AdventAI

LOVE AND LAW ABIDE TOGETHER.

By Dudley Marvin Canright

From Review and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 13., March 30, 1886

The widely known president of Princeton College, James McCosh, D. D., LL. D., as reported in the Christian Union of March 11, 1886, has just said some good things upon this subject. He clearly points out the danger into which the Church is running to-day by exalting love and humanity, and discarding law and justice. We can give only a few extracts from this able sermon. Dr. McCosh says:—

“Law was in the nature of God from all eternity, and is the instrument of his government. It was inscribed on the nature of man when he was created; it was graven by God’s own finger on the granite blocks of Sinai; it was spoken in gentle and attractive tones by our Lord in the Sermon on the Mount; and it is written by God’s own Spirit as a new commandment on the hearts of God’s people. It goes with man wherever he goes, to tell him, if he is prepared to listen to it, what is right and what is wrong, and in the end to punish him if he refuses to obey. It is so essential a part of his nature that it will follow him into the regions below, to torment him more than the worm that never dies, than the fire that is not quenched.”

“That law has been broken, but is still binding. When Moses came down from the mount with the two tables, he threw them from him, and broke them, as he witnessed the wickedness of the children of Israel. But he had just to re-ascend the mount, and have them written again by God’s own finger. Which thing may be unto us for an allegory. Man has broken God’s law; but that law retains all its claims, and ever renews them. The law is embodied in the gospel. All this was instructively represented in the ark of the covenant, laid up in the holiest of all, and typifying the new covenant. On the lid of it were the cherubim, overshadowing the blood-sprinkled mercy-seat; and the promise was given: ‘There I will meet with thee, and I will commune with thee from above the mercy-seat, from between the two cherubim.’ But within the ark were the two tables of stone. Christ came, not to destroy the law, but to fulfill it. The gospel, wherever it goes, carries within it the law fulfilled by Christ, the law still binding on his followers. There is a sense in which believers are free from the law; they are free from its curse; but in another sense they are still under it; they are not free from the obligation to obey it. When sinners come to Christ, he welcomes them. He says, Your sins be forgiven you; but he does not give them liberty to go back to their sins, but, ‘Go, and sin no more.’ Just as the father, after rejoicing over the return of his prodigal son, took him into his house to keep him in safety, so our heavenly Father takes us into his family to train us to obedience. When the sinner comes to Christ, Christ pays his debts; but it is only to send him to pay his dues, not in the oldness of the letter, but in the newness of the spirit. In heaven itself, the soul, brought into unison with the law of love, will be fulfilling it to perfection; and the music of heaven will consist essentially in attuned hearts, each breathing its own melody, and all in harmony—hearts in accord with the heart of God, and in accord with one another, and fulfilling the pleasure of God forever and ever.”

“The law has . . . its definite requirements which it cannot forego, and will not lower. ‘Guilty or not guilty’ are the alternatives it proposes. It admits of no middle course or compromise; it accepts of no excuse; it will not listen to any plea or extenuation.”

“Charity never tries to set itself above law; if it did so, it might work only mischief. ‘Love is the fulfilling of the law.’ Love takes the form of a commandment. When asked by the lawyer, ‘Which is the great commandment in the law?’ Jesus said unto him, ‘Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind. This is the first and great commandment. And the second is like unto it, Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself. On these two commandments hang all the law and the prophets.’ Thus indissolubly are charity and commandment joined in Scripture. It is love that makes us like unto God, who is love; but the love of God is a love regulated by eternal justice.p. 202

“We cannot by any process of analysis get rid of either of these elements. Defective systems of ethics arise from omitting one or the other, not giving each its due place. A stoic, a Pharisaic, morality leaves out love, and presents only the expressionless form of law. Utilitarianism leaves out eternal and unchangeable obligation, and offers a flexible morality, suiting itself to supposed results. . . . All this implies that alongside of love there is law, commanding and demanding. As far as the eye can reach, the two are seen to run parallel. I do not say that they never meet; for they meet in the nature of God and of all holy beings. And, though often dissevered here, they will meet at last in the character of saints in heaven, with whom love will be law, and law will be love.”

“‘What therefore God hath joined together, let not man put asunder.’ There is no propriety in drawing invidious comparisons as to the relative importance of the two. It might be argued that law is the higher; for it commands love, says when it is to flow, and where it is to stay. But then, love is the very end for which the law exists; the end of the commandment is charity. Law without love is a mere form without life; love without law is a life without a body in which to reside. Law without love is a channel without a stream; love without law may be a stream, bursting forth and spreading destruction. Let the two revolve around each other like binary stars, each with its own color, the one the complement of the other.”

“We are now more in danger of a sentimental and a simpering faith, acting the part of a Delilah, professing love to the man who boasts that he is strong, only in the end to show how weak he is, and to consign him to blindness and darkness. Let us have charity, they say; but charity without principle to guide it, may distribute its gifts very indiscriminately and injuriously. Let us have fire, they insist; but we cannot have fire without fuel to feed it, and fire cannot be allowed to burn and consume in every place, and as it pleases. There should be a vessel to contain the pleasant incense that we offer, otherwise it will soon dissipate into inanity. . . . More evil may arise from lawless love, which is fascinating, than from hatred, which is repulsive. There is a teaching in our day antagonistic to the old and orthodox theology. It does not take, it cannot be made to take, any scientific form. It would let down doctrine and exalt charity, and would thereby make religion easier and more attractive—as they suppose. It is ‘Broad Church’ in England, delivering itself from all creed. It is the ‘Religion of Humanity’ in this country, instead of the ‘Religion of Divinity for Humanity.’ It would free humanity from certain restraints and sacrifices, with the view of exalting it. It is not just the same, but it is analogous to the attempt in the last century to do away with doctrine on the pretence of exalting morality, and which led to dry High Churchism in England, to Moderatism in Scotland and Ulster, to Rationalism on the Continent of Europe, and to Unitarianism in this country; and ended in all in the decay of religion and the lowering of morality. The new gospel which has appeared among us is evidently running a like career. Doctrine is discarded first; duty goes next, in the next man or in the next age.”

“Love and Law, with God in both, is the sum of all morality. We should regard it as our highest end to come under the two in their union. The one will give motive to exertion, which will be directed in the right way by the other. The one will impel to all that is good, the other will restrain from all evil. The one will set you out and carry you on in the journey, the other will show you the path you ought to take. The one will be the spring of waters, the other the channel in which to flow. The one will be the centrifugal, the other the centripetal, force, to keep you circulating around the Sun of righteousness. The two will guide and guard you through life and on to heaven, where they melt into one in God’s character and in yours, and love will be law, and law love.”

We call that sound sense, and Scriptural, too. Let simpering, sentimental, all-love-and-no-law advocates read and meditate thereupon. D. M. CANRIGHT.