SUNDAY THE CHRISTIAN SABBATH

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 30, 1886

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 13.

Read the full edition

“SUNDAY THE CHRISTIAN SABBATH.”

A SUPPLEMENT.

BY A. SMITH.
I HAVE reviewed a portion of a serial article on the Sabbath question by the editor of the Michigan Christian Advocate; but Mr. A having continued his effort, I note a few additional points of interest.
In his fourth paper Mr. A quotes Heb. 4 : 1–11, giving the revised rendering, and reasons therefrom as follows: “Here we have a plain statement of the seventh-day Sabbath for the Jews after the example of God’s rest in the creative work. . . . Then we have just as clear a statement of the first-day Sabbath for Christians, after the example of Christ’s rest [probably including the Sunday fishing precedent at the Sea of Tiberias. John 21 : 1–13] from the work of redemption.”
The first day of the week is not mentioned at all in the texts above quoted, but the seventh day is. Wherein, then, is the statement of the first-day Sabbath just as clear as that concerning the seventh-day? Dr. Adam Clarke, commenting on the rest that remaineth, mentioned in Heb. 4 : 9, which Mr. A says is the first-day Sabbath, has the following: “It was not (1) the rest of the Sabbath; it was not (2) the rest in the promised land: therefore there is another rest, a state of blessedness, for the people of God: and this is the gospel, . . . and the eternal glory it prepares for.”
Mr. A then lays great stress on the term “another day,” making it opposed to the term “seventh day.” But the candid reader will see by a careful reading of Heb. 4 : 8, that the term is opposed, not to the seventh day, but to the rest that Joshua gave the Israelites in the land of Canaan. Mr. A admits that the apostles did frequently teach in the Jewish synagogues on the seventh-day Sabbath; but only so as to get a hearing of the people. But why, I ask, did the apostles ever call that day the Sabbath, if it was no longer the Sabbath; and why did they not somewhere call the first day of the week the Sabbath if it was such? Mr. A next quotes Rom. 14 : 5, and hints that the term day therein refers to the weekly Sabbath. But unfortunately for his argument, it would include Sunday as well as the seventh day, and would therefore prove it to have been a matter of indifference to Christians as to what day they kept, or whether they kept any at all, so long as they were individually satisfied or persuaded in their own minds. Dr. Adam Clarke says on this verse: “Reference is made here to the Jewish institutions, and especially their festivals, such as the Passover, Pentecost, Feast of Tabernacles, New Moons, Jubilee, etc.,” and denies that Christians are at liberty to so regard the Sabbath.
Mr. A: “At length God formally manifested his will respecting the new order of things, by inspiring St. John to designate the first-day Sabbath by its proper name, ‘Lord’s day.’ Rev. 1 : 10.”
From Ex. 20 : 10; Isa. 58 : 13; and Matt. 12 : 8, is proved that the seventh-day Sabbath is the Lord’s day. But, admitting for argument’s sake that the term Lord’s day in Rev. 1 : 10 means the first day of the week, it is not called the Sabbath at all. Suppose that the early Christians did frequently meet for worship on Sunday, it cannot be proved that they did not also do likewise on the seventh day; nor that such assembling served to sanctify the day. God’s command alone can sanctify the weekly Sabbath; but in the case of the first day it is entirely wanting.
In his last paper Mr. A plunges into the writings of the early Fathers, and comes out of the bath covered with the down of tradition. Quoting from the reputed writings of Ignatius, whose genuineness is questioned by eminent first-day scholars, he says: “If those who were concerned with old things have come to newness of hope, no longer keeping (Jewish) Sabbaths, but living according to the Lord’s day, in which our life has arisen again through him and his death.” Concerning this quotation, Andrews, in his Testimony of the Fathers, says: “But the so-called Lord’s day is only brought in by means of a false translation [of the Greek text, which he renders], literally: ‘No longer Sabbatizing, but living according to the Lord’s life.’ Eminent first-day scholars . . . have testified explicitly that the term Lord’s day has no right to appear in the translation.”
Further on Mr. A says: “Again he [Ignatius] called the Lord’s day the ‘queen and chief of all days.’”
But, bad for his theory, Mr. A has ignorantly or dishonestly left out an important point in Ignatius’ testimony. It reads, literally, as follows: “And after the observance of the Sabbath, let every friend of Christ keep the Lord’s day as a festival, the resurrection day, the queen and chief of all the days.”—Chap. 9. Mr. A then professes to quote from Irenaeus, but he does not give the chapter where it may be found, evidently for the good reason that it does not appear in Irenaeus’ writings at all, nor in those of any other of the early Fathers that we can find.
Mr. A next quotes from Justin Martyr as follows: “‘On the day called Sunday, there is a gathering in one place of all who reside either in the cities or in the country places, and the memoirs of the apostles and the writings of the prophets are read.’—Apology, I., 67. He goes on to give reasons for keeping this day; viz., ‘Because it is the first day on which God, having wrought a change in the darkness and matter, made the world; and Jesus Christ our Saviour, on the same day rose from the dead. For he was crucified on the day before that of Saturn (Saturday), and on the day after that of Saturn, which is the day of the sun, having appeared to his apostles and disciples, he taught them these things, which we have submitted to you also for your consideration.’ This statement is of priceless value” as serving to show that Jesus taught his disciples “to observe the first day of the week.”
Doubtless it is of priceless value to the first-day Sabbath cause, just as a morsel of bread is of priceless value to a starving man, or a drop of water to one dying of thirst in the desert. On the best food that can be gathered for it, this papal Sunday Sabbath will continue to be “poor and very ill-favored and lean-fleshed.” The “Apology” of Justin Martyr, from which Mr. A quotes, was addressed to a heathen emperor of Rome. The following testimony concerning Justin Martyr is conclusive: “The idea of the change of the Sabbath from the seventh day of the week to the first, is . . . never found in his writings.”—Andrews’ Testimony of the Fathers, p. 34.
The reader will doubtless notice, that, by indorsing Justin Martyr’s statement that God began the work of creation on Sunday, Mr. A repudiates his own position, and that of others he has quoted, that God instituted Sunday as the Sabbath in Gen. 2 : 3. (See my former articles.) He goes on to cite numerous early Fathers, by none of whom the first day of the week is ever termed the Sabbath at all. On the decree of Constantine he makes a waspish dab at “Seventh-day Advents” (Adventists), and says of the decree: “It simply made the Lord’s day the legal Sabbath.” But Constantine was a heathen emperor, and his first decree was in behalf of the “venerable day of the sun.”
By his appeal to the Fathers, Mr. A has practically repudiated the following dogma of the Methodist church:—
Ques. “78. What is the only sufficient rule of a Christian’s faith and practice?—The word of God, as contained in the Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments.”
Having “strained his milk through a coal sack,” Mr. A concludes that it is “ample” (probably in its nourishing qualities), and thinks that no intelligent Christian mind can be disturbed by subtle essays and lectures in favor of the seventh-day Sabbath; and claims that to deny the sacredness of the first-day Sabbath “is practically to deny our Lord’s divinity, and crucify him afresh.” We can assure Mr. A that “essays and lectures” will be given until the world is warned that this first-day Sabbath is a papal institution, and until the seventh-day Sabbath cause shall arise and triumph in victory. The final Judgment day will determine on which side of the question the “intelligent Christian” is found.