A REVIEW.
BY A. SMITH.
In the Michigan Christian Advocate of Jan. 9, appears the first number of a serial article under the above heading, which in an editorial is claimed to have been read before the Detroit Ministerial Union, and to have been recommended by that body for publication. The writer, whom for convenience we will term Mr. A, after a brief introduction, makes his first proposition in the form of the following question and affirmation:— “Is the Christian Sabbath day of divine authority?—Yes! unqualifiedly and unmistakably, yes!” In support of his proposition he starts out with the assertion that “the Sabbath is not a day;—it is not Sunday, nor Saturday, nor any other day; it is holy rest unto the Lord. . . . Nowhere in the Bible are we commanded to keep holy Saturday, or Sunday, or any other day, as a specific and unalterable period of time; but everywhere are we commanded to keep holy the Sabbath.”
Let us compare Mr. A’s assertion with Bible testimony: “And God blessed the seventh day, and sanctified it.” Gen. 2:3. “Remember the Sabbath day to keep it holy. . . . The seventh day is the Sabbath.” Ex. 20:8–10; see also Deut. 5:12, 14; Matt. 12:1, 8, etc. The terms Saturday and Sunday are not in the Bible. Mr. A knows very well, which we can also prove from his own arguments, that Saturday is the seventh day; but he very evidently substitutes the name of the day for the number in order to disguise the truth.
Mr. A makes several excellent admissions concerning the law of God,—“The moral law was not abrogated with the peculiar national law of the Jews.” “In every age and country men are under obligations to keep God’s law, and hence to keep God’s Sabbath.” “The ten commandments were never abolished.” “If the ten commandments have not been abolished, the fourth, or Sabbath commandment, has not been abolished,”—and in proof thereof quotes Matt. 5:17; Rom. 3:31; 1 John 3:4. (A seventh-day observer could not have done better within the same space.) But unfortunately he daubs the excellent structure which he thus rears, with the following: “James warns Christians to live so as to be judged by the gospel, and not by the law (chap. 2:8–13).” (The moral law is a law of liberty to those who keep it.) Mr. A also contradicts himself as follows: “The law was our school-master to bring us to Christ. This is especially true of the Sabbath law. The Jewish Sabbath law was designed to lead directly to the better Christian Sabbath law.”
By the terms “law,” “Jewish Sabbath law,” etc., does Mr. A mean the moral law, and the fourth commandment of the same? If so, wherein does the design he speaks of appear? The Bible nowhere so declares it. And as to the “better Christian Sabbath law,” where can it be found? Neither Mr. A nor any one else has ever given us the text. If the moral law, as Mr. A evidently means to assert, was our school-master to bring us to Christ, then, according to Gal. 3:25, when faith is come, we are no longer under the moral law. Paul makes no distinction between the commandments of the moral law (admitting that he refers to that law in Gal. 3:24, which we deny); but Mr. A does make a difference, to the discredit of the fourth commandment, upon which he reasons thus: “If Christians are not under law, but under grace, they are not under the Sabbath of the law, but under the Sabbath of grace.”
Let us apply the same syllogistic reasoning to the fifth commandment: If Christians are not under the law, but under grace, they are not under obligation to honor their parents of the law (their natural parents), but their parents of grace (their fathers and mothers in Christ. See 1 Cor. 4:15), and therefore, of course, under no obligation to honor their natural parents. Such reasoning would be in harmony with the spirit of this age, and would serve as an excellent supplement to Matt. 15:5, 6.
The office of a school-master is to instruct; but the moral law of ten commandments gives no instruction in itself that would lead any one to Christ. It convicts of sin, and is a rule of life to the obedient, but we find in it no provision of grace; but the ordinances under the ceremonial law typified the sacrifice and ministry of Christ, and thus served as a school-master to bring us to him. Had the school-master used the rod upon Mr. A, he might, perhaps, if possible, have learned a better lesson on this Sabbath question.
Mr. A persists in calling the Sabbath of the fourth commandment “Jewish.” But it is nowhere so called in the Bible. God calls it his Sabbath. See Ex. 20:10; 31:13; Isa. 58:13. Is it not, therefore, an insult to the Author of the Sabbath to persist in calling it Jewish? Mr. A says “Moses gave it [“the law Sabbath,” as he terms it] to the Israelites;” but farther on in his article he says “the Jews fixed upon the seventh day of the week for their Sabbath rest.” Syllogistic conclusion: Therefore Moses was the Jews. It was not Moses who gave the Sabbath, but God himself. See Ex. 20:12. Mr. A says: “The fourth commandment reads, ‘Keep the Sabbath day to sanctify it.’” The words which he quotes are not in the fourth commandment, but in Deut. 5:12. Such a blunder in quoting is hardly pardonable in a man of Mr. A’s supposable erudition.
Mr. A says of the Sabbath, “It was commemorative of national deliverance. The Jew was to remember his deliverance from Egyptian bondage as often as his Sabbath day returned. Those who now imitate the Jews must be equally mindful of this Jewish memorial.” In another place he quotes Deut. 5:15 in support of this position. The truth is, that when the Jews were in bondage, they could not properly keep the Sabbath nor observe the principles of justice and mercy (see Lev. 19:32–37); but now that they were free, they were under renewed obligation to observe both. According to Mr. A’s argument, we cannot keep the seventh-day Sabbath unless we are mindful of this memorial, and thereby “concede that the Jewish Sabbath was not intended for every age and nation.” But the same rule would apply equally well to the principles of justice and mercy as we have seen. See also Deut. 24:17, 18.
Mr. A further says: “For a period of two thousand years prior to the time of the giving of the law by Moses, there is no evidence of regular Sabbath-keeping. The people forgot God, forgot duty, lost sight and thought of spiritual worship, and served other gods.” He should have added that he himself forgot to read Gen. 5:22, 24 with Heb. 11:5; Gen. 7:1; 17:17–19; 26:5; and Ex. 1:17, 20, 21; and that God who uttered the law in awful majesty from Mt. Sinai, and wrote it on tables of stone, did not forget the order of the weekly cycle from creation. Mr. A probably forgot also, if he ever knew (which is doubtful, if he is an honest writer), that other writers who observe the first-day Sabbath like himself, flatly contradict his statement concerning the observance of the Sabbath from Adam to Moses. See “Dictionary of the Bible,” by Wm. Smith, art. Sabbath; Dr. Scott’s Com. on Gen. 2:3; etc.
Mr. A: “That in selecting the Jewish Sabbath day he [Moses] selected the regular successive seventh day of human time from Adam down, cannot be proved by any authority, human or divine.” Quoting from Rev. George Elliott, in his work on “The Abiding Sabbath,” he says: “There is no possible means of fixing the day of the original Sabbath.” But Mr. A contradicts himself and Mr. Elliott as follows: “Adam rested ‘according to the commandment’ the first day of human time. . . . He worked six days and rested the seventh, but the seventh came next on the first day (Sunday) of the second week of human time, and so on until . . . the Hebrews began to observe Saturday. . . . However the Jews may have fallen into the custom of observing Saturday as their Sabbath, that custom was done away by the ushering in of the new dispensation, by the force of Christ’s own example, and by the usages and teachings of the apostles and early Fathers.”
So it seems, after all, that Mr. A knows, or believes he knows, that the Sabbath of Gen. 2:3 was Sunday; that the day the Jews kept wasp. 163 Saturday; that the day of the resurrection was Sunday; and that Sunday has ever since been kept as a memorial of the resurrection. But he admits that the idea that the Sabbath of Gen. 2:3 was the first day of the week, or Sunday, “seems not to have entered into the calculation of the Jews.” And we might add, nor into the calculation of any one else till it became necessary to invent a theory to justify disobedience to the Sabbath of the Bible, of the apostles, and of the early Fathers. Let us test his assertion. The following are all the texts in the New Testament that mention the “first day” of the week at all: Matt. 28:1; Mark 16:2, 9; Luke 24:1; John 20:1, 19; Acts 20:7; 1 Cor. 16:2. Not one text calls the first day of the week the Sabbath. But these texts refer to the seventh-day Sabbath: Luke 23:56; Mark 16:1; Acts 17:2; 16:13; 18:3, 4, 11; 13:42, 44. Let the reader determine on which side the power of example lies.
How reliable the so-called testimony of the early Fathers is, whose example is of so much value to Mr. A, the following testimonies will sufficiently show:—
“When God’s word is by the Fathers expounded, construed, and glossed, then, in my judgment, it is even like one that straineth milk through a coal-sack, which must needs spoil the milk, and make it black; even so likewise, God’s word of itself is sufficiently pure, clean, bright, and clear; but through the doctrines, books, and writings, of the Fathers, it is very surely darkened, falsified, and spoiled.”—Martin Luther.
“We should be cautious how we appeal to heathen, however eminent, in behalf of morality; because much may be collected from them on the other side. In like manner we should take heed how we quote the Fathers in proof of the doctrines of the gospel; because he who knows them best, knows that on many of those subjects they blow hot and cold.”—Autobiography of Adam Clarke, book 3, p. 134.
Mr. A says that the Jews made the slightest violation of the Sabbath, “even incidentally, punishable with death,” not even the kindling of a fire on the Sabbath day being allowed. As to the death penalty, it was inflicted only on the willful transgressor. See Num. 15:30, 31. It was also executed for the violation of the third, fifth, and seventh commandments, as well as for that of the fourth. See Lev. 20:6, 9, 10. Concerning the prohibition to kindle a fire on the Sabbath, it is evident that the people were at the time traveling in an open, hot desert, and therefore had no need of a fire for warmth nor for cooking food; for there was not a feeble person in all their tribes. See Ps. 105:37. It is just as great a sin to transgress the law of God now as it was in the days of Moses; but the execution of the penalty is deferred till the day of Judgment, when every unforgiven transgressor will suffer the pains of the second death.
(To be continued.)