S. D. ADVENTISTS AND THEIR RELATION TO TEMPERANCE ORGANIZATIONS

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Feb 2, 1886

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 5.

Read the full edition

S. D. ADVENTISTS AND THEIR RELATION TO TEMPERANCE ORGANIZATIONS.

Several correspondents have earnestly requested information as to whether it would be proper for our people to unite and co-operate with the Woman’s Christian Temperance Union, join a prohibition club, or attend such temperance meetings when held on the Sabbath.
There are connected with these queries some practical questions of real difficulty, which require careful consideration. The temperance work is a most excellent one, and we honor those who labor for it unselfishly. The W. C. T. U. is an organization which has done, and is doing, a vast amount of good. The women who are laboring in it are among the purest and noblest in the land; of this we have no question. The prohibition party, we believe, take the only consistent position on the question of licensing the sale of intoxicating drinks, and we wish them abundant success in driving out the saloons and putting down the abominable liquor traffic,—one of the greatest curses that afflicts our country to-day. Then should not our people all heartily unite with them, and join these organizations at once? We answer that an affirmative reply is not a necessary conclusion. There may be other considerations which should decide us to do otherwise.
Our religious belief and the standpoint from which we view the future are so different from the views of the mass of those who support these organizations, that we are logically led to different methods of action. We are believers in the soon coming of Jesus and the closing up of all earthly scenes. They expect long ages of probation in this world of sin, and look for the removal of wickedness by means of human laws and agencies. We have no hope that the world will grow better, or that drinking and lawlessness will be stopped until Christ shall come. They hope, by agitation and legal and Christian effort, to bring about the good time coming. We have special truths committed to our hands, with which the world must be warned; and some of these have been trampled in the dust for ages. We hope to gather out honest souls who will receive these truths, and thus be saved from the terrible doom which awaits a wicked world and a proud apostate church. We have far more than we can do to properly bring these truths before our fellow-men.
Our temperance friends have no such purposes, and most of them have no sympathy whatever with what is dearest to us. They think our notions fanatical, and our principal work all wrong, something which ought to be discountenanced. How can there be hearty union between those who look at things so differently, and have such different objects in view?
In saying this, we do not throw aside one jot of our interest for temperance, or our hatred for the saloon. But we do insist that we should properly keep in view the leading issue to which we have devoted our lives—the saving of our fellow-men from the impending ruin which awaits a sleeping world. We wish the temperance work well, and believe that at proper times we should give it a suitable share of our attention. We should live lives of temperance, speak for temperance, and, when we vote, vote for temperance. But we should never forget our leading work as S. D. Adventists,—to make known the truths of the last message.
We can and should wish prosperity to these temperance organizations as long as they do not join with their work issues inconsistent with the leading objects of our mission. Until they take such a position, we can heartily wish them Godspeed, though we may not deem it consistent to make our own work secondary and fully throw ourselves and our energies into the plans they are carrying forward.
In the preceding remarks, we have spoken of what we have long since considered a proper attitude for S. D. Adventists to take toward various temperance organizations, until comparatively a recent date. We seem now to be reaching a new phase of the subject, which demands a careful consideration.
An alliance seems to be forming between what is called the “National Reform Party,” and the Woman’s Christian Temperance Union, and prohibition parties. It is well known that the former has for its leading objects, the remodeling of our national Constitution, to give it a more religious cast, so that Congress can legislate on religious questions, and the upholding of the venerable pagan, Catholic Sunday as the “Christian Sabbath.” We have long been looking for such a movement, and now see it rapidly taking shape. These temperance organizations are seemingly becoming the warmest supporters of the National Reform movement. The National Reform party have elected quite a number of the leading officers of the W. C. T. U. as vice-presidents. There is a constant interchange of courtesies going on, and the W. C. T. U. have already in their conventions taken the Sunday-Sabbath under their protecting ægis as a leading object of care and interest. There seems to be perfect harmony and union in the objects of the two organizations. The Christian Statesman, the organ of the National Reform party, manifests the greatest gratification at these results. We make no complaint on this score. We simply see in them the fulfillment of the predictions of God’s word.
The same is true, in a measure, of the Prohibition party. In the Ohio campaign of last fall, the union of the National Reform party and the Prohibition party was most conspicuous. Mr. Leonard, a prominent Methodist minister of the State, was chosen as their candidate for governor, and the campaign was a hot one. There was a large increase in the prohibition vote. The movement was strongly aided by the forces of the National Reform party. They seemed to be in perfect sympathy. The W. C. T. U. of course worked hard for the same objects.
It now looks as if the nucleus was already formed, or forming, for the new “party of moral ideas” which is to make the Sunday issue prominent. Everything looks favorable for the formation of such a party. The two great rival organizations of Republicanism and Democracy are not satisfactory to a large number of the most religious and conscientious of the American people. The main issue between them is the spoils. Both use every possible means, good, bad, and indifferent, with which to achieve success. If the liquor interest can help them through, they pander to it and buy it in. They are very moral when it seems to pay to take that side. But, alas! they are not so when it seems to pay to be otherwise. Many of the conscientious voters see these things and are disgusted. Over thirty thousand last fall voted the prohibition ticket in Ohio. The Republicans probably lost the election in New York because of the falling off of so many of this class of temperance voters. We cannot tell what shape things will assume in the near future, but they cannot long stand as they are at present.
If this alliance between the National Reform party and these temperance organizations continues, we cannot see how S. D. Adventists can continue to be identified with them. Their objects and ours will not only then be dissimilar in some particulars, but radically opposite. Then, “how can two walk together unless they be agreed?” We cannot support the Sabbath of the Lord, which God’s commandment requires, and the heathen Sunday of Catholic tradition at the same time. Here must be an irreconcilable conflict.
But the fact of such an alliance should not make us less interested in temperance. That is a noble cause. We are a temperance people, and hold no fellowship whatever with intemperance in any form. We should talk and act in favor of temperance on all occasions. And whenever the issue is brought before us in such a manner as not to involve us in support of things we cannot consistently uphold, we may vote for temperance. We do not see how we can go farther than this.
Meantime, we should not forget that the vast body of these temperance workers do not realize the nature of the struggle upon which they are entering. They do not understand the character of the Sunday institution, nor do they realize that it is the child of apostasy. They are perfectly honest in their convictions. This should make us charitable to them as individuals, and above all should lead us to make every effort possible to enlighten them upon these subjects of such transcendent importance. Let us send them the light of present truth by every means in our power.
We would not advise our people to attend ordinary temperance meetings on the Sabbath. Usually there is fun, and other features inconsistent with Sabbath sacredness, connected with such meetings. Most of those present have no feelings of Sabbath restraint upon them, and we could not keep the Sabbath there. We do not mean by this that the temperance question, when properly presented, is inconsistent with Sabbath sacredness; but the practices of temperance advocates often are.
And, finally, dear brethren and sisters, let us all devote ourselves to the great and important work God has given us, that he may guide us by his unerring counsel.
G. I. B.