AdventAI

“SUNDAY THE CHRISTIAN SABBATH.”

By A. Smith

From Review and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 12., March 23, 1886

A REVIEW.

(Concluded.)

BY A. SMITH.

Mr. A makes the oft-repeated assertion that “redemption is greater than creation,” and that the first day of the week must be observed to commemorate it. Perhaps redemption is greater than creation, but the Bible does not say so; and even if it is a fact, we are not required to observe any day as a memorial of the event, nor could we do so; for redemption was not limited to the six days immediately preceding that of the resurrection, nor is it yet completed, nor will it be till sin and sinners are no more, and the earth shall have been restored to its Edenic beauty. See Rom. 8: 21–23; Eph. 1: 13, 14. If we are to keep any day as a memorial of redemption, let us keep the day of the crucifixion; for Paul says, “We have redemption through his blood, the forgiveness of sins.” Eph. 1: 7. The Bible shows that the instituted memorial of the burial and resurrection of our Lord is baptism. See Rom. 6: 4, 5. What need, therefore, of mutilating God’s unchangeable memorial of creation without any license of Scripture or proper adaptation of circumstances?

Mr. A further claims that to be consistent, those who keep the Jewish Sabbath must also keep the entire round of [ceremonial] sabbaths kept by that people. But, fortunately, all those ceremonial sabbaths passed away with the ceremonial law, and we have nothing to do with the observation of them. Mr. A says that “the Christian who turns back to the Jewish Sabbath-day, turns to a ‘weak and beggarly element;’” and points with satisfaction to the more liberal spirit of modern Jews in renouncing it and coming over to the observance of the first day of the week. But this only strengthens us in our position that the time is very near when “all that dwell upon the earth shall worship him [the papacy, whose mark the first-day Sabbath is], whose names are not written in the book of life.”

Mr. A wants to know what they will do who go up into the polar regions where alternate day and night each continue for months in succession. Well, if any contemplate moving to the poles of the earth, we would gladly furnish them with specific instructions whereby they can keep the Sabbath if they want to. If Sunday can be kept there, the Sabbath of the Lord can be kept. God knew all about that when he made the Sabbath for man as an inhabitant of a round world.

Mr. A speaks of the two covenants, but he makes no argument upon them worthy of notice, though he makes the mistake of saying that it consisted of “circumcision, Sabbath days, etc.” See the terms of the first covenant in Ex. 19: 3–8; 24: 3–8. Circumcision had been given as a covenant to Abraham four hundred years before. See Gen. 17: 10. The new covenant was made, not with the Gentiles, but with the “house of Israel.” Heb. 8: 8–11. Every one, therefore, who partakes of its benefits, must become an Israelite; and such are all true Christians, of whatever tongue or nationality. See Gal. 3: 7, 27–29. To Israel the Sabbath is a perpetual covenant and sign. Ex. 31: 13, 16, 17. Israel was to continue so long as the sun, moon, and stars continued. Jer. 31: 35, 36. Israel is perpetuated in Christ. 1 Pet. 2: 9. Jesus now reigns over Christian Israel on the throne of grace (Heb. 4: 16); but at his second coming he will be seated on the throne of his glory (Matt. 25: 31), and will then rule over the whole house of Israel (including the spiritual seed) forever. Luke 1: 32, 33; Dan. 7: 14, 18, 27. And in the new earth the Sabbath will be kept by the redeemed people of God eternally. Isa. 66: 22, 23.

Says Mr. A: “It was a very pertinent recommendation made by Dr. John Wallas, of Oxford, that all seventh-day Sabbatarians should make a voyage around the world, ‘going out of the Atlantic Ocean westward by the Straits of Magellan to the East Indies, and then from the East returning by the Cape of Good Hope homeward, and let them keep their Saturday-Sabbath all the way. When they come home to England they will find their Saturday to fall on our Sunday, and they may thenceforth continue to observe their Saturday-Sabbath on the same day with us.’”

Well, we should doubtless enjoy the journey, and especially the excellent company. But, as a people, we happen to know, if he does not, that the day line is in the Pacific Ocean, crossing which we should change our reckoning, and dash his anticipations to the ground. We prefer, on the whole, to stay at home and study our Bibles, and let our Sunday friends try the experiment of going the other way around the world, thus bringing their so-called Christian Sabbath to correspond in point of time to the seventh-day, or Bible Sabbath.

Mr. A says, in referring to the first-day Sabbath, “This is the ‘rest that remaineth.’” But Dr. Adam Clarke says on the term “rest” in Heb. 4: 9, which Mr. A probably intended to quote, “It was not the rest of the Sabbath.” Thus we see that a Methodist editor and his colleagues are arrayed against a great Methodist commentator. Let them settle the dispute among themselves.

In his third paper, Mr. A endeavors to show that Jesus met with his disciples only on the first day of each week after his resurrection until his ascension, and, to make assertion good on a doubtful text, says that “after eight days” (John 20: 26) meant “the second first-day after the resurrection.” But it is with great brevity that he refers to the meeting at the Sea of Galilee (John 21: 1–14), evidently afraid to have it known that the disciples went fishing on Sunday, and that Jesus taught them how to catch fish. Jesus was seen of his disciples not on Sunday only, but “forty days” (see Clarke’s Com. on John 21: 14 and Acts 1: 3) before he ascended to heaven. See Acts 1: 3. Mr. A says the day of Pentecost was the seventh Sunday after the resurrection; but H. D. Hackett, D. D., professor of Biblical literature; Dr. Albert Barnes; Jennings, in “Jewish Antiquities;” Olshausen, a German commentator; and Dean Alford, all believe that the day of Pentecost fell that year on Saturday.

In one place Mr. A says that from the moment the resurrection occurred “the first day of the week became the only fit day for the celebration of the Sabbath of rest and joy;” and in another place, that the day of Pentecost “occurred immediately following the completed Israelitish Sabbath, or in other words the closed series of seventh-day Sabbaths.” Blessed period! with two weekly Sabbaths in juxtaposition from the resurrection to Pentecost. Mr. A further says that the example of Christ and the apostles proves that the first day of the week was hallowed as the Sabbath; and that “during the entire ministry of Paul,” the disciples, following the clearly indicated will of their Master, came together on the first day of the week to break bread and listen to the preaching of the gospel. Acts 20: 7.” He says also that Paul and “other distinguished ministers utterly ignored the seventh-day Sabbath, and kept the Lord’s day.” Will the reader again refer to Acts 17: 2; 16: 13; 18: 3, 4, 11; 13: 42, 44 for a refutation of Mr. A’s statement.

Eld. J. N. Andrews, in the introduction to his “Complete Testimony of the Fathers of the First Three Centuries of the Christian Era,” says: “The change of the Sabbath from the seventh day to the first is never mentioned in a single instance. They never term the first day the Christian Sabbath, nor do they treat it as a Sabbath of any kind. . . . But the writings of the Fathers furnish positive proof that the Sabbath was observed in the Christian Church down to the time when they wrote, and by no inconsiderable part of that body.” If the reader wishes to know how the Sabbath came to be changed, send to the Review Office for a three-cent tract entitled, “Who Changed the Sabbath.”

I believe the foregoing testimony sufficiently refutes Mr. A’s argument, and will therefore forbear to follow him further in his intricate mazes. I am glad, however, that the Sabbath question continues to be agitated. It becomes brighter by reason of the friction to which it is subjected. I close this review with the words of the psalmist, “It is time for thee, Lord, to work: for they have made void thy law.” Ps. 119: 126.

Grandville, Mich.