A GREEK FALSEHOOD

3%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 25, 1886

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 21.

Read the full edition

A GREEK FALSEHOOD.

IGNORANCE OR DISHONESTY? WHICH?

(Concluded.)
Now let us see if this day on which they came to the sepulcher is also called “the Sabbath,” as the new critics so lustily assert. The words on which they make this claim, as will be seen by the foregoing translation, are “eis mian sabbatōn.” Let us analyze this construction.
Eis is simply a preposition meaning to, toward, or into. It is regularly followed by the accusative case, as we have in the following word “mian,” which is in the accusative.
Mian is an adjective, from the nominative masculine heis, which is the first of the cardinal numbers, meaning “one.” (By a Hebraism it is here used as an ordinal, signifying “first.”) Adjectives in Greek have a declension the same as nouns; and a difference in gender, number, and case is indicated by a change of form, the same as with nouns. A presentation of the declension of the numeral adjective “one,” in the singular number, will show the reader at once where the form “mian” is found. The adjective is declined as follows:—
Masculine gender. Feminine gender. Neuter gender.
Nominative case, εἷς (heis) μία (mia) ἕν (hen)
Genitive ἑνός (henos) μιᾶς (mias) ἑνός (henos)
Dative ἐνί (heni) μιᾷ (mia) ἐνί (heni)
Accusative ἕνα (hena) μίαν (mian) ἕν (hen)
From this the reader will see that the form mian is found only in that column which marks the feminine gender, and in the line which gives the accusative case. Therefore we say of mian, that it is a numeral adjective, feminine gender, singular number, and accusative case. There must be some noun either expressed or understood with which it agrees, and that must be a noun of the feminine gender, singular number, and accusative case, which caused the adjective to be so written; for adjectives must agree with their nouns in gender, number, and case.
One word more remains to be considered, and that is sabbatōn (σαββάτων), a word which our translators render “of the week,” but which the new critics say should be called “Sabbath,” because it is the word which is generally translated “Sabbath.” There are two different words rendered “Sabbath” in the New Testament. The first is sabbaton (short “o” in last syllable), a noun of the second declension; the second is a form in the dative plural sabbasi, as if from the nominative sabbat, which would be a noun of the third declension. But both words are of the neuter gender.
The word generally used in the New Testament is sabbaton in some of its forms; and it is used both in the singular and the plural; but when it is used in the plural form (with the exception of such passages as Acts 17:2 and Col. 2:16, where it has a plural signification,) it means just the same as if it had been written in the singular. See Robinson’s Greek Lexicon. The forms for the nominative and genitive, in the singular and plural, are the following: nominative singular, sabbaton (σάββατον), genitive singular, sabbatou (σαββάτου); nominative plural, sabbata (σάββατα), genitive plural, sabbatōn (σαββάτων). The reader will note that the genitive plural is distinguished by having the long “o,” omega (ω), in the last syllable instead of the short “o,” as in the nominative singular.
In what case and number is the word in Matt. 28:1?—It is in the genitive case, plural number, and so it is in every one of the eight texts where the first day of the week is named, except Mark 16:9, where it is in the genitive singular (sabbatou). What is the relation indicated by the genitive case?—It shows that relation which is expressed in English by the word “of,” so that whatever definition we give to sabbatōn, it must have the word “of” before it. If we call it “Sabbath,” it must be, “of the Sabbath;” if we call it “week,” it must be, “of the week.”
Now what must be the definition of sabbatōn in the case before us? If we say it is “Sabbath,” meaning just one day, then we have the expression, “the first of the Sabbath.” The first what of the Sabbath? It cannot be translated “the first Sabbath;” for, as we have seen, the word “of” must come in before the word “Sabbath;” and further, the adjective mian (by a Hebraism used as an ordinal, the first) cannot belong to Sabbath; for it does not agree with it in any particular, mian being of the feminine gender, singular number, and accusative case, while sabbatōn is of the neuter gender, plural number, and genitive case!
Before following sabbatōn further, let us dispose of mian, and our way will then be still clearer. There is no word expressed with which the adjective mian agrees, hence there must be some word understood, and to be supplied, to bring out the full sense of the passage. What can that word be?—There is only one which can be supplied, and that is hēmeran, accusative singular of the feminine noun hēmera, “day.” Hence Greenfield in his Greek Testament, after the adjective “first,” in all the eight texts, refers to the margin, where he says, “supply hēmera [day].” So in all these passages we have “first day” as a fixed fact. But first day of what?
We now come back to sabbatōn, which we are gravely told means “Sabbath” in these passages. Then we have “the first day of the Sabbath;” but as the Sabbath consists of only one day, we have “the first day of one day”! We have charity enough for our friends to believe that this is greater nonsense than even they will be willing to father; but they must accept it or abandon their position.
As it must now be apparent to all that we cannot give sabbatōn in these passages the definition of “Sabbath,” the question remains as to how it shall be translated. Does it ever mean “week,” referring to the whole seven days? and can it mean so here? If it can, then all difficulty is removed, the Greek which Matthew, Mark, Luke, John, and Paul have given us is vindicated, and a clear and intelligible idea is expressed; namely, “the first day of the week.”
Conclusive evidence to show that sabbatōn in these instances does mean “week” is all that is further called for in this argument; and this can easily be given.
Looking in the lexicons, under the word sabbatōn, we find the following definitions:—
Greenfield, in his New Testament Lexicon, defines it first as “the Sabbath, the seventh day, singular and plural,” and secondly, “a period of seven days, a week, singular and plural. Matt. 28:1; Mark 16:9, et al.”
Pickering, in his Comprehensive Lexicon of the Greek Language, defines the word thus: “A cessation from labor, rest, the Sabbath, a day of rest; by synecdoche, a week. Mark 16:9; Luke 18:12; Matt. 28:1,” etc.
Bagster’s Greek Lexicon says: “Properly, cessation from labor, rest; the Jewish Sabbath, both in the sing. and pl.; a week, sing. and pl., Matt. 28:1; Mark 16:9, et al.”
Liddell and Scott’s Greek-English Lexicon says: “The Hebrew Sabbath, i. e., rest; hence the seventh day, or day of rest. 2. A week. N. T.”
Gesenius, in his Hebrew Lexicon, under shabbath (שַׁבָּת) the equivalent of the Greek sabbaton, says: “4. Sometimes a sabbath is nearly i. q. a week. Lev. 23:15, 16. Here the seven complete sabbaths are parallel to the ‘seven weeks’ of Deut. 16:9.” He says the Chaldee word for Sabbath also means “week.”
Robinson, in his Greek and English Lexicon of the New Testament, gives as the second definition of sabbaton, “2. By metonymy, a sabbath, put for the interval ‘from Sabbath to Sabbath;’ hence a se’nnight, week; so espec. Luke 18:12, nēsteuō dis tou sabbatou [I fast twice in the sabbath, that is, in the week]. Elsewhere only after numerals marking the days of the week. Mark 16:9, prōtē hēmera sabbatou. Plur. Matt. 28:1, eis mian sabbatōn. Mark 16:2; Luke 24:1; John 20:1, 19; Acts 20:7; 1 Cor. 16:2. . . . In the Talmudists the days of the week are written אחד בשבת, שני בשבת, שלישי בשבת, i. e., the first, second, third day in the Sabbath (week); see Lightfoot, Hor. Heb. in Matt. 28:1. Comp. Ideler Handb. der Chronol. I., p. 481.”
The Encyclopedia of Religious Knowledge, article “Week,” says:—
“The enumeration of the days of the week commenced at Sunday. Saturday was the last, or seventh, and was the Hebrew Sabbath, or day of rest. The Egyptians gave to the days of the week the same names that they assigned to the planets. From the circumstance that the Sabbath was the principal day of the week, the whole period of seven days was likewise called shabat in Syriac, shabta; in the N. T., sabbaton and sabbata. The Jews, accordingly, in designating the successive days of the week, were accustomed to say, the first day of the sabbath, that is, of the week; the second day of the sabbath, that is, Sunday, Monday, etc. Mark 16:2, 9; Luke 24:9; John 20:1, 19.”
Cruden says:—
“Sabbath is also taken for the whole week. Luke 18:12. I fast twice in the week: in the Greek it is, I fast twice in the sabbath.”
Bloomfield in his Greek N. T. says this fast was on the second and fifth days of the week; but our friends would have the old Pharisee fast twice on the same day, which must of course have been between meals!
Nevins, in his Biblical Antiquities, p. 174, says:—
“The seventh day, which we term Saturday, was styled among them (the Jews) the Sabbath, that is, the day of rest. And because this was the most important day of all the week, the whole week came to be called from its name, a sabbath; whence the other days were called also the first day of the sabbath, the second day of the sabbath, and so on in their order.”
The Union Bible Dictionary, art. “Week,” says:—
“The Jews called Sunday one of the sabbath, that is, the first day of the week. Monday was two of the sabbath.”
Calmet says:—
“Sabbathum is also taken for the whole week.”
Young in his new Concordance, under the word “week,” says:—
“A week (from Sabbath to Sabbath) sabbata.” He then refers to Matt. 28:1; Mark 16:2; Luke 24:1; John 20:1, 19; Acts 20:7; 1 Cor. 16:2. Again he says:—
“A week (from Sabbath to Sabbath) sabbaton,” and then refers to Mark 16:9 and Luke 18:12.
But one more query can arise on this subject; namely, inasmuch as the same word, and the same form of it (sabbaton), is used to signify both the Sabbath and the week, how is it to be determined when it has the signification of “week”? The answer is, Whenever it is preceded by a numeral adjective specifying the day of the week, and agreeing with “day” understood. Whenever sabbaton is used in such a construction, following such an adjective, it cannot with any sense be translated by any other word than “week.” And this is exactly the construction we find in every one of the eight first-day texts. So easy is it to tell why it should be so translated and when. And the authorities for such a rendering are certainly sufficiently weighty and abundant.
It would not have been necessary to enter into this vindication of the common rendering and the revised version of these passages, had not persons of late years taken counsel of their ignorance to find some objection to the Sabbath of the Lord. We trust they may be led to see the folly of their course; or, if that cannot be, that the common people may become so enlightened that said teachers will find no following.