AdventAI

SUNDRY QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS.

By George I. Butler

From Review and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 5., February 2, 1886

CORRESPONDENTS inquire if it is right for a colporter or any person but a minister, to dismiss the meeting with the benediction.

Answer.—Webster defines the word “benediction” as “specifically the short prayer which closes public worship.” It is really nothing more nor less than a short prayer, asking God’s blessing to rest upon the congregation as they separate, commending them to his special care. Really, in the nature of things, we can see no sin in the asking of the Lord to bless the people as they depart, by any one who is called upon to lead the meeting. Nevertheless, we should regard with some respect the customs of the time established by usage, which are not inconsistent with God’s word. The general custom of Protestant churches since the Reformation, confines this ceremony to the minister. He is the authorized representative of the church. If we recognize this custom, none but ordained ministers should pronounce the benediction. It hardly looks consistent with modesty, in view of this long established custom, for a private person, colporter, or local elder, who may lead a meeting, to pronounce the benediction. We do not know as they commit any sin by doing it, for the Bible says nothing about it; but we could not advise others besides ministers to perform this ceremony. We think they should simply pronounce the meeting closed.

“Has one of our preachers who has been silenced by not receiving a license, the right to administer baptism?”

Ans.—None but ordained ministers of the gospel and ordained church elders have a right to baptize, and the latter only in their own churches, unless by special authority of the Conference. This has been decided by the General Conference. The Scriptures make it plain. A license confers no right to baptize, and of course one who has no license would have no such right any more than would any private person.

“When a church member makes a motion that a brother be disfellowshipped, and this be supported and voted upon, and no reason why he is disfellowshipped given in the motion, will the vote of the church stand? Is it valid?

Ans.—We do not see that the validity of the vote would necessarily depend upon the reason for the action’s being placed in the motion. The object of the motion is to bring out the sentiment of the church in reference to the action taken. It is an expression of their opinion on the question before them. The reason for the same might be in the motion, or it might not. Of course there should always be a good reason for the taking of such action. Also proper labor designed to reclaim the person should be bestowed, if possible, beforehand. A record of the reason given should be preserved in the church book for future reference.

“Can S. D. Adventists partake of the Lord’s supper with other denominations, and still be retained in the church? Or, do Adventists, as a people, practice or hold to open communion?”

Ans.—S. D. Adventists really hold to close communion. To be more specific, they believe it consistent to commune (which they consider a token of fellowship) with only such as live up to the truths which they consider as important,—obeying the law of God and the doctrines of Christ,—and such as place themselves under the obligations imposed by the church of Christ. Such they hold in full fellowship. They come under the requirements of God’s word; others do not fully do this. They would therefore consider it inconsistent to commune with churches or persons who do not place themselves under such obligations. Whether they should disfellowship a member who did differently would depend something on circumstances, or the merits of each particular case. Some may not have had suitable instruction to know that their course was inconsistent. Such should be properly instructed.

“Is it lawful for an elder to gather five members of his congregation together by stealth, without a public announcement of the object of the meeting, and act on the case of an absent member?”

Ans.—No. It would be very wrong to deal with members in such a manner as is above represented. Before dealing with members, there should be patient labor and faithful efforts made to reclaim the erring. Anything like underhanded work is very wrong. The person involved should be notified of the meeting where his case is to be considered, and such should have a fair opportunity to answer to any charges made. Ample time for considering the case should be given. Such things are too important to be treated lightly.

“Is it consistent or right for a Sabbath-keeper who has to labor for a living, to pick hops or work in a hop yard?”

Ans.—We know of no scripture prohibiting it. There may be other employments preferable, but we do not consider it a sin. God made hops to grow. They are useful for some purposes, and we dare not say the picking of them is a sin.

Inquiry is made by a sister, whether or not it would be wrong to let her little girl who helps a neighbor take care of her baby, remain and do this on the Sabbath, if she did nothing else.

Ans.—We should much prefer to have our children at home on the Sabbath. The example around them where work is being done, will naturally lead them to lightly regard the Sabbath. Such children need religious instruction and influences on the Sabbath, to derive the benefit they should from it. Even if the work itself would not violate the Sabbath (which is somewhat debatable), yet the influence is in a wrong direction, and therefore unsafe; and she will not thus receive the religious help she needs.

We are asked about “going to the store to buy groceries after sunset Friday night,” and sending for mail on the Sabbath.

Ans.—Going to the store to trade after sunset Friday night, is just as much breaking the Sabbath as chopping or any other work done on that day. It should not be tolerated in any church of our people. We also regard the practice of going to the post-office for ordinary mail on the Sabbath, as a violation of the commandment.

Inquiry is made whether a partnership between a Sunday-keeper and a Sabbath-keeper, in which they put up one hundred tons of hay, the Sabbath-keeper mowing on Friday and resting on the Sabbath, while the Sunday-keeper stacks on the Sabbath and rests on Sunday, dividing the hay equally, is right.

Ans.—This is a very close question, yet we should judge the Sabbath-keeper reaped some benefit for Sabbath labor. Again, we judge that the influence on the community would be bad, as many would conclude that the Sabbath-keeper was, in a measure, responsible for Sabbath labor. We should much prefer to give them no occasion for such a conclusion. We regard it as important that we avoid even the appearance of evil. Where a course is presented which may be wrong or may be right, we can hardly tell which, we would avoid it lest we might find ourselves doing wrong and committing sin against God. Let us take the safe course, and then we know we are right. G. I. B.