AdventAI

ALL FOR THE SABBATH.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 4., January 26, 1886

A CATHOLIC ARGUMENT IN THE MOUTH OF A PROTESTANT.

The apostle says, “We can do nothing against the truth, but for the truth.” So it almost seems that men can say nothing against the Sabbath, but for the Sabbath. Most of what they attempt to say against it is so transparently weak and so visibly destitute of both reason and Scripture, as really to be a support to it. Many an argument written ostensibly and intentionally against it, would be a very fair campaign document in its favor.

The following from the Christian at Work comes fairly under this head. A correspondent, finding nothing in the Scriptures to sustain the Sunday, but all to uphold the original seventh day, expresses her conviction accordingly to the editor of the paper above named, and asks his opinion. If his reply does not strengthen her convictions in favor of the seventh day, it will be because she is willing to sacrifice at a very low price some of that clearness of discernment which she manifests in her questions. The article reads as follows:—

“A correspondent writes to us with reference to an editorial in the Christian at Work of the 26th ultimo, on the Sabbath question, in which she pleads for the ‘observance of the Sabbath,’ that is, Saturday, the seventh day of the week. We quote:—

“1. I know some Christians tell us that Christ changed the Sabbath, but I find no authority for it anywhere in the Scriptures, but contrariwise. 2. I know Christ did away with the ceremonial and Jewish law, but not the decalogue, and I believe the ten commandments are as binding now as before the birth or resurrection of our Saviour. 3. I believe that ‘the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God,’ and that God blessed that day and hallowed it, and commanded us to keep it holy. Shall we not do it as Christians, and have the first day of the week for a rest and amusement day if the law so orders? I, with other Christians, have always kept the first day of the week, but cannot see that it is right. I should be much pleased to have a few words on the subject from the editor. A SEEKER OF TRUTH.”

“There is no doubt of the earnestness of our friend, and we have no doubt that she is the representative of many others. Let us very briefly state the case as we understand it: (1.) We quite agree with the writer that Christ did not change the Sabbath. Not only so, but neither did the apostles change it or announce any such change, indeed, they worshiped in the temple on Saturday. (2.) Christ did away with the ceremonial law, and all that is not universally moral may be included under that head. But are not the ten commandments in any part ceremonial? The first commandment properly prohibited the making of ‘any graven image or the likeness of anything.’ That is a distinct, separate command; the bowing down to such ‘likeness’ is another matter. Yet we carve statues, and even place them in our churches. Why?—Because that part of the decalogue no longer holds. In a way, it may be said to be ‘ceremonial’; it certainly was not universally ethical—intended to govern the life of to-day. The object for which the command was enacted—the prevention of the perpetuation of Egyptian idolatry—has passed; and with the passing away of the occasion, the law falls. (3.) So with the Sabbath. God commands a rest day; that is universally ethical. He mentions Saturday for popular convenience and uniformity. That is not universally ethical, and may be treated as ceremonial, to be abrogated or retained at pleasure. The early Christians celebrated worship and the communion every day at first. Gradually the days of such observance became fewer. As the distinction between Jews and Christians became more strongly marked, Saturday as the one rest day began to give way among Christians to Sunday, the day on which the Lord arose; so that the practice of the early Church has given us Sunday as our Sabbath. Therefore we accept it, believing its observance to be as acceptable to God as that of Saturday. Indeed, if we were living in Arabia, we might feel justified in observing Friday, the Mohammedan worship day, out of regard to their feelings and conscience, just as many Jews regard Sunday with us. It is the one day in seven, not Saturday or Sunday, that is the all-important fact. And it is right to accept Sunday and place one’s self in the pale of uniformity, and thus hold to that decency of order which the apostolic Church and the spirit of the gospel alike enjoin.”

It is perhaps appropriate enough that Catholic arguments should be used in behalf of a Catholic institution. What a humiliating position for a Protestant who has inscribed upon his banner, “The Bible and the Bible alone the rule of faith and practice,” to be engaged in defending a practice for which he is obliged to confess that no scrap of authority has come down to us from either Christ or his apostles in the form of legal enactment or apostolic injunction!

Advocates of the seventh-day Sabbath have long been wont to claim that the same argument with which the Protestant defends his Sunday, the Catholic could use, and did use, to defend his image worship. What shall we say now, when a Protestant comes out and volunteers a defense of Catholics on their own ground by claiming that that part of the commandment which forbids the making of images is ceremonial and no longer holds? In order that he may make out that part of the fourth commandment which he wishes to get rid of, to be also ceremonial and hence changeable at the will and caprice of men.

The head-center of the great apostasy in the Christian Church is the pope of Rome. Of him Paul said that he should endeavor to raise himself above all that is called God or that is worshiped. He has done this very thing in his attempt to change the Sabbath of the fourth commandment. Must we conclude that all those who attempt to defend this change, partake of the same spirit? It would seem so from the tone in which the editor of the Christian at Work replies to its correspondent. With all the liberty and flippancy with which he would treat a last year’s scrapbook, he takes hold of the law of the great Jehovah, and declares that this part is ceremonial, and that part has outlived the occasion for which it was given, and the Lord mentioned this part for convenience; and in the other item didn’t mean what he said, and that it is left to man to change such and such portions of it. When was he thus taken into the counsels of the Most High that he may thus freely set aside the letter of his law and construe it as he pleases?

Another fact that clearly reveals the spirit of the writer, though he may himself be scarcely conscious that he possesses such a spirit, is what he says about keeping the Sabbath in Arabia. If he were among Mohammedans, he would keep Friday for conscience’ sake. Then Mohammedans keep the Sabbath by observing Friday, as well as Christians keep it who observe the first day. But somehow no one must keep the seventh day. That of all days must be stricken from the Sabbatic calendar, though it is the only day that God himself has ever placed there. And the whole intent of the article is to dissuade that correspondent from keeping the seventh day.

If the Christian at Work really believes its own position, why did it not say to that correspondent, “Why, yes; if your conscience inclines you to observe the seventh day, keep it; you will be keeping the fourth commandment as much by that day as by any other; the commandment only requires one day in seven; and if you choose to obey it on that day, we bid you Godspeed.”

But do the seventh-part-of-time Sunday-keepers ever reason thus? Not they. On the other hand, while professing that all days are equal before the law, they fight the seventh day with tooth and nail. The intensity of bitterness and the strength of intolerance manifested against this day can be accounted for only on the ground that this is really the day which God requires, and that all forms of opposition to it are inspired by that malevolent being who would willingly sacrifice all truth, consistency, and candor, in its overthrow.