AdventAI

LETTER AND SPIRIT.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 2., January 12, 1886

Paul, in 2 Cor. 3:6, says: “Who also hath made us able ministers of the new testament; not of the letter, but of the spirit; for the letter killeth, but the spirit giveth life.” The view which some maintain, that by the letter Paul means the old covenant, and by the spirit, the new covenant, can hardly be harmonized with this language; for in that case we should have this declaration: “Who also hath made us able ministers of the new testament, not of the old testament, but of the new testament,” which would certainly be unnecessary tautology. And the remainder of the sentence would then read: “For the old testament killeth, but the new testament giveth life,” which would be untrue, inasmuch as the old testament as well as the new had provision for giving life. Is not the following a much better paraphrase? Who also hath made us able ministers of the new testament, not of the letter of the new testament, but of the spirit of the new testament; for the letter of the new testament killeth, but the spirit of the new testament giveth life.

This phraseology would suggest that there is a letter to the new testament as well as to the old, and that there was a spirit to the old as well as to the new. We can draw from the language, “The letter killeth, but the spirit giveth life,” only this conclusion: that the former refers to that arrangement connected with both covenants which, under certain conditions, would and will cause the death of the transgressor; and the latter, to that provision under both covenants, by which a person could and can secure everlasting life.

Under the old covenant it was given to man to carry out in a measure the provisions of condemnation, or the infliction of death upon the transgressor. For this reason, that system is called in the next verse “the ministration of death.” Under the new covenant, infliction of death upon the transgressor is not committed to the hands of men, not even the penalty of temporal death, which, as inflicted under the former dispensation, was simply a foreshadowing of the second death to be inflicted by the Lord upon the sinner. The infliction of punishment in any manner for sin, as connected with his worship, the Lord now reserves to himself; but this will, nevertheless, in due time be visited upon the unregenerate; and in this the letter of the new testament will be fulfilled.

Paul was a minister, and those who, with him, are called to preach the word, are ministers of the spirit, or of that which giveth life; namely, the provisions for pardon and acceptance with God through the gospel of Christ. See 1 Cor. 3:5; Gal. 3:5. They are ministers of the spirit of the new testament by presenting before men the gracious provisions of the gospel, and persuading them to accept of the Lord and of his promises upon the conditions made known. Thus had the spirit of the new testament been ministered to the Corinthians (2 Cor. 3:3), and through the ministry of Paul, the Spirit of the living God had written the principles of his immutable law upon the fleshy tables of their hearts, and thus they became the “epistle of Christ,” known and read of all men. But it was not committed to the apostles, nor is it to any ministers in this dispensation, to minister the letter of the new testament, or to inflict upon any, in any manner, punishment for sin.

In Rom. 7:6 Paul says of those who have been converted, that they should “serve in newness of spirit, and not in the oldness of the letter;” that is, they were to serve Christ in their new relation as converted persons, led by his Spirit, and pressing forward to the end, which in that case would be everlasting life. By “the oldness of the letter” he evidently means the bondage of sin in which they were held while the old man of sin was living in them; for so long as the carnal nature remained uncrucified, they were the servants of sin (Rom. 6:6), the end of which was to be death. Verse 21. This seems to be clearly what Paul means by serving “in newness of spirit, and not in the oldness of the letter.”

In view of these facts, they make a great mistake who suppose that Paul, in Rom. 7, by the oldness of the letter, refers to the efforts of Christians or converted persons to keep the law of God. That is not his subject. It is the contrast between those who have been converted, and those who are still under the bondage of sin; the one class were serving Christ in newness of spirit, going forward to eternal life; the other were serving sin, in the oldness of the letter or under the sentence of condemnation, and going forward to the second death.