart and be guiltless?
7. Another statement from which we must utterly dissent is this: “Whether a day is Saturday or Sunday depends on which direction you take in crossing the Pacific Ocean.” The day line running through the Pacific Ocean is recognized by all navigators. On this line the day changes; here two days abut against each other. Time immediately west of this line is one day in advance of time immediately east of it. Now a man crossing that line from the east on Saturday, does not carry Saturday with him into the western regions beyond, but himself steps out of Saturday a day in advance, that is, into Sunday. And on the other hand, crossing the day line from the west on Sunday, he does not carry Sunday with him into the regions east, but himself steps back a day into Saturday. Therefore, whether a day is Saturday or Sunday does not depend in the least on which direction a person takes in crossing the Pacific Ocean. It is Saturday and Sunday on their respective sides of the line, just the same, whichever way he crosses it, or whether he crosses it at all or not. One thing only depends on the direction in which he crosses it, and that is, whether he will be in Saturday or Sunday. That is all.
8. “The Mosaic law nowhere requires the seventh day of the week to come on Saturday.” Not the Mosaic law, but the law and providence of God, established the week, and set apart the seventh day of that week for religious rest and worship. And God pointed out by the threefold miracle of the manna, every week for forty years, in the wilderness, which day he meant by the seventh day; and there certainly has been no break or derangement of the week from that day to this. But that seventh day, men have taken and applied to it the name of a heathen deity, and called it Saturday. Now is it not a most singular remark that “the Mosaic law nowhere requires the seventh day of the week to come on Saturday”! The law of the seventh day, we imagine, has very little to do with the name “Saturday,” or with the heathen deity from which it is derived. We imagine, further, that what the law requires is that men strip from the seventh day the heathen title they have given it, and call it by the name which God has fixed upon it; namely, “the Sabbath”; and then that they take off their feet from it (Isa. 58: 13, 14), cease trampling it into the dust, and remember it to keep it holy, as he has solemnly commanded them to do.
But perhaps after all these remarks are all misdirected; for the more we consider the matter, the more it seems to us that the Independent could not in the foregoing quotation have been offering any serious suggestion at all, but only indulging in a lot of pleasantry.