AdventAI

A SKEPTIC'S QUERY ANSWERED.

By J. O. Beard

From Review and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 10., March 9, 1886

BY J. O. BEARD.

“How do you harmonize the discrepancy in the accounts of the birth of Christ?” was the question asked me by a skeptic a short time ago. What discrepancy? I asked, not knowing what he meant. “Why, in the dates of the birth of Christ as given by Matthew and Luke, the only two accounts of his birth given in the Bible; and you claim that they are both inspired; if so, they should agree on such an important question.” I candidly confessed that I was not aware of any discrepancy, when he explained as follows:—

“Matthew says that Jesus was born while Herod was king of Judea (chap. 2:1); and Luke says he was born while Cyrenius was governor of Syria (chap. 2:1-7); but Josephus says that Archelaus, Herod’s son, ruled Judea for about nine years after the death of his father, when he was banished; and that Cyrenius was made governor of Syria after the banishment of Archelaus. That would make at least nine years difference in the two dates of his birth.”

I had no answer ready, but promised to look up the facts concerning the case. I have recently given him the following answer:—

Judea was not a part of the Roman province called Syria, until the banishment of Archelaus (see “Smith’s Bible Dict.,” Art. Judea); but was a separate province. It was ruled by Herod, called the Great, first as a procurator from B. C. 47 to 41; then after an absence of about a year, a usurper having driven him out, the Roman Senate reappointed him, bestowing on him the title of king. This office and title he retained until his death, which occurred soon after the birth of Christ. His son Archelaus succeeded him as governor of the province of Judea, but never received the title of king. About nine years later, complaints were made against him, not only by his subjects, but also by his brothers, who were governors of adjoining provinces, and he was banished. See “Smith’s Bible Dict.,” Arts. Herod and Archelaus.

Judea was then annexed to the province of Syria, and was governed by a procurator who was subject to the governor (proconsul) of Syria. Cyrenius (his full Roman name was Publius Sulpicius Quirinus) was governor (proconsul) of Syria at two different times: first from B. C. 4 to B. C. 1; and the second time from A. D. 6 to 11. See “Smith’s Bible Dict.,” Art. Cyrenius; “Library of Universal Knowledge,” “Chamber’s Encyclopedia,” “Johnson’s Encyclopedia.” The last author refers to Zumpt, “De Syria Romanorum Provinciam.”

It was during Cyrenius’ first term of office that the enrollment and taxation were made to which Luke refers. Luke 2:1, 2. But it is unquestionably the second term which Josephus mentions. What reason Josephus had for mentioning the second term, and omitting a notice of the first, we do not know. It may have been because of the banishment of Archelaus, and the annexation of Judea to the province of Syria. But whether that was the reason or not, other historians agree that Cyrenius held the office twice at the above given dates, which, I think, is sufficient to explain the whole difficulty.