AdventAI

WHICH DEVELOPS ATHEISM?

From Review and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 10., March 9, 1886

The current issue of the Fortnightly Review contains an article by a Catholic priest, Rev. W. Barry, whose object is to persuade Protestants that they have no alternative except to become atheists or papists. The writer says: “If what they [Protestants] value most is the revelation of Christianity, they will be compelled, perhaps in no long time, to seek it where alone it exists inviolate, consistent in all its parts, and a living power. Such it is within the precincts of the Church of Rome.” The reason of this assertion—for which he gives no particle of proof—he finds in another assertion of his own, that private judgment, or free thought, inevitably leads to atheism; and as the Church of Rome has always been hostile to private judgment, or, in his own words, “strong enough to resist free thought,” therefore whoever does not want to become an atheist must become a Romanist.

He seems to be perfectly furious against the exercise of reason. “It is free thought,” he says, “which has made the Gospels a legend, and the subject of them myth. But, finally, there comes to light the reason of all this fury. “Private judgment,” he says, “is fatal to the notion of a society like the Catholic Church, with its objective and infallible creed.” Of course it is; and this, not only because it judges that Church by its works, by its history, and by the spiritual condition of the nations who have been the longest subjected to it, and sees that these are evil; not only because it judges the claim to infallibility, and sees that it is ridiculous; not only because it judges the central doctrine of transubstantiation, and sees that it is simply nonsense; but, beyond all that, because it inquires into the origin and foundation of the Catholic Church, and finds that it is utterly destitute of authority—that Christ never founded it, nor authorized it, and, in fact, never said a word about it. That is why private judgment is, as the priest says, “fatal to the notion of a society like the Catholic Church.” That is why the Catholic Church has always tried to put down private judgment whenever it had the power. That is why the pope, when he ruled at Rome, would not suffer Bibles to be distributed there. That is why Catholic priests and bishops seek to destroy public schools, and with curses drive children into their own schools, in order to prevent them from exercising or learning to exercise private judgment. And this is not all: private judgment goes to the New Testament, which is the only source of information which we have upon the matter, and sees, not only that Christ did not establish the Romish Church, but that his life and words and character are such that he could not by any possibility have established or approved it, or failed to abhor it. And just so far as private judgment brings a man into fellowship with the true Christ, as the New Testament presents Him, so far it makes him abhor the falsehood which the priests of the Romish Church put forth in His name.

Private judgment sees also, as a matter of fact, that atheism springs up more frequently “in the precincts of the Catholic Church” than anywhere else, and for this very simple reason, that when men are forced by common sense to reject the ideas about God and his ways of action which are taught them by the priests, being sure that God can be no such being as that, they not unnaturally cease to believe in him at all. It is not Protestantism, with its free inquiry into the works and ways of God,—with its free encouragement to every man to learn all that he can of the works and word of God, and not to be afraid of seeking and finding the truth,—it is not this which makes atheists. To say so would be to make God a god of falsehood. Catholicism sets up a multitude of objectsp. 151 of worship. Protestantism, with all its varieties, has this one essential unity—more important than all the others—that it holds fast to the great command which Christ quoted from the Old Testament: “Thou shalt worship the Lord thy God, and him only shalt thou serve.”—Christian at Work.