BY W. M. HERD.
FIRST SPEAKER.—I was strongly impressed under the remarks you made the other night, brother, in arguing against the old law of ten commandments. You spoke of the law of Christ as being the one which Christians should keep. Do you, then, think that Christ would make a law that would conflict with his Father's law, or be different in any respect? I do not so read the evangelists' account of his life and teachings. But if there is another law, or “law of Christ,” distinct from the law which was spoken with the voice of God and written with his finger, will you please direct me to it? For I am anxious to know what new obligations I am under in order to serve God acceptably.
Second Speaker.—Oh, there are no new obligations; on the contrary, we are released from one of the hardest obligations in the old law; that is, keeping the seventh-day Sabbath. In fact, in this dispensation we are not bound to keep any Sabbath; for that is abolished, with all those ordinances that were against us. However, in memory of the resurrection, we do keep Sunday as a day on which we can rest from our labor if we choose, and meet with others to worship God.
F. S.—I am astounded at your statement! Do you mean to say that Christ made a new law without any new obligations? Then why not let the old one stand? As for the Sabbath's being against us, we have the testimony of Jesus himself that it “was made for man;” then how could it be against us? All who have given their careful and candid attention to the subject, say that man needs just such a day of rest to recuperate his strength and faculties after six days' strain upon them. Do you think for a moment that God, who “knoweth the end from the beginning,” ever intended man to be without a Sabbath, or day of rest? Is it not reasonable that He who made man, should know man's requirements better than any other being? Why! look back at the record of creation; when man was first made, God at once gave him the Sabbath. God himself rested from his labor on the seventh day, and then he blessed and sanctified it, because he had rested in it, thus “setting it apart to a holy use.” So we have both the example and precept of our heavenly Father for observing the seventh-day Sabbath. The sanctifying could only be done by giving to Adam a precept for the proper observance of it both by himself and his descendants, by which they would receive benefit both physically and spiritually; besides which they would each week have their memory quickened as to the fact that God made the world in six days, and rested the seventh, pointing out the true God. This was a day on which man was to cease from his own work, and draw near to God and worship him.
Sunday-observers claim great antiquity for the “day of the sun,” and we are disposed to give them all they claim; as it is quite certain that the first object of idolatry was the sun, and Abraham's fathers were idolaters. Those who worshiped the sun and sun-gods, as Baal and others, set apart the first day of the week for that purpose, as distinct from the people of God, who remembered his precepts and obeyed them, as we read of Abraham. Gen. 26: 5.
What is there in the fourth commandment which is against us? Doesn't man need rest, and his servants, and his cattle, etc.? and as a loving father, who knows what is for our welfare, is it not perfectly reasonable for God to require it? You have children, and you know how it was when they were young; that for their health you had to require that they do certain things which they did not always think necessary, and that they abstain from some which were injurious. It should be our delight to obey God in this requirement, (1.) because we need the refreshing season of rest; and (2.) because we then have a better opportunity to study God's handiwork around us, and remember with gratitude the great Creator who makes such abundant provision for us. This we could not do if occupied with our worldly affairs. Would it not be inconsistent for God to give this Sabbath to man, and then take it from him when he needs it just as much as ever? But the psalmist says, “Thy memorial, O Lord, endureth throughout all generations.”
However, I am curious to see this new law which you call the “law of Christ.” He said that he had kept his Father's commandments, and I should suppose the same commandments were good enough for us. But when and where was the new law given?
S. S.—Well, I must confess you have put the matter in a somewhat different light from that in which I have viewed it before. But the new law I spoke of can be found in various parts of the New Testament, which I will refer to.
F. S.—Well, but wasn't it all given at once? Jesus had many opportunities to give his law, in the synagogues, and with his disciples in private, and when instructing the multitudes; he could readily have given a new law, if necessary, in his sermon on the mount. But his words then are evidence that his Father's law should not be changed in the slightest particular till the words of the prophets are all fulfilled, which carries us over into the eternal state; or in his own words, “till heaven and earth pass.”
S. S.—But then, you see, the old law of ten commandments was in force until the death of Christ. Now for the texts in which we find the new law: The first commandment is given in Luke 4: 8; the second in Acts 17: 22–25; the third in James 3: 12; the fourth, as I said, is not in the new law; the fifth is found in Eph. 6: 2, 3; and the last five, in Rom. 13: 1–9.
F. S.—Well, here is a dilemma, surely. A poor wayfaring man comes along, thankful that he can read, feeling that he is sinful, and desiring to know how to serve God acceptably, and to depart from sin, which, he is told, is the “transgression of the law.” He is pointed to Christ to obtain mercy and pardon for his past offenses; he believes the word, which says that if we confess our sins, God “is faithful and just to forgive us our sins, and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness.” But where is that law which he has broken, but now desires to obey? We will suppose that the man comes to you, my brother, to learn his duty. You tell him the Old Testament is for Jews only; so the law must be sought in the New Testament. But should he happen to read Paul's statement in Heb. 8: 8, he would be in a quandary; as the new covenant, or testament, was made with the houses of Israel and Judah; and you tell him that anything Jewish is not for him. Again, “salvation is of the Jews;” must he lose that also? The apostles were Jews; and of the flesh, even Christ came from the tribe of Judah. Thus the poor man becomes very much confused. But he soon gains comfort from reading Paul's words in 2 Tim. 3: 16, 17; Rom. 2: 29, and kindred passages. He is led to examine the ten commandments, as they are and have been taught quite generally in the day-schools and Sabbath-schools of the land. But you tell him that those were abolished at the death of Christ, and a new law was given.
Let us look at that new law. When was it given, and to whom? Let us begin with the first precept, found, you say, in Luke 4: 8: “It is written, Thou shalt worship the Lord thy God, and him only shalt thou serve.” Now then, for whose benefit did Christ give his first commandment there in the wilderness? No one was within hearing but Satan; was he the messenger to whose hands such a command was intrusted for the Christian Church? That would seem impossible, after he had just been employing all his cunning and power to try to get Jesus to worship him! Ah! you think there is some mistake? So you want to alter your text? Very well; go on.
S. S.—Yes, it would never do to have the law of Christ given through such a source. But in Luke 10: 27, is comprehended the whole law of Christ. I wonder I had not thought of it sooner.
F. S.—It is wonderful, my brother, how the memory is sharpened when we get into an uncomfortable corner. Possibly you will have to exercise yours again before we get through. But how does our friend fare now? “Love the Lord?” says he, “so I do, with all the affection I am capable of; and I feel like loving all the world since I know that the Lord has pardoned me. But how am I to show my love to the Lord?” Why, you answer, by obeying his commandments; and his commandments are not grievous. Says the poor fellow, “That is what I am looking for; but where are they?” Finding no satisfaction from the information you give him, he turns to his reference Bible, and finds a parallel passage in Matt. 22: 37–40, and reads: “On these two commandments hang all the law and the prophets.” “Ah!” says he, with a sigh of relief, “it is evident that Jesus is speaking of the Old Testament when he mentions the prophets; and I, for one, will go back there for my law, or rule of life. God spoke the ten commandments in the hearing of all Israel; and Paul says that ‘if ye be Christ's, then are ye Abraham's seed, and heirs according to the promise.’ We are the Israel of God, the second house of Israel; and I know that God wouldn't go to work in a roundabout way to teach me my duty. He would be straightforward; for I remember he says in one place that the wayfaring man, though a fool, shall not err in the way of holiness. I may be a fool, but I like a straight path.” But, say you, hold hard, my friend; do you know where you are taking yourself? If you intend to keep the ten commandments, you will find it hard work; for you will have to keep the seventh-day Sabbath, my friend; for that is the only one authorized by the fourth commandment. “Is that so? then may God help me; for I am fully determined to let nothing turn my steps aside from the narrow road that leads to eternal life; and by the grace of God I will obey him, fourth commandment and all.”
So our wayfaring man is not such a fool as we took him to be, after all, brother. The wisdom of this world is often put to shame by the simple, childlike faith just noticed. But now about your new law. If these two principles enumerated by the Saviour are the whole law of Christ, then we have two codes of laws operating at the same time and place, one of which you would call a “yoke of bondage,” and the other the “law of Christ.” But the Saviour showed it was not a new law he gave. Remember the circumstances. The Sadducees had been silenced, and the Pharisees were gathered around our Lord, when a lawyer asked a question to tempt him, hoping to entangle him; but he was grievously disappointed. Now, do you, as a professed follower of Christ, think that our Lord intended his new and higher law for the benefit of the unbelieving Pharisees? Should it not have been given to his own followers? But what law did the Pharisaical lawyer refer to? It must have been previously in existence, to judge from the tenor of the question; and the conclusion of our Lord's reply shows that it was. “On these two commandments,” says he, “hang all the law and the prophets.” What two?—Why, love to God and love to our neighbor; and our neighbor, as shown by the parable, is any one of our fellow-men who stands in need of our love. But is it not a fact that love to God will cause us to do our duty, as shown in the first four of the ten commandments? And should not love to our neighbor lead us to do our duty, as expressed in the last six precepts of the decalogue?
S. S.—You have made a strong case, certainly; yet I think that somewhere or other I have read that there is no such thing as love or mercy in the ten commandments.
F. S.—This is not the first time I have heard that argument, if it can be called an argument. Now you know the words of the decalogue by rote, if I am not mistaken; listen while I repeat part of the second commandment. “Visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children . . . of them that hate me, and showing mercy unto thousands of them that love me and keep my commandments.” There are both love and mercy; and God himself, in such a loud voice as to shake the mount, said that those who love him, keep his commandments.
S. S.—I cannot get around you, brother; you must have the truth on your side, or your arguments could not be so strong; but there are some points which need explanation, and perhaps you can help me.
F. S.—My heart is rejoiced to think that you are indeed in earnest in seeking for truth. You know Jesus said, “Thy word is truth,” and the belovedp. 35 apostle tells us to “walk in the light;” while the wise man says, “The path of the just is as the shining light, that shineth more and more unto the perfect day.” I will be glad to render you any aid in my power to explain any doubtful passages.
S. S.—I was thinking of Gal. 5: 1 and Col. 2: 14; to what law do they refer? and also Eph. 2: 15?
F. S.—Now, to show they do not refer to the decalogue, or moral law, let us examine side by side these passages with others in the New Testament:—
Mark 2: 27, “Made for man.” | Col. 2: 14, “Contrary to us.” Rom. 3: 31, “Established.” | Eph. 2: 15, “Abolished.” Jas. 2: 12, “Law of liberty.” | Gal. 5: 1, “Yoke of bondage.”
You will see that I have taken texts that are just opposite to each other. I did this to show that it was impossible for the same law to be referred to in every case; and that it was doubtless an error in comparing these which led you to think of a new law, or “law of Christ.” But we have all broken the law, and stand in need of a mediator. If Christ is the law-giver, who is our advocate with him? Is it, as the Catholics say, the Virgin Mary? Neither you nor I can believe that. But the context in each case will decide. We cannot stay to examine this now, however; but will leave that for your leisure moments. You will find that those in the first list refer to the decalogue; those in the second, the texts you named, to the ceremonial, or typical law, called a law of types and shadows, “carnal ordinances,” etc. As it pointed forward to Christ, it would naturally pass away at his death, the antitypical offering.
S. S.—I will certainly look this up more thoroughly. But the thought comes to me forcibly, why was not the Sabbath commandment repeated in the New Testament?
F. S.—That same query has troubled not a few; and yet sometimes I think that a great many have been glad it was not repeated. It furnished them with an excuse, of which they were sadly in need, for not keeping the Sabbath. But right here I would say, that this is the excuse the Roman Catholics make for not keeping the letter of the second commandment. You know it is not repeated word for word; and in tones of triumph they say to Protestants who observe Sunday instead of Saturday, “Where is the command in the New Testament against our custom?”
Now, while the fourth commandment is not repeated verbatim in the New Testament, neither are the others, except the short ones. But it is several times referred to. We find Jesus recognizing the law of the Sabbath when he says, “It is lawful to do well on the Sabbath days.” And Luke, the evangelist, in recording the circumstances connected with the burial and resurrection of Jesus, says that the women “kept the Sabbath according to the commandment.” The custom of the apostles is also clearly shown to be that of keeping the Sabbath, even after Christ rose again. In fact, the terms of the new covenant, or testament, show that it was the same law on which both covenants were based, only the Lord says he will now write it in their hearts. Heb. 8: 10; Jer. 31: 33.
Paul tells us in Heb. 9: 16, 17 that the testator must die before the testament can be of force. In Gal. 3: 15, he shows that nothing can be added to nor taken from the testament after the death of the testator, which confirms the testament. Now it is not claimed by any that the law was abolished until the death of Christ; but we find that that very event certainly established the moral law; or, as Paul says, “we establish the law” by faith.
Again, the first day is supposed by some to have been inserted in the fourth commandment in place of the seventh; but when was it done? They would say, “Three days after his death.” But that is just too late! for it was his death which confirmed the covenant,—the law which contained the seventh-day Sabbath of the Lord and all; and by parity of reasoning with Paul, we find it could not be changed afterward, nor is there any testimony anywhere to prove the change which is claimed by Sunday-keepers.
S. S.—Well, I have had a very profitable conversation with you, and see things in quite a new light. I now see that the law of God, or “royal law,” as James calls it, enjoins the observance of the seventh day, and by God's grace, I will keep it.