AdventAI

A BOILING QUESTION.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 10., March 9, 1886

We have “weighty” questions, and “momentous” questions, and “burning” questions; but the most appropriate term, seemingly, that can be applied to the Sunday-Sabbath question just now, is, a “boiling” question; for the whole country is fast coming into a state of ebullition on this subject. We cannot anywhere now go amiss of the agitation touching it; and anything said on it at any time, is almost sure to find many who are interested in the matter.

This we are glad to see; for it can but result in advantage to the truth. Error only loses, truth always shines the brighter, by agitation. And this is especially true on the question before us; for when any candid person beholds the supreme indifference with which the Sunday advocates contradict each other, and the attenuated ridiculousness of the positions they take, he can want no better evidence that truth has not taken its stand with them, but abides on the side of the Sabbath.

We published in the REVIEW, two weeks ago, an extract from an article in the Christian at Work, in which the writer admitted that no obligation was laid upon us by either Christ or his apostles for the keeping of the first day of the week as the Sabbath, but that we must look to “later than apostolic times” for the introduction of that observance. This is utterly fatal to the institution from the stand-point of the whole Protestant world, that the Bible and the Bible alone is the rule of faith and practice. But that difficulty he disposed of very summarily by asserting that that fact did not weaken its obligation at all, but gave it all the more force and beauty! Can men be honest in such assertions? On the same ground we suppose that the doctrine of purgatory, invocation of saints, image worship, sprinkling for baptism, etc., etc., which originated in later than apostolic times, are all the more forcible and beautiful on that account!

And now another writer in the Christian at Work of Feb. 11, 1886, Henry J. Van Dyke, Jr., D. D., makes some more good admissions on the Sunday question. After stating the common arguments for the change of the Sabbath from the seventh to the first day of the week, he says:—

“This argument may be good for those who can honestly use it. But for one who is not convinced that it is supported by the facts, for one who after patient study of the New Testament fails to find any sufficient evidence of the alleged historic connection, this method of reasoning is a source of weakness rather than of strength. A poor defense injures a good cause. An historical argument is worse than worthless if it be not exact. The question is not what the apostles ought to have done, according to our judgment, or what they might have done, had they known all that we know; but the simple question is, What did they actually do? We do not find in the New Testament a single trace of their alleged transference of Sabbatic obligations from the seventh to the first day of the week. . . . We see the disciples assembling for worship on the first day of the week, but we see them also listening to Paul daily in the school of Tyrannus (Acts 19:9), and there is no clear evidence that Sunday was observed as a day of sacred rest and abstinence from secular employment until the time of Constantine, when it was established by imperial law and joyfully accepted by the Church as her holy day. A chain is no stronger than its slenderest link. An argument is no stronger than its weakest point. Is it wise to suspend the authority of our Christian Sabbath by a chain which threatens to snap in the middle?”

Here we are brought down to the time of Constantine, 321 A. D., as the first point where there is any evidence that Sunday was observed as a day of sacred rest and abstinence from secular employment, and then it was established by the edict of the emperor. This is quite a ways from the time of the apostles, and a time when, if we may credit Church history, every baleful corruption and superstition which has cursed the religion of Christ was in process of luxuriant growth. Mr. Van Dyke is correct in his statement that here was the birth of Sunday obligation; but to round out his admission to its full proportions, he should have said that the edict of the emperor was issued before his so-called conversion to Christianity, and was in behalf of Sunday as a pagan festival, and that it had nothing to do with the Christian Church till it was manipulated into that position by Pope Sylvester.

Then Mr. V., like some others, although he vehemently urges the necessity of maintaining the Christian Sunday, places it on a basis which allows every man to observe it about as he pleases. Speaking of the obligations of law on the subject, he says:—

“How swiftly and how majestically did Christ sweep away all the pious sophistry of this legal logic! He appealed from the letter to the spirit. He declared that the law was not an end, but a means. It is not intended to crush men into conformity to a set pattern, but to lift them up into holiness and happiness. Higher than the law is the end for which it was given,—the glory of God manifested in the welfare of man. All things must bend to this—Sabbath and sacrifice, times and seasons, purification and ritual; all the rules which God has given, through Moses or other messengers of his will, must be read in this light of humanity and love. For the Sabbath was made for man, and not man for the Sabbath.”

Talking thus loosely about the divine law, he cannot of course plead very strongly for human law; and on this point he makes the following judicious observation:—

“We do not need, and we ought not to demand, the enactment of more stringent and particular laws by the State, or the enforcement of more rigid and personal discipline by the Church. That is the road on which the Pharisees traveled. It is narrow gauge, single track, and leads nowhere.”

True in one sense; that is, it leads “nowhere” into any realm of truth and righteousness. But in the other direction, it does lead to persecution for its victims and perdition for its authors.

Let the “Christian” keep on “at work” on this question, and it will perhaps give us at last as thorough a demolition of Sunday as any one could require.

There has lately come into our hands, Tract No. 118, on “The First-day Sabbath,” issued by the “Presbyterian Board of Publication,” No. 1334 Chestnut street, Philadelphia. The writer acknowledges that there is no command in the New Testament for Sunday observance, and says that this “does appear at first sight like a want of something decisive on this matter of the change.” It not only appears so at first sight, but it appears more and more so at every subsequent sight. The idea of enforcing anything as an observance in the Christian Church for which neither Christ nor his apostles ever gave any injunction or instruction, is utterly preposterous. Yet this writer has an invention to get over this difficulty, like the other who thought, or rather asserted, that an institution was all the better because it originated this side the days of the apostles. So this writer on the point before us says:—

“I observe, that if our Lord and his apostles possessed any other means for accomplishing this change, we should naturally expect them to employ that means, in preference to a direct and overruling commandment.”

We italicise the astounding portion of this quotation. In the name of reason, we can but ask what people mean by writing such stuff as that, and what dignified publishing boards mean by printing it. Do they think that anybody except such as Dr. Clarke calls “the basely interested,” will fail to discern that it is merely a desperate makeshift, a piece of sham sophistry, to try to shield themselves in a practice for which they have no divine authority? This statement is simply to prepare the way for an argument on the gradual and circumstantial change of the Sabbath, without any commandment. He says: “He [Christ] never attempted to explode, but always to undermine their prejudices.” If this writer had been one of the Pharisees in the days of Christ, we imagine he would have thought there were some pretty violent explosions when Christ called them a generation of vipers, children of their father the Devil, and denounced woes upon them for making void the commandments of God by their traditions. So violently did he explode their prejudices that they sought to rid themselves of him by nailing him to the cross. No milk-and-water teacher ever brought upon himself such a fate.

No! when God had duties for men to perform he made them known by “direct and overruling commandments.” And when Christ had duties for his people to perform he told them so in direct terms. Where are the men who will cry “shame!” in the ears of these sophists till they desist from their foolish reasoning, or till the people are aroused to the nature of their work?

All that is said of the Sabbath as the safeguard of religion, the bulwark of morality, the salvation of society, the great link to bind man to his Maker, is more than true; but it must be the true Sabbath, and not a counterfeit. Against all these devices, inventions and makeshifts of men, we set the word of the Lord. Our stand and our motto on the Sabbath question is, and shall be, “The word of the Lord, the word of the Lord, forever.”