The Cleveland, Ohio, Plain Dealer of March 22, 1886, contains a sermon preached by a Catholic priest of that city, from which we copy the following extract. It is headed, “Man’s Duty to God: The Necessity of Religion—Protestantism Said to be No Longer a Living Issue:” —
“At the morning services in St. John’s Cathedral yesterday, Rt. Rev. Bishop Gilmour strongly condemned the action of the House of Representatives in passing the free school book bill, and advised that steps be taken to prevent the enactment of the law. Rev. D. J. Stafford officiated at the vesper service, and after concluding the service at the altar, preached a sermon on the ‘Necessity of Religion.’ He said:—
“‘When I was first ordered by my superiors to give this series of sermons, I intended to speak of the dissolution of Protestantism; but on second thought, Protestantism being dead, and no longer a living issue, I elected to speak of the necessity of religion.’”
The term “Protestant” as referred to in the above and defined by Webster, is, “One who protests against the doctrines and practices of the Roman Catholic Church; one who adheres to the doctrines of the Reformation.” The above statement of the Romish priest, D. J. Stafford, if correctly reported, is enough to cause the blood of every true Christian and lover of liberty to boil. Could the fifty millions who were put to death by the Romish Church, rise from their graves, the world would know that Protestantism is not dead. Their blood, bones, and flesh (like Abel’s) cry from the Waldensian valleys and mountains of Piedmont, from the dungeon, and from every den of cruelty where that power has slain its victims. But alas! we are compelled to admit that the statement of the Romish priest of Cleveland, Ohio, is the truth, so far as the mass of the popular churches of the present day is concerned. It is a common remark among professed Protestants, “The Catholics are not so bad, after all;” “there are many good Christian people among them,” etc. They are spoken of as “one of the agencies by which the world is to be Christianized,” and as “laboring in one common cause with the Protestant branches of the Catholic Church.” When such expressions are common in public and in print, no wonder that the Catholic Church believes that Protestantism “is no longer a living issue.”
A few weeks since, at a meeting of the Ministerial Association of Akron, Ohio, a proposition was made by some of their members to send for Father O’Connor, the converted Catholic priest of New York City, to deliver a lecture on Romanism in their city. It was voted down by a large majority of that professed body of Protestant ministers! The reason given for voting against the proposition was that there was too much of a feeling of union existing between the Protestants and Catholics to allow of such a move! Such a record from a Protestant ministerial association! when the Catholic Church is to-day the same she ever has been, in heart and purpose,—opposed to every principle of religious freedom; and is the same beast of cruelty, showing her iron teeth of death, and only held from her former work of persecution by the chain wrought out by the early Protestant Reformers, who suffered and died to gain the freedom and truth this Ministerial Association is professedly sworn to defend and maintain by every principle of honor. Who can doubt that “Babylon is fallen, is fallen”?
The same body of ministers sent a delegation to urge the Catholic priest of Akron, Ohio, to come and join them in the common cause of enforcing the “Christian Sabbath” (Sunday). At death, the dignitaries of the Catholic Church are eulogized by those who bear the name of Protestant, as great and good men who have passed into their peaceful reward! No marvel that the power with “eyes like the eyes of a man” can see that Protestantism is dead so far as the popular churches are concerned! From the popular stand-point of to-day, we ask, Why do not Protestants and Catholics unite?
1. The doctrine of the Reformation was, “The Bible, the Bible alone,” from which their faith and practice must be derived and sustained. But “fables” and the “traditions” of men have taken the place of the word of God. There are but few to-day who will defend their faith and practice by the Bible alone. Tradition is exalted above the Bible in many important points of faith and practice. In this the Protestant Church has really given away the living issue between them and the mother Church. In the Catholic “Catechism of Christian Religion” this question is asked:—
“Is the authority of tradition equal to that of the Scriptures?”
“Ans.—It is God who speaks in both cases, and of course the authority of the former is equal to that of the latter.”
In the “Catholic Christian Instructed” we have many quotations from the Fathers to sustain “prayers for the dead,” “purgatory,” etc.
“Ques. How is it proved that sacrifice can be offered for the souls in purgatory?”
“Ans. By the testimony of the Fathers of the Church.” Then follow the names of Tertullian, St. Cyprian, St. Chrysostom, St. Augustine, etc.
“Ques. Had the ancients these different modes of offering the holy sacrifice?”
“Ans. St. Justin Martyr mentions the order of solemn mass. Tertullian does the same. It is found in the apostolic institutions. The practices of low mass are equally ancient. See Tertullian, St. Cyprian, Eusebius, St. Augustine. See, in a word, all the Fathers of the early and pure ages.”
Such authority from the Fathers can be greatly extended to sustain every doctrine that Romanism has fostered to curse the Christian religion. Our grandfathers a few centuries past raised the cry of protest against being bound by such authority when it conflicted with the word of God, and said, “The Bible, the Bible alone, must be our authority.” But the degenerate Protestant Church of to-day has searched in vain for Bible proof for their practice of keeping Sunday for the Christian Sabbath, with some other doctrines they hold; therefore they are forced to advance in the reformation, or adopt the Roman Catholic rule expressed by St. Augustine, “When any doctrine or practice of the Church cannot be traced to its origin, and no time can be pointed out when it commenced, it is, therefore, it must be, grounded on apostolic tradition.” Hence when the Protestant Church brings forward Ignatius, Irenæus, Justin Martyr, Chrysostom, Tertullian, Augustine, and others for their authority for keeping Sunday (as they do), they have adopted the same authority that proves all the doctrines of the Catholic Church to be equal to, if not above, the Bible; therefore the only “living issue” upon which Protestantism was founded has been surrendered, rather than to advance in the increasing light of the Reformation. Thus a fallen church has become drunken with the false doctrines of the mother Church, and knows it not. Isa. 29:9–14; Rev. 17:1–5.
2. The Protestants believe, the same as the Catholics, in the inherent immortality of the soul and conscious state of the dead.
3. Certainly they stand a unit on the Sabbath question, so far as the day is concerned. The Protestant world has indorsed the day that the Romish Church “substituted” in place of the Bible Sabbath of the fourth commandment. The Northwestern Christian Advocate, of Chicago, Ill., said: “We warn them (the opposers of the measure) further, that in the contest for the Sabbath (Sunday), it may so fall out that Roman Catholicism in America, and Protestantism will be found side by side; for neither of these will consent to be marshaled by German atheists.” There is no doubt about their standing side by side on this great issue.
4. Temperance, divorce, and marriage laws are agitating the Protestant world in connection with the Sabbath question. These three are the great moral questions looming up before the nation at present. The rigid discipline of the Catholic Church in never permitting divorce, has been a subject of much favorable comment by Protestants in contrast with the loose laws and practice of divorce among their own denominations. The said reformers on the above issues have had no doubts about the position of the Romish Church on the Sabbath and divorce questions, but they have been anxiously waiting to know what the position of the Catholic Church would be on the temperance question. The Akron Beacon of April 1, 1886, says: “A letter from the papal See to the Plenary Council held at Baltimore, urges total abstinence on the part of all Catholics. It bids Catholic liquor-sellers choose a more honorable means of making a living.” Such recommendations as these from the acknowledged infallible pope, must have weight among the subjects of that Church. The Protestant world applauds the pope for these words. Who can fail to see that the platform of the Romish Church and the one upon which the popular Protestant Church stands are so nearly alike that the priest of Cleveland, Ohio, was justified in saying that Protestantism is dead, and is “no longer a living issue.” The Plain Dealer says that the sermon was a “scholarly effort.”
How much longer shall we have to wait to see the Protestant world reach her hand across the fast-closing chasm, to join with the Romish Church, and form an alliance to make the image to the beast? Thank God, the Reformation is not a failure, though the popular Church cease to protest! God will have a faithful few, who will not worship the beast nor his image, nor receive his mark in their hand or forehead. The protest will be carried on by those who keep the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus (Rev. 14:9–15), till the beast is given to the burning flame, and the loyal shout the victory in the kingdom of God. Dan. 7:11; 2 Thess. 2:8; Rev. 15:2, 3. The world must be lightened with the glory of the last message of protest (Rev. 18:1–5) against “that man of sin.” Let us share in the battle, and triumph in the victory. R. A. UNDERWOOD.